4 ms·
The literacy idea is a good one. I was mystified by the description of the tasks being basically an IQ test or cognition test or math and logic test tangential
by VLM 10y ago
The literacy idea is a good one. I was mystified by the description of the tasks being basically an IQ test or cognition test or math and logic test tangentially involving a computer as a topic and shockingly the result of predictable IQ test results being that computer user interfaces suck, which is pretty hilarious.
"I failed my standardized tests math section because the user interface of a #2 graphite pencil is poor." No, its because you're not good at math, the problem isn't the pencil. Half the population has to be below the median, after all, and we design civilization to make sure evolution doesn't cull anyone, so ...
I am kinda old and I can assure you that plenty of people were completely incompetent at using a physical card catalog (kind of like a printed out google search form, where an old fashioned library used to kinda be a printed out internet, back before libraries became internet cafes without coffee and also turned into daycares). Inability to search for things intelligently is not a recent invention of computation, any more than the inability to write essays is a result of word processing software or century old typewriter or the ballpoint pen.
Its truism thru history that as soon as the first tool was invented, some dude without enough mental horsepower to use it immediately started attacking the tool as being poorly designed. Fire, wheels, carpentry tools, farm machinery, computers, same old story. Some folks can't think, and giving them a tool then asking them to perform a thoughtful task is doomed to fail and result in the tool catching most of the blame. Why if only wheels were better designed to be round in all three dimensions instead of just two then that pesky problem of axle placement wouldn't be so stressful for end users, etc etc.
The fact of the matter is the median human is barely at a level of boolean algebra basics and arithmetic and following instructions on a packaged cake mix box. Giving someone innumerate a calculator doesn't mean they can now launch the space shuttle, any more than giving someone an anvil means they can shoe horses or handing me a basketball means I automatically have a career in the NBA.
- dozzie 10y ago> No, its because you're not good at math, the problem isn't the pencil. Half the population has to be below the median, after all, [...] This is hilarious, talking about hypothetical somebody sucking at math and using popular incorrect opinion about median in almost the same sentence xD There is a quite simple distribution with population of just five that has neither half of the population below the median nor above the median.
- justinhj 10y agoI must be missing something here. Surely the definition of median is that half the population is above, and half below?
- dozzie 10y agoNo. Median is a value of a specimen that at least half of the population is not smaller than it and at least half is not greater than it. In typical cases of large(-ish) populations with a range of values the notion of "precisely half of the population is smaller" is just a mental model good enough to generally understand what the median is about. Now imagine a degenerated case of a population with the same score. Surely there is a median, but surely none of the specimen is smaller than the median. A little less trivial case is a population of five with one value below, one value above, and three values in the middle.
- dozzie 10y ago> Median is a value of a specimen that... Correction: median doesn't have to be a value of a specimen.