6 ms·
I'm not surprised. Typically "computer skills" are taught as "click here, here and here to edit a word document". I think going back to basics and teaching peop
by flukus 10y ago
I'm not surprised. Typically "computer skills" are taught as "click here, here and here to edit a word document". I think going back to basics and teaching people how to do things from the command line would improve literacy dramatically, especially with the younger generation who have been shielded from the concepts of "files" and "programs".
- ghaff 10y agoWhy should the typical computer user need to understand concepts like files and programs? That sounds akin to saying that before someone can drive a car they should need to learn how to strip down an engine. There probably are those who advocate that but they're in the minority
- farnsworth 10y agoI suspect, but can't say for sure, that every commoditized technology throughout history has gone through this process where first you can't use it without understanding it in depth, then people try to build "it just works" experiences with gradually decreasing pushback from the experts, and eventually very few people actually understand the thing.
- flukus 10y agoBecause those are the primitives that make computers work. Interfaces change like fashion but something like "saving a file" is something that was useful 30 years ago and now. Stripping down the engine would be more akin to coding the programs themselves. This is more akin to saying that before someone drives they should know about the accelerator, brake and steering wheel, the basic tools that they use to interact with the car.
- SerLava 10y ago> This is more akin to saying that before someone drives they should know about the accelerator, brake and steering wheel, the basic tools No, this is something in between, but an analogous system does not exist in cars. If cars had trim, like airplanes, that might be analogous.
- flukus 10y agoTo follow the analogy further, it's both. We've never had a machine as general purpose as computers are. I'd classify it as more like writing and mathematics than any piece of technology. And with those we teach from the bottom up.
- xiaoma 10y agoSo they can work with them far more efficiently? A computer is a much more general purpose tool than a car.
- jcahill 10y agoNot mentioned yet: separation of concerns. http://enwp.org/separation_of_presentation_and_content http://enwp.org/separation_of_presentation_and_content
- will_hughes 10y agoKnowing the basics of what a file and program are is more like knowing what a door and steering wheel are. 'A file is where data is stored' And 'a program is a collection of instructions for the computer to do something' are the basic levels of understanding one would expect.
- reitanqild 10y ago> Why should the typical computer user need to understand concepts like files and programs? That sounds akin to saying that before someone can drive a car they should need to learn how to strip down an engine. I'd say it sounds a lot more like learning the basic theory of hydraulic brakes (because you shouldn't brake too much but rather switch to a lower gear when you drive down from mountains.)
- Qantourisc 10y agoThe same reason you want literacy in any other field: to not be taken by the nose, taken advantage of. Example medical care, in theory I should not know a thing about it. Yet not all doctors show the required dedication to figure out a problem to it's root cause. As such I need some literacy in this field, so I can solve, or insist/steer the problem to a solution.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoComputer is not a car. Car is an appliance, and perfect bullshit-free car would be one that simply drives you from point A to point B safely, without any additional input besides providing the point B. Computer is not an appliance, it's a general-purpose problem-solving tool. It's closer to reading and writing than to dishwasher or fax machine. You can argue that applications are like appliances, and that makes some sense, but refusing to learn about the environment those applications live in makes you that much less able to do things that span multiple applications.
- anthk 10y agoNo, this is like knowing how to read road signals.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoWhy would you need the command line for that? Any GUI file browser is a much clearer tool for understandings files and programs.
- flukus 10y agoYou don't, but when you want to combine the primitives to get stuff done it's much easier from the command line.
- kagamine 10y agoThat's a matter of opinion that I am sure many Linux/unix users do not share. Even on windows the tree structure is easiest understood in plain text without all the noise. It's literally a diagram of the file system.
- PhasmaFelis 10y ago> That's a matter of opinion that I am sure many Linux/unix users do not share. Indeed. It's one of the fundamental fallacies of design: The fact something is clear and easy for you does not mean that it's objectively clear and easy. You are not your users. http://uxmyths.com/post/715988395/myth-you-are-like-your-users http://uxmyths.com/post/715988395/myth-you-are-like-your-use... I grew up using command line, I kept stubbornly using it for years after GUIs was ubiquitous, and I still use it regularly at work and at home. None of that means that it is the best tool available for this specific learning task. > It's literally a diagram of the file system. So is Windows Explorer or any other GUI file browser, in every way. If you put it in details view, it even displays the same data in the same way as a command line directory, except you can navigate it intuitively with a mouse.
- flukus 10y agoExplorer will show a lot of unrelated stuff on the left. It will hide important information (filenames). It makes it difficult to see hidden files. It will pollute the view with different icons for file extensions. When someone is learning what a file is, explorer shows both too much and too little information.
- onion2k 10y agoMost people's primary computing device is a phone. They don't have a command line the user can access.
- flukus 10y agoA phone is a media consumption device, not a computing device.
- z3t4 10y agoYou are right, and it's a problem, but it doesn't have to be that way, we can improve human input/output.
- AstralStorm 10y agoTouch screens are extremely clumsy input devices...
- z3t4 10y agoKeyboards sure are hard to beat. Maybe a foldable blue-tooth keyboard that you can have in your pocket and then place on your lap or a table. Where do you place your mobile while typing with both hands though ? Maybe in a casing so it can sit on your lower arm. Or a Velcro/burdock case so you can place the mobile on textile surfaces.
- flukus 10y agoI'm hoping for something like hololens with some kind of keyboard, virtual or otherwise. Then we can take large screen monitors with us.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jonathankoren 10y ago"Computing?" Now that's a term I haven't heard in a long time. Who does computing outside of data center? I'm typing this on a laptop right now, but I wouldn't say I do any "computing" on it. Even at work, I would say that the actually amount of "computing" I'm responsible for (i.e. a program I specifically wrote to calculate some number.) is very low compared to simply text editing, web surfing, and music playing. Throwing around this archaic and ill defined term, and then dismissing the phone as "a media consumption device" strikes me as elitist and out of touch. Is photography consumption? Clearly not, since it's production. Is media editing consumption? No. Is it computing? Well given that nonlinear digital video editors were big expensive machines several years ago, I'd say so, unless of course we're moving the bar. Is writing computing? 30 years ago it was. Do people actually write on their phones? Yes. Oh communication doesn't count? How about term papers? Do they do that? Yes, they do.[0] I think you need to reexamine your biases. [0] http://www.wsj.com/articles/look-mom-im-writing-a-term-paper-on-my-smartphone-1455729046 http://www.wsj.com/articles/look-mom-im-writing-a-term-paper...
- hawski 10y agoThey know command line alright. It's only that Google search bar is the new command line.