6 ms·
I have to partially disagree with that. Calling PGP an utter failure is an understatement. Just like calling a cat a small tiger. PGP is possibly the WORST ex
by user5994461 10y ago
I have to partially disagree with that.
Calling PGP an utter failure is an understatement. Just like calling a cat a small tiger.
PGP is possibly the WORST experience in usability for any well known software that ever lived.
This thing should be taught in courses for decades to come as how to fail a product by 1) having no UI 2) no integrations with anything 3) zero usability 4) not even trying to give a fuck about normal users 5) in fact, not even trying to make it possible to use for advanced users.
---
You want signed email & identities. It's simple.
Just get the national government to distribute RSA USB keys to every citizen. Then they can use them on public government websites (taxes & jobs stuff) to confirm poeple's identities, just plug in the key. Quick and simple. (And that's not incompatible with ALSO asking for a password that was send in a different paper letter. 2FA-style.).
Then later, citizens can sign the emails they send to everyone with gmail/hotmail because they'll add the feature to recognize the national USB identity key, now that there are X millions people using it.
- cdelsolar 10y agoReally? Which national government? Why wouldn't they backdoor it?
- user5994461 10y agoAny government who wants to bring 2FA to its citizens. Shipping a national backdoor is an entirely different topic. Please focus on the use case at hands.
- spenczar5 10y agoI think that issue is central. You're describing a scheme with a central, trusted authority distributing keys. The question is, what's a central authority we can all trust? I think many people wouldn't trust any government. At that point, the design crumbles.
- user5994461 10y agoWell. You trust your government to issue national ID card and e-passports already.
- narrowrail 10y agoI'm guessing you are from Europe because the idea of distrusting your government appears to be really foreign to you. According to Wikipedia, "The passport possession rate of the U.S. was approximately 39% of the population in 2015."
- dom0 10y ago> distrusting your government appears to be really foreign to you. That "U.S. Government" collecting, indexing and analyzing all data of any citizen must be an entirely different entity from the "United States Government" after all.
- user5994461 10y agoYeah I am. I guess that makes sense. People in the UK don't have any "national ID card". Must be a culture thing. I guess that makes sense. That's why I have to go through fucking stupid private background check agencies for everything in the UK.
- madgar 10y agoDo you think only 39% of Americans because the other 61% are all terrified of their government? Or might it be because international travel is a luxury not everyone can afford?
- serge2k 10y agoThe US has strange hangups about national IDs.
- nickik 10y agoJust because I have and use such passport does not mean I think its a good idea or trust it completly.
- marssaxman 10y agoWhy the fuck would you ever insert a government-provided USB key into any computer you actually cared about, much less actually use any government-provided key? The national government is the prime adversary. I mean, seriously, Alice and Bob want to communicate, and your solution is that they should use Eve as a courier!??
- eropple 10y agoFWIW: your point--and it's a good one--is better made without the yelling. And to answer you, though I don't speak for the person you were relying to: the U.S. government isn't even in my threat model. If the Eye of Sauron points my way, I lose. And so, given that as a prior, a universally trustable third party is not a bad idea. The implementation might totally suck (and I think it's a better practice to have a wide set of vendors and making the acquisition of such a key subsidized, rather than directly provided, by the .gov), but the central point of trust doesn't, and it isn't inherently a problem for it to be state-operated.
- dmoy 10y agoJames Mickens has an awesome point roughly along these lines. It is one of my all time favorite lines about security up there with some Gene Spafford stuff. """ If your adversary is the Mossad, YOU'RE GONNA DIE AND THERE'S NOTHING THAT YOU CAN DO ABOUT IT. The Mossad is not intimidated by the fact that you employ https:// https://. If the Mossad wants your data, they're going to use a drone to replace your cellphone with a piece of uranium that's shaped like a cellphone, and when you die of tumors filled with tumors, they're going to hold a press conference and say "It wasn't us" as they wear t-shirts that say "IT WAS DEFINITELY US," and then they're going to buy all of your stuff at your estate sale so that they can directly look at the photos of your vacation instead of reading your insipid emails about them. """
- marssaxman 10y agoI take your point - though I was not intending to yell, but to represent my state of alarm and bafflement, as the original poster's worldview is both alien and frightening. It's as though someone were circulating one of those "modest proposals" to improve automobile security by installing a sharp metal spike on the center of every steering wheel, without realizing that these things are supposed to be jokes. A universally trustable third party key provider might not be a bad idea in itself, but a national government - any national government, I was not specifically referring to the US government - seems about as non-trustworthy as any third party gets. To my way of thinking, the whole point of cryptography is to allow the weak to protect themselves from the powerful, and giving the organization which is at least nominally the most powerful agent operating in one's area the opportunity to poison your crypto before you even begin seems... counterproductive.
- at612 10y ago> Just get the national government to distribute RSA USB keys to every citizen. I lived in a country that did exactly that. And it was a disaster. The keys were trivially easy to steal, even by accident (personal experience here), and you still have the same trust problem as before, except that with a central authority now you do not have as much control. I have also used the electronic-signature-comes-with-your-ID-card thing, and it was a similar disaster, with dodgy drivers and half-arsed crypto implementations in common software. E.g., try using the same token in Firefox and Thunderbird (or anything else) at the same time. PGP is fine. It's just that proper security is not easy. And the same applies in the physical world as much as in computing.
- user5994461 10y agoIt's 2FA, it's doesn't rely ONLY on the key for authentication and a token can be revoked easy if stolen. The implementation and the technology has some challenges to be executed. Just like everyone tech projects, that doesn't have GooMicroZon people. Nothing special ^^
- ryukafalz 10y ago>The keys were trivially easy to steal, even by accident So distribute keys on smart cards that don't allow you to export the key. This is what Estonia does, and - concerns about their election infosec aside - it seems to work pretty well.
- at612 10y ago> So distribute keys on smart cards that don't allow you to export the key That's what I covered in the second paragraph. :-) The thing is, both those implementations were a disaster from either a technological or a security point of view. We're not even getting into whether a central source of trust is a good idea or not (you will look at the state of HTTPS and make up your own mind on that). So, to repeat, proper security is hard.
- vic-traill 10y agoInteresting. If you don't mind me asking, what country?
- user5994461 10y agoGuys. It doesn't have to be state controlled okay? It can be a SV startup if you prefer :D The government is just an example because they already handle ID for everyone, and they need it to provide their services. It makes sense for them to go digital at some point and to guarantee the ID. I didn't know that Americans were so anti-American ^^
- narrowrail 10y agoBeing distrustful of your government is completely "American." Having the U.S. federal government issuing an ID that is mandatory would make many in the U.S. raise a huge stink.
- XorNot 10y agoGood thing that social security number thing never took off I suppose.
- caf 10y agoIt's a bit of a Continental European view that "they [the national government] already handle ID for everyone". Universal government ID isn't historically the case in countries descended from the UK.
- drivingmenuts 10y agoGo read up on the whole Number-Of-The-Beast thing and mix that with a heavily Christian-influenced view of politics (which is there, even in the politics of not-particularly Christian people). We are talking about a country where some people view having a Social Security Number as a Very Bad Thing. Don't even get me started on the Hillbama-gunna-take-er-gerns crowd. They'll be blaming Obama for whatever well into the next decade. We are a majorly paranoid society, for no particular good specific reason that I can see.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dcposch 10y agoThe first half of what you said, everything about PGP usability, is on point. The second half--the federal government as centralized national PKI, generating everyone's private keys for them--is hilariously terrible. I can almost hear Moxie, Matt Green, Trevor Perrin, and every infosec researcher and crypto engineer and privacy advocate facepalming in unison.
- matheusd 10y agoBrazil is heading in that direction. Every single corporation here and even freelance service workers are required by law to have a key/certificate pair to be able to do file taxes. Pretty much every single commercial transaction is signed with a certificate. It is not yet required for every individual citizen to have one, but everything points to that happening at some time in the future.
- jcranmer 10y ago> Just get the national government to distribute RSA USB keys to every citizen. Then they can use them on public government websites (taxes & jobs stuff) to confirm poeple's identities, just plug in the key. Quick and simple. (And that's not incompatible with ALSO asking for a password that was send in a different paper letter. 2FA-style.). Estonia does provide S/MIME certificates for every citizen, although I've been told that they're not particularly heavily used. Between Estonia and the DoD, there's a few million users of S/MIME. Whereas PGP has a few tens of thousands of users. It's clear which product won out in the marketplace.