9 ms·
I come at this from the opposite side: Under what circumstances is working 100+ hours a week optimal? I can think of quite a few actually. Building/updating lif
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
I come at this from the opposite side: Under what circumstances is working 100+ hours a week optimal? I can think of quite a few actually. Building/updating life critical systems come immediately to mind. Security vulnerability work, in the same vein.
Let's also not ignore that plenty of people are working 100+ hour weeks. Many Nurses/Doctors, laborers & construction workers, deployed military members, movie producers, financial brokers.
I've seen all of these first hand - hell I've done it for extended periods. Near Christmas of 2010, about a month after I got back to the Pacific from 8 months in Iraq (Those were 90-100 hour work weeks at a minimum), the Koreas got into a little fracas [1] and it looked like war time for PACOM. That first week I worked 136 hair on fire hours with 38 of those being straight through.
That's 20 hours working, 4 hours of sleep (usually on a cot in a meeting room) with meals eaten while reading message traffic and reviewing documents in the bathroom. The following months were better, but not by much.
In my experience 100+ hour weeks are usually less than 12 months and then a break. Often though, the break is short (a week or so) and it's time to start again.
So it's actually not that crazy, but you have to be committed. Most people aren't that committed, and I find that sad, as there is so much worth committing yourself to.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardment_of_Yeonpyeong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardment_of_Yeonpyeong
- mickronome 10y agoI can only speak for myself, but I would completely self-destruct both mentally and physically working that much. Only possible exception would be something that doesn't feel like work at all, but then it isn't really working, is it ? It would be more like accidentally getting paid for living the life one fortunately were able to choose living.
- std_throwaway 10y agoMost people would die soon if they try to do that. I'm happy for you that you have a very capable body and a strong mind.
- will_hughes 10y ago> Under what circumstances is working 100+ hours a week optimal? I can think of quite a few actually. Building/updating life critical systems come immediately to mind. Security vulnerability work, in the same vein. I would say the opposite. If someone is working on critical systems where literal life and death is at stake, I want them rested and at full mental capacity with the ability and time to think through repercussions to choices they make.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoAgreed generally. I think the rub is where you get systems that are so specialized that you can't throw bodies at them. The Apollo missions are a great example of this [1]. So while it would be ideal to be able to have 3 shifts that work on the same project or codebase, to get the desired speed you need, in practice generally only a handful of people can manage the complexity. [1] http://www.airspacemag.com/space/apollos-army-31725477/ http://www.airspacemag.com/space/apollos-army-31725477/
- will_hughes 10y agoI'm not suggesting throwing more bodies at a problem is a solution, it's often not. Apollo is a good example of artificial deadlines pushing development effort. What would've been the impact of pushing back? A launch delay? Okay, maybe a considerable delay. No life was in jeopardy by pushing it back. It was all political (and maybe some orbital mechanics too). Similarly for folks working on life critical systems today - sure, $Company might launch their new thingy sooner, and perhaps nobody dies as a result of shitty code getting shipped. But a week or two's delay is probably worth it. If you're responding to an emergency - that's an entirely different situation. Maybe everything's on fire and you're losing money hand over fist or someone's life is actually in danger - sure, fine, work the stupid hours to solve the immediate problem.
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoThere's a reason that airline pilots are forbidden to work too many hours. Should doctors not have the same kind of rules?
- pfranz 10y agoI remember hearing that while medical workers work very long shifts of consecutive hours, there is still a very noticeable drop in performance--however, there was an even larger drop in care when they switched shifts. So while the long shifts are problematic, the reduction in shift switches outweighs it. I imagine the armed forces have a similar rationale--they seem to be pretty thorough about studying these types of things.