5 ms·
Everyone I know with a PhD has asserted that it is 99% about being willing to slog through the years required to get the work done. That seems to suggest that t
by pc86 10y ago
Everyone I know with a PhD has asserted that it is 99% about being willing to slog through the years required to get the work done. That seems to suggest that the only difference (or most of the difference) between an average person and someone with a PhD is that the PhD just... took the time to get a PhD.
- metaphorm 10y agothat's what they assert when discussing it in polite company. perhaps there's a difference between what people say to others and what is really true?
- krapht 10y agoThen I'll say it anonymously as a former graduate student who left academia? For getting a PhD at any tier 2 or lower school, it is sufficient to work hard and be reasonably intelligent.
- metaphorm 10y agogetting a PhD is just a credential. that's a pretty weak measure of success. I was referring to public statements made by "famously successful" people.
- laichzeit0 10y agoTake every non-trivial side project you ever worked on and calculate the percentage you completed. Not half ass completed, but actually completed completed. Like you commented everything, wrote documentation, put it on Github, have decent test coverage, etc. Or how many Coursera courses did you sign up (with the real intent of actually finishing) vs how many did you _actually_ finish, doing all the homework, getting a really good grade? Employers look for people with degrees because it's very good estimate for "this person can finish shit" for this very reason. To say PhD is "just a credential" and has no predictive capabilities in terms of being "successful" I think is being disingenuous.
- metaphorm 10y agoI didn't say it has no predictive capabilities. You said that. Is that what you think? Because it's not what I think. I said a credential alone is a pretty weak measure of success. It might be a very strong measure of potential for future success. Do you see the difference?
- smcl 10y agoYou need to get onto the PhD programme in the first place - meaning you'd probably need a good degree and some sort of funding - which does select reasonably well for ability. There's gonna be exceptions however (people who are otherwise capable but lack either of those, or people who are not the smartest but have managed to secure both)