3 ms·
"So how did arguably the most popular idea on the internet end up on the scientific ash heap? For that matter, how could such questionable research migrate from
by mcguire 10y ago
"So how did arguably the most popular idea on the internet end up on the scientific ash heap? For that matter, how could such questionable research migrate from a journal to a viral video to a best seller, circulating for years, retweeted and forwarded and praised by millions, with almost no pushback?"
That's easy.
1. Videos and books aren't peer reviewed. In fact, books and videos by scientists usually are not even about the science. They are about self promotion.
2. Peer review isn't the gold standard of truth. At some level, it's political. At another, it's just three or four people arguing about what they believe.
And don't forget...
0. A single paper has roughly as much chance of being wrong as of being right, even without methodological issues. Which all research has.
But also...
-1. The power pose thing told people something they wanted to hear. Piltdown man and cold fusion did too. And that recent thing with random cells + lemon juice -> stem cells.
- tantalor 10y agoThe lemon juice -> stem cells thing: http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2014/01/29/268171016/a-little-acid-turns-mouse-blood-into-brain-heart-and-stem-cells http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2014/01/29/26817101... And a critique: https://researchtheheadlines.org/2014/02/10/how-not-to-report-a-major-discovery-in-stem-cell-science/ https://researchtheheadlines.org/2014/02/10/how-not-to-repor...
- mcguire 10y agoTrue, I referred to the description in the popular press. :-) On the other hand, the more nuanced versions appeared breathlessly in all of the scientific news outlets I frequented at the time it was published. As a complete non-biologist, it definitely sounded too good to be true; I was unsurprised when it was retracted a few months later, even without knowing all the antics involved.
- francoisdevlin 10y agoThe fact that the presenter is a beautiful, well dressed woman speaking at a commercial venue certainly helped this get popular. TED is here to make a buck...
- jmde 10y agoBingo. The fact this is one of the two most popular TED talks says volumes about TED, and how to interpret TED vis-a-vis the broader scientific community.
- trhway 10y ago>The fact that the presenter is a beautiful, well dressed woman speaking at a commercial venue certainly helped this get popular. imagine if additionally such a woman also had heavyweights like Kissinger, Shultz and future DOD secretary on the board of her enterprise... It could have easily get into like almost 10B valuation.