5 ms·
I have one issue with the widespread use of psychiatric drugs. As laypeople, we readily recognise the social and cognitive basis of much of what is called ment
by jdietrich 17y ago
I have one issue with the widespread use of psychiatric drugs.
As laypeople, we readily recognise the social and cognitive basis of much of what is called mental illness. We clearly see that when our friends are overworked and in debt, they become anxious. We see people lose their job and become depressed. Anecdotally, I struggle to recall a single instance of anyone I know experiencing significant distress with no clear social or cognitive reason.
As part of the medicalisation of our thoughts and emotions, we seem to have discarded the notion that we personally can change how we feel, by changing how we think and the way we live our lives. We have no model for how to think about our emotions in the broader context of our lives without involving someone with a certificate and a nice office.
To me it seems absurd that much of the medical establishment would regard the unhappiness a recently bereaved person as a chemical imbalance or a symptom of illness, but there are no shortage of references to the use of anti-depressants to treat "bereavement related depression".
I can't speak for anything beyond my own experience, but I have been diagnosed with a catalogue of mental illnesses by a variety of highly trained professionals. It turned out that my life was just really crappy and I needed to sort myself out. I felt hopeless because I really didn't have any reason to hope. I lacked energy because I had nothing to do. I felt nervous and restless because I was living in a shitty set of circumstances. A few significant but simple changes to my lifestyle and mindset suceeded where endless "treatment" failed.
It occurs to me that it is possible that we are treating symptoms without addressing causes. We rarely treat physical pain with painkillers alone, but usually act to resolve the cause of the pain wherever possible. It seems illogical to me that someone can become depressed as a result of a specific event in their lives, be prescribed antidepressants and continue to take those drugs for many months or years, without anyone thinking to address the issue that precipitated the negative thoughts and feelings in the first place.
I suggest that those advocating SSRIs as a cureall for anxiety and depression take a closer look at the recent metastudies into their efficacy. From the largest and most recent (JAMA. 2010;303:47-53):
""The magnitude of benefit of antidepressant medication compared with placebo ... may be minimal or nonexistent, on average, in patients with mild or moderate symptoms. For patients with very severe depression, the benefit of medications over placebo is substantial.""
For all but the most severe depression, SSRIs are less effective than sunbathing or jogging. Given the quite substantial risk of side effects, especially amongst the young, I can't help but be dismayed at how widespread SSRI use is.
Looking at the healthcare debate in the US, the elephant in the room is that USians consume vastly more medicine than anyone else in the world but see no real improvement in their health as a consequence. From my perspective as a cynical Brit, USians seem to have an almost mystical faith in the power of medicine and seem to have medicalised a dizzying array of things which most of the rest of the world does not consider disease. British dentistry is often the butt of jokes amongst USians and considered substandard, but in fact it is of a very high quality. The difference is that British dental standards are based on function rather than aesthetics. We tend to perceive American dentistry as being vain and neurotic, the maxillofacial equivalent of spinning rims. What we would consider artificially straight and white, many USians would consider the lower bound of normal.
USians are literally bankrupting themselves on healthcare spending, but live shorter lives than Cubans, who spend 1/25th what USians do but lead healthier lifestyles. The United States has the world's highest rate of incapacity due to mental illness and the fastest growth in the rate of mental illness, despite prescribing more psychiatric medications than anywhere else in the world. I invite the reader to draw their own conclusions.
- jgg 17y ago>To me it seems absurd that much of the medical establishment would regard the unhappiness a recently bereaved person as a chemical imbalance or a symptom of illness It doesn't seem so absurd when you realize that they make a lot of money that way. I agree with your post though. The marketing agencies for drug companies want you to feel as though being uncomfortable for any amount of time means something is wrong with you. It doesn't help that (in the United States at least) there is a very large consumer culture which is based around an intellectually-unhealthy ideal, which, I think, makes people deeply unhappy. Thus, when people realize what is wrong with the world around them, they feel extremely uncomfortable and are quickly herded into the category of "mentally ill" rather than being allowed to face what is troubling them. Depression is very much a fad disorder, like ADHD and Asperger's syndrome (much to the dismay of people who suffer from them legitimately, no doubt).
- Alex3917 17y ago"To me it seems absurd that much of the medical establishment would regard the unhappiness a recently bereaved person as a chemical imbalance or a symptom of illness" Reminds me of a quote, "The serotonin theory of depression is comparable to the masturbatory theory of insanity." -David Healy
- pw0ncakes 17y agoAmerican society has a high rate of mental illness because, due to some horrible choices in how to build our society and economy, our society is literally breaking down, and because our lifestyles are very unhealthy. In that regard, I'm not talking about high fructose corn syrup or preservatives-- which are mild as far as unhealthy things go-- so much as long commutes, withered social networks, a geography of alienation, and a work culture that expects even average Americans to make sacrifices for work that only make sense for the most ambitious 2-5 percent. The meager social safety net and lack of universal healthcare also creates an environment where crippling mental illness are more common, due to the feedback loops that turn a mild "rough patch" into a full-scale nervous breakdown (once the job is lost, health insurance lapses, medical bills pile up, et cetera). Our problem with mental illness in this country is because we're an unhealthy society, and we're so unhealthy as a society that throwing drugs and money at the problem won't substantially help, but that doesn't mean that the drugs are causing the problem. There is a difference between clinical depression (pathology) and misery, which is often a result of bad circumstances, and even in a bad situation there's no benefit or justification being depressed per se, but that distinction is mainly clinical. A lot of people are miserable for circumstantial reasons, and no amount of medication can fix that (without damaging the person's mind). If you give an appropriate dose of an antidepressant to a person who is in the sort of horrible circumstances that are common for the US poor, you might stop the panic attacks and crippling depressions, but you still have a person who's likely to be miserable. We do, of course, overdiagnose mental illness in the US. I know an eccentric but essentially normal person who was committed as a prank (Manhattan rich kids are the sort of sick fucks who would find this funny) and ended up in a mental hospital for 3 weeks (which is illegal, because you can only be held for 72 hours, and that only if you're in a state that represents direct danger to yourself or others). He was placed on all sorts of inappropriate medications, lost his job, and had more mental problems after the ordeal than before it. This sort of thing has more to do with our culture than with the drugs themselves.