3 ms·
They've tried, hard, for some time now. Look through dang's and sctb's comment history to see how hard they've tried to improve the discourse.
by DanBC 10y ago
They've tried, hard, for some time now. Look through dang's and sctb's comment history to see how hard they've tried to improve the discourse.
- Chris2048 10y agoI think a reform of the guidelines would be more effective. Not every mod-comment is seen. I also think that specific flags would help, i.e. flag a comment that is against some guideline, with reference to the rule it broke.
- dang 10y agoWhat guidelines would you suggest?
- Chris2048 10y agoYou would be in a better position to notice common fallacies etc, but any "list of logical fallacies" is a good starting point, especially those fallacies that can be used to insult, or insinuate, E.g. Specific guidelines about ad-homs. This would also include advice not to use personal information/ circumstances in an argument, unless you are happy to see them criticised. One of the worst fallacies, us probably the kind that removed the civility from a discussion, and hence the good faith. As a side note, the worst kinds of guideline is an ambiguous one, that leaves a lot to interpretation, e.g "act civil" is itself a nice rule, but otherwise useless, better off as a heading above specific clarifications. HN doesn't need to be Wikipedia wrt comment rules, but a few Wikipedia style rules might be good.