5 ms·
> A lack of social-security-paid maternity is not technically a law What do you mean? It is a property of the legal system. > looking at what laws explicit me
by pron 10y ago
> A lack of social-security-paid maternity is not technically a law
What do you mean? It is a property of the legal system.
> looking at what laws explicit mention gender.
BTW, that's not a very good way to find legal discrimination. For example, suppose there was a country with no laws against rape (some Arab countries are not far from that). It doesn't mention sex, but women are raped by men far more than the other way around, or even (grown) men by other men. Such an absence is a clear legal discrimination against women (and probably children).
> Personally I don't see why the law don't just grant this to everyone
I don't know, as I'm not familiar with those laws and their goals, but you should always keep thinking about power. It's OK to treat men and women differently if it doesn't create a power disparity. The goal isn't to make women and men identical, but to allow them to have equal power.
> I have very little understanding for why the law can't just provide this service for everyone regardless of gender, except that government funding for victim of crimes support would have to be significant increased.
Again, I'm not sure, but my guess is that this is a "black lives matter" point, aimed to fix a discrepancy in reality. Laws are not written in a vacuum, and sometimes laws are aimed at specific people who are discriminated against at the time the law is written. One of the first things you learn when you study history is that a new law tells you a lot about changes in society, because people don't legislate against things that don't happen or they don't perceive as threats (the threats can be imaginary). The law is not the code for a simulation program; it is a set of steps for using the collective power of the stat to interact with social reality.
> Would you say there is currently a identifiable trend in changing cultural expectancy that society has on from female and male roles? If so, where would you say it points to?
Of course, and it seems pretty obvious to me. As recently as a few decades ago, women who put having children on hold to have careers were viewed as freaks. Just watch Mad Men.
> Society has just agreed that discrimination against nudists is acceptable
Nudists are not a social group just as chess players aren't, and it isn't a religion, either. It's OK to argue whether forbidding nude beaches is right or wrong, but it has nothing to do with the issue of burkas on the beach.
> Trying to repay bad blood from over 400 years is a recipe for war.
It's not "bad blood". Those are real effects, which are a major cause for current conditions. And where did you get 400 years? As recently as 50 years ago, there was a legal separation of blacks and whites in the US as well as overt economic discrimination.
> The historical cause is of lesser importance than the present need.
I agree. Fixing the wrongs isn't about the past, but about fixing the current effects of past deeds. If I steal your car so you can't get to work, giving it back isn't a matter of settling past issues, but correcting the problem of you not having a car because I stole it.
> Do you find that compatible with the successful abolishment of gender segregation in buses that the feminist movement fought for?
I am not familiar with that experiment or its goals.
- belorn 10y ago> It is a property of the legal system. A lack of something is not a property. The legal system lacks infinite number of things. Its not a meaningful definition if infinity is included. > It's OK to treat men and women differently And there we got a key disagreement. It is not OK to treat people different based on gender. Any such treatment will cause local power disparities, like bias that cause real harm. >> why the law can't just provide this service for everyone > my guess is that this is a "black lives matter" point The reason why the law treat women as incapable to pick up the phone and contact the agency is rather obvious. Cultural views and values. The problem is the result of power disparities for victims, where gender has a seven time factor in dictating who gets support and who doesn't. As a group, victims of crimes is one that should also be discriminated against because of their gender. > As recently as a few decades ago, women who put having children on hold to have careers were viewed as freaks. One of the theories behind that "interesting phenomenon" that is gender segregation in nations like Sweden, it describe how women after world war 2 started to have more time to spend on a career rather than spending all time on raising children. Men however are still stuck with the same expectation to support the raising of children, so their role in the work market has been static. Neither is a cultural change away from women being solely valued for their ability to raise children, nor men being valued solely for their ability to support the raising of children. > Nudists are not a social group just as chess players aren't Unsure if you are aware, but I find that comment highly offensive. Lets just start by quoting the lead in the wikipedia article on Naturism. "Naturism, or nudism, is a cultural and political movement practising, advocating and defending personal and social nudity". There exist a long history of nudism philosophy, culture, and values. I find your comment similar to someone saying that black people are not a social group, just as people wearing glasses aren't. People who believe that clothing is constraining their identity is equally discriminated by a law that require specific form of clothing on beaches. All the effect of discrimination, like being hurt and feeling rejected is current reality of those people. The stigma of "being the wrong kind of person" and having that discrimination not even acknowledged is very harmful. > And where did you get 400 years? >> One group has been enslaved for two centuries, and then forcibly put down for another two centuries Two centuries, plus two more centuries, is four centuries. And what material marks has been created for which black people exclusively can have? Is there a reason why the solution to those problems should not be used on society as a whole for anyone with the same material situation? It sound to me like you want solution to only go to people of black people because they deserve it more because of past injustice? > I am not familiar with that experiment or its goals. http://www.thelocal.de/20160329/is-germany-introducing-sex-segregated-trains-not-quite http://www.thelocal.de/20160329/is-germany-introducing-sex-s... My question stand: Is it compatible with the successful abolishment of gender segregation in buses that the feminist movement fought for?