3 ms·
Please (re)read Norman's Design of Everyday Things, for starters. TLDR: Blame the designer (of the tool), not the user. I taught 100s of people how to use CAD.
by specialist 10y ago
Please (re)read Norman's Design of Everyday Things, for starters. TLDR: Blame the designer (of the tool), not the user.
I taught 100s of people how to use CAD. Tough going. Technophile me thought "Of course it's better, easier, more powerful." Most of my student's blamed themselves. But I knew they were smart, knew what they wanted to accomplish, and just couldn't figure out how to do their jobs with CAD.
You could say "square peg, round hole", or "like pushing rope". I preferred "CAD is an angry 800lb gorilla sitting between people and their work".
Being kinda thick, I finally figured out the tools suck, not the people. Specifically with CAD, worse than the terrible UI, they had terrible mental models, completely divorced from how the users see their own work.
In conclusion, blaming the user is not very humanist. I rage at computers all the time, and I supposedly know what I'm doing. I have deep empathy for anyone not chin-deep in this crap.
- mikeash 10y agoThat's definitely the right approach most of the time. But sometimes people are just beyond any sort of help. When a literate, educated user cannot even read a message presented on the screen (and I don't mean understand or act upon the message, I merely mean read it), or when they don't understand that their electrically operated computer will not function until the building's electricity is turned back on, I think it's fair to blame the user. Sometimes people really do have the necessary knowledge and skills, they just refuse to apply them to computers. Certainly, many computer are too quick to blame the user when it's really a design problem, but it's not always wrong.
- kbenson 10y agoI sometimes wonder if this is the result of people falling into one of two categories of how they learned to see the world, deeply or shallowly. I think of myself as looking at the world deeply. I'm often less interested in the immediate response to my action than I am as to why that was the response. I want to understand the cause of things. I've met plenty of people that don't care about this at all, they care that action X yields response Y, and (for the most part, barring specialties) go through life with that as their model of the world. Sometimes I envy these people, as their heuristic approach often yields better projections than I'm able to come up with in certain areas (such as how a person may respond to a complex situation). Unfortunately, I think the shallow mental model has problems when presented with large systems of behavior as a whole that are foreign. Similar to the average person when dropped into a foreign culture with a different language, someone with a shallow mental model of the world may find a computer, with it's decades of layered systems and skeuomorphic metaphors, if they are even attempting that in the specific instance, may be initially too daunting to attempt on their own. At least that's my pop-psychology theory of the day.
- madaxe_again 10y agoI think there's a correlation here, but I'm not sure that someone's weltanschauung would be causative of digital literacy. Rather, I think the divide is "I can" vs. "I can't", and the latter limited thinking leads to the sort of limited world view you describe. It's something that fascinates me - so many lead lives that are essentially proscribed, view reality through a pre-fabricated toy lens - and when confronted with an individual that has chosen something other than default options in life react vigorously and vociferously. I see the same in computer literacy and literacy in general - the "I can't" stemming from a refusal to accept new information which may conflict with preconceived notions. If anything, I think it's fear of thought for the potential unhappiness that knowledge brings - adding something to the picture can make the overall scene so large and intimidating that many shy away rather than attempting the daunting task of filling the gaps. I mean, it is daunting - once one has climbed a mountain of knowledge you can see the whole, the foothills, how it joins in coherence - but at the bottom, all you can see is an almighty sheer face. I have learned to be comfortable with the knowledge that I know nothing, despite knowing far more than my fellow man. Knowledge requires humility, as you swiftly learn that you couldn't be further from the centre of the universe or less significant. I think there's a point early in life when this bifurcation happens - perhaps it's down to whether parents attempt to answer a child's questions about the world or simply reply with "stop asking stupid questions". Perhaps it's down to egoism - you either have to be humble or unspeakably arrrogant to pursue knowledge, and the middle is intimidated. That's my pop-psychology theory of the day :)
- joshuak 10y agoYou should read "Thinking, Fast and Slow", it will change your life. Hint: you're not too far off base
- yourapostasy 10y ago> When a literate, educated user cannot even read a message presented on the screen (and I don't mean understand or act upon the message, I merely mean read it)... This is usually trained into users by non-existent or awful error handling and messages in the majority of software. How the industry addresses errors is haphazard at best, and I see lots of evidence of what I call "checkbox/boilerplate project management" in lots of software products. The classic symptom is an error throws a message along the lines of "Foo Error: there was a foo type of error"; it is an error message, so I guess it got marked as a successful part of somebody's sprint by its mere existence, and not evaluated on its utility. The industry should be hiring legions of editors with red markers to up our communications game when it comes to error messages.
- mikeash 10y agoTo an extent, yes. I can understand why users will ignore error messages when they're in the middle of doing something else. I can even understand why they might ignore them when things are going wrong. But where it crosses the line for me is when an expert is helping them and asks them, "Can you read me the error message?" And they plead computer-ignorance and refuse. (Yes, this really does happen.)
- dublinben 10y agoLearned helplessness seems like a perfectly reasonable reaction to the terribly designed products we are all subjected to.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- flukus 10y agoI've seen people that can't understand the interface to an elevator, that the up light means it's going up and the down light means it's going down. That's for a single purpose tool that people use everyday. How do you propose we design intuitive UI's for those people? And aren't CAD tools power tools? They are designed to be easy to use for the experienced, not easy to pick up. There is a trade off between power and ease of use.