10 ms·
How publishers are defeating ad blockers and how ad blockers are fighting back
- paulryanrogers 10y agoThe cat and mouse game between publishers and blockers continues to pollute the web for everyone. Sad to see things escalating so quickly.
- fapjacks 10y agoThis article concludes that adblockers are "losing"... But do you know what happens when I see a modal asking me to whitelist the site? See ya! This isn't some critical thing I rely on to survive. It's Forbes. I don't need any of their content, and I'm totally fine walking away until my particular blend of adblockers can block the garbage on their site again.
- user5994461 10y agoWow Forbes. I've been unable to read that site for years. Is there even content somewhere after all the popups and redirections? Hard to tell.
- davidgerard 10y agoYes, usually a sponsored op-ed blog presented as if it's an actual article.
- bumblebeard 10y agoAgreed, although maybe this is what they want to happen. If you use their bandwidth and they don't make any money off your visit, then they probably don't care if you never come back. I'm like you though; I actively avoid reading sites that do this. I also block JavaScript by default, which helps to mitigate a lot of other annoyances and privacy invasions.
- flukus 10y agoThe don't realize the relationship is symbiotic though. Part of the value of big news sites like forbes is their influence. To an extent they are widely read because they are widely read, people read it to see what others are reading.
- dismantlethesun 10y agoPerhaps, but as an alternative perspective.... I work for a midlevel publisher. Nearly of our content is syndicated, with very nearly none if it being unique. Our value -add is our selectivity, and great on-site user experience when it comes to filtering and subscriptions. 20% of our readers use adblock. For video content which is a mere fraction of our site, that comes out to $700 a day in bandwidth costs going to adblock users, or $21,000 in the average month. That's a lot. What publisher wouldn't fall over themselves to get 20% more profits in a given year? In the last year, we grew approximately 20% but our % of adblock users soared so while costs are up, revenue is flat. This isn't a sustainable situation. I have a lot of sympathy for people who do not want to see intrsuive advertisement, and I myself feel the same way sometimes, but when it comes down to sheer costs---we can't afford to subsidize adblock users. I'm unconviced that adblock users add more value that they take away. Since we know how many of them they are, and how much they cost, we can ask is $21,000 better spent subsizing adblock user who may tell their friends about our site, or is it better spent on traditional advertising? I think that people do follow word-of-mouth better than traditional ads, but that also means the friends of adblock users are more likely to be adblock users themselves---thus just an additional cost ontop of one we can't handle already.
- flukus 10y agoIs that video content that users want or stuff that you auto play for them?
- dismantlethesun 10y agoWe don't autoplay videos because that costs bandwidth. These aren't ads. They have to click play for anything to happen.
- iLoch 10y agoShortsighted, wouldn't you say? Eventually this will choke out all competition except for companies with the smartest people/deepest pockets. We'll end up creating monopolies around content by refusing to pay for it when there was healthy competition.
- raverbashing 10y agoFake news sites usually don't have paywalls It's sad really
- Pinckney 10y agoDoesn't affect my logic. Tragedy of the commons.
- andromeduck 10y agoI for one am willing to pay for content as long as it's large enough to o cover most of the sites I frequent, fixed rate subscription, no extea fees for content (pay per comment/timed exclusivity for paid members to drive membership fine by me), and most importantly, a way to personally choose who gets a portion (at least 25%) of the subscription fees. Short of that I really don't give a damn. It's not my problem.
- fapjacks 10y agoYou're supposing that there aren't people out there willing to make and distribute content without demanding some kind of payment in return. Content doesn't only come from people that put tons of crappy ads on their sites. And I can't say I'll find it tragic when Buzzfeed and Upworthy go bankrupt.
- edibleEnergy 10y agoYeah sorry, it's not totally clear but what we were trying to convey in the conclusion is in the back and forth between ad blockers and ad block detectors the detectors seem to be winning, especially if you're using AdBlock Plus or AdBlock.
- hprotagonist 10y agoIts amazing how much of this I am unaware of because of tools like noscript. Anti-adblock tech that relies on js just doesn't matter much..
- gruez 10y ago...until you visit a site that gives you a blank page without javascript. speaking of which, i wouldn't be surprised if more and more sites start to require mandatory js to view their content.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- intrasight 10y agoI browse on mobile with JS disabled and most news sites still work.
- mioelnir 10y agoHappens frequently to me with uMatrix. Then you look at the list. You know the usual suspects like jQuery, google ajax, bootstrap, Akamai etc. fairly fast. On other sites you look at what they want to include and you just think "yeah, no, let's not do that" and just close the page.
- flukus 10y ago> i wouldn't be surprised if more and more sites start to require mandatory js to view their content. Which is all the justification you need to block it.
- dopeboy 10y agoJust curious - how much of the web are you actually able to browse? It seems the majority of sites I run into have some sort of dynamic interactivity done via JS.
- brightsize 10y ago
- alex_anglin 10y agoNot only publishers it would seem: This weekend I tried visiting the website of a streaming video provider I was interested in subscribing to only to be informed that, roughly, "there was a problem completing my request. If you have an ad-blocker, please disable it and refresh this page. <company in question> uses certain tools for marketing purposes that can be blocked by ad-blockers" ... ironically for their marketing department, I decided not become a customer then and there.
- coderdude 10y agoThey wanted to see information about how you use something they offer. You wanted something they offer. You declined, which is your choice, of course. I think you both lost that battle.
- smsm42 10y agoI think the company insisting they know better than myself what I need to see and how I need to see it is not going to be good to do business with. If you know your tech doesn't work well with adblockers, you have two choices: a) accept that some part of the audience doesn't want ads and work so that your tech supports them and b) tell them "screw you" and refuse to take them as the clients. The company chose the latter. Why anybody would insist on being a client of somebody that doesn't want you as a client, given the choice?
- coderdude 10y agoThe bit about them insisting they know better than you what you need to see and how you need to see it, coupled with the bit about ads, is a non sequitur. We're talking about tracking usage stats. Some people simply can't be bothered to disable an ad blocker for non-ad related things. Others take a more extreme stance and consider analysis itself to be an affront. Everyone loses. Producers don't know what works or doesn't and consumers don't get the content they desire. One thing I've noticed is that these comments tend to come from pure consumers but rarely from those who both produce and consume. It's partially an issue of having a lack of perspective of the other part of the equation.
- olvar_ 10y agoI'd just like to point out that the "war" developing is not so much between advertising and ad-blockers. I think most of us would be fine with advertising on some page you are visiting. The real problem comes from trackers and other tactics that don't try to show a product TO you, but try to show YOU to a company. The problem is not that I don't want to see advertising, I just don't want to share my information with someone I don't even know. Maybe there is a way in between.
- wernercd 10y agoPersonally, I wouldn't mind SOME ads feeding companies... Hell, I'll watch short videos to get ahead in some games I play... the problem is massive ads, 3 line stories turning into multi page ad fests, "Around the Web" type crap, security risks injected via ad networks, etc... It's not the ads per-se: it's the MASSIVE abuse of ads. it's why we can't have nice things. Same can be said of TV shows and how it went from a minute of ads... t0o 10 minutes out of a 30 minute slot being ads.
- nerdponx 10y agoGood point about TV. I'd happily subscribe to cable if it weren't for the fact that I'd be paying to have ads blared at me every 5 minutes.
- smsm42 10y agoI just DVR everything and then skip ads. I can't watch non-recorded TV anymore - not only ads are extremely long and mind-numbingly boring, they insist on showing the same ads several times during the same show! I don't know how people tolerate it.
- jghn 10y agoYou're still affected as the time allotment for actual content is going down. Even reruns are getting compressed
- 10y ago
- MiddleEndian 10y agoThe victory I'm waiting for is CSS selectors to finally get updated, so I can block something like so: div > $p > .adindicatorclass The p element would be blocked. This will also be great for getting rid of non ad content that you just don't want to see.
- majewsky 10y agoWon't happen. The point of CSS is that all selectors and properties only ever trickle downwards. If they could propagate upwards (from `.adindicatorclass` to its parent, in this case), the cost of evaluating them would become prohibitively expensive. (And even worse, you could probably construct self-contradicting stylesheets.)
- frozenport 10y agoMy eighty year old grandparents can't [be trusted to] browse web pages with internet ads. If internet ads were billboards in the same way we see highway advertising, I wouldn't mind. Today a significant percentage of them are scams, with victims.
- drewg123 10y agoMy largest annoyance after ads is autoplay html5 videos from news sites. CNN is especially bad. I wish Ublock could have an option to stop all html5 autoplay. (yes, I've got the "Disable HTML5 Autoplay" in chrome, and no, it mostly doesn't work)
- cmurf 10y agoCNN are dicks for this but I also blame Chrome and Firefox for not enforcing click to play.
- reustle 10y agoWhen so much is controlled by JS these days, is it reasonable to expect they can block it all the time? With flash, at least it is one element that the browser can lock until you click it. With JS, who knows what/where the developer will inject and start playing audio / video.
- RandomInteger4 10y agoOmg, yeah, autoplay is annoying in itself, but then add on top of that autoplay which runs on a loop, where even if you pause the video, the video begins playing again after a certain while. I've even had some sites do this where during the autoplay the site would autoscroll back to the location of the video and then not let you scroll away from the video until it was done playing. You'd be somewhat interested in the article, so you say "Fine, I'll watch the whole fucking ad" and then go back to reading only to have your fucking reading inter-fucking-rupted 15 fucking seconds later. FUCK!!! Seriously, fuck these web developers who do this absolute bullshit.
- benjaminjackman 10y agoYou can try umatrix. It will block all media stuff under the other category if you configure it that way. You can then whitelist what you want.
- manicdee 10y agoI particularly dislike the small sidebar videos that autoplay after a minute, and have absolutely nothing to do with the subject the page is ostensibly covering. Open an article on protectionism, head off to Wikipedia to look up some unfamiliar terms, suddenly, "COMPANIES AROUND THE WORLD ARE DEVELOPING SEXBOTS. WHAT DOES THIS MEAN TO THE FUTURE OF HUMAN RELATIONSHIPS?" Now my wife wants to know why I was researching sex bots, and the more I try to explain the situation the deeper I dig myself thanks to the Othello Effect.
- electic 10y agoBasically, after reading this article, use uBlock instead of AdBlock. It works.
- rosstex 10y agoSpecifically, uBlock Origin!
- hrrsn 10y agoI wish someone would port Origin to Safari. :(
- woogiewonka 10y agoConfirmed. Tried it on BI and works beautifully.
- RRRA 10y agoHow are the ad blocker not moving to the rendering engine already...
- callalex 10y agoSee: the Content Blocer system on iOS. The interface is a rules specification, and the implementation is delegated to the OS/hardware manufacturer to save power and performance.
- WhitneyLand 10y agoRight, too bad the entire architecture is useless because blockers are not allowed to use JS. Filter expressions are not enough anymore.
- RandomInteger4 10y agoI never used an adblocker until recently when Youtube started showing those fucking World of Tanks ads and ads for similar games from the same fucking company. Many of you don't understand how that could be a huge nuissance, because your systems are powerful enough to shrug it off, but for my old system, those fucking ads would freeze up the UI of the page. Even with my new system, many of the ads offered enough of a slowdown to the experience of using many sites on top of sometimes causing the system to crash completely that an adblocker became necessary.
- raybb 10y agoIf your company is really that slow because of adds you might want to think about blocking some ad providers with your host file. I tested it with a verge page and it went from about ~50mb down to ~10mb. (Disclaimer it was 50mb because of an auto playing ad video)
- petre 10y agoOr a custom DNS cache if you want to block on all of your network. There is a Perl script on github that generates a local rule set for unbound using Dan Pollock's list. There are other services as well.
- RangerScience 10y agoInteresting. Is there an adblocker that blocks or prevents the most annoying parts of ads - sounds, animations, taking over chunks of the screen? Maybe one that limits cross-domain traffic, so requests for more than, say, a megabyte get nixed?
- boyter 10y agoInteresting to see how others are doing this. I recently was tasked with adding some logic to determine the number of ad-blocking users across the network of sites I help maintain. I added my own custom script into Appnexus (ad provider) and attempted to load it. Ad-blockers, I discovered do one of two things in this case. The first is to just block the loading of the content, in which case it was easy to detect. Others would inject their own custom content, hence adding a custom script and then checking the contents for a special string. A fun task for sure though.
- InclinedPlane 10y agoDear publishers: you're fighting the wrong battle, and the wrong people. You look at people who visit your site without seeing the ads as "stealing" your content without paying the price (suffering, apparently I guess) of viewing the ads. Forcing them to view ads is a dumb move that you've been forced into because of the bizarre incentives in the business, but it's not a sustainable strategy. Forcing people to view ads won't make those ads effective, and it'll make your viewers hate you more. Ads are likely not a long-term stable source of income either. Precisely because people are becoming more and more savvy when it comes to figuring out what to buy and less and less tolerant of being told what to buy. I know that advertising is one of the easiest ways to make money, especially with a content site on the internet. But you need to put serious effort into finding a better way. If you don't then you'll be caught flat footed when both your ad revenue and your viewers gone. Foster stronger bonds with your viewers, figure out how to monetize them without ads (there are a zillion ways without paywalls), keep innovating, laziness is how you die.
- ec109685 10y agoWhat are some of the zillions of ways?
- InclinedPlane 10y agoThere are two important things to understand when it comes to monetizing content production effectively. One, when you have a strong, unique brand that produces content that people love and identify with people want to give you money. Two, the concept of consumer surplus, market segmentation, etc. (see here: https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-duckies/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/12/15/camels-and-rubber-...). At the simplest level if you offer a quality product and you let people pay whatever they want for it, even nothing, you will still make money. That alone may not be enough to cover your costs, but it's an important realization. The difference between the "you need to control your customers, sell them to advertisers, and force ads down their throats" mindset versus the "you need to engage with your users and they will support you no matter what" mindset is like night and day, being so diametrically opposite can make it difficult to make the transition. The easy level of monetization is to let people give you money in exchange for "nothing". Offer donations, or patronage support with token rewards (such as being thanked, put in the credits, etc.), and merch that allows people to show off their support or that allows people to express their identity through a connection to you or your content (this works for everything not just rock bands or web comics). Up from there you can offer more substantive rewards. You can offer subscriptions that gain people access to extra content, to content earlier than it will be publicly available, to higher levels of credit, or to higher levels of engagement and connection with creators. You can package your content in different forms and release it as a compilation, charging money for it or offering it to subscribers. Say you're a web comic, you can print books containing your comics by year or by story line or whatever. If you're a musical artist you might release all of the tracks you're working on at any given time freely (through youtube or mp3 downloads) but then cut an album of the tracks (perhaps after re-recording them and having them professionally mixed/mastered) and sell that (either digitally, in physical form, or likely both). If you write you can compile stuff into books focusing on certain themes. And so on. You can break your work up into specific projects and crowd fund each project. This also gives you the advantage that you'll typically end up having to figure out how to produce various products out of that project to use as rewards, which you can also sell afterwards. And that's just a start, there are tons of other options. These things aren't viable for "content" creators who don't produce a lot of original content or that don't produce content of high enough quality to engage strongly with their fans, and I'm mostly ok with that. There are tons of clickbait and tabloid content creators out there who survive not because they produce anything of value but because today eyes can be monetized through ads. The main problem here is that income inequality is at such an extreme level that a lot of people have hardly any disposable income to support anything, no matter how much they value it, but the effects of that are even more wide ranging.
- gottam 10y agoIt reminds me of the music/movie industry in terms of how these adblock detectors mimic something like DRM. Anyway the problem is with the business model. People are installing adblockers in response to more aggressive advertising, and then the ad companies get more aggressive because of it. It's a never ending cycle.
- nojvek 10y agoAs a JS guy, I open the devtools and just delete the modal div elements. Problem solved.
- WhitneyLand 10y agoWhat's the best iPhone/iOS solution? Apple's new hooks for blockers only allow regex filters, so the blockers can never win without being able to add code. There are other browsers besides Safari but then you have other problems: 1). Do they have daily updates to their ad blockers to keep up the arms race? 2). How do you use important Safari plugins like LastPass?
- WhitneyLand 10y agoFound an answer, this is working well so far: https://purify-app.com https://purify-app.com
- jasonkostempski 10y agoDoes anyone know of a blacklisting plugin that will, for example, let me add wsj.com and then remove all links to that domain from any page I'm on? Ideally it would have a community driven list of known bad players. If something like that became very popular, I think companies would start to fear "disappearing" from the internet and start behaving a little more sanely.
- faebi 10y agoWhy can I not pay a reasonable amount of money to get past advertisments? Usually I do not need the subscription for 300$ a year but I want to read one article in a adfree way and pay for the advertisments they are losing. Unlike in apps, I haven't seen a website where I can give them money for no-ads. So for me their business model is broken.
- grzm 10y agoI'm curious as to the actual breakdown, but I know that most subscription-based journalism still receives the majority of its revenue from ads. I suspect that ad-free experiences would be prohibitively expensive for most if not all subscribers. This is largely speculation though. Anyone in the industry have some harder numbers? One example I know of that I believe is ad-free is theinformation.com which has a yearly subscription of $399. https://www.theinformation.com/payment-policy https://www.theinformation.com/payment-policy Running an institution like the NYT or the WSJ must be much more expensive.
- lsaferite 10y agoSo, this has nothing to do with the article itself and is instead about the HN post. This is a dupe of the exact same article posted 2 hours earlier. The URL is only different because this one, the dupe, had a # at the end of the URL and bypassed dupe detection. Why isn't that something that is identified and fixed automatically? Even better, if HN detects that someone is purposefully trying to bypass dupe detection, does HN punish that user? This case looks like it could have been a simple mistake, but there's zero reason that HN shouldn't be stripping a trailing # and in general having the dupe detection flag URLs that only differ in fragment ids.