9 ms·
I'm not sure at all how you can make conclusions from just 9 houses. I've been house hunting recently. Even houses in the same neighborhood are very different,
by smsm42 10y ago
I'm not sure at all how you can make conclusions from just 9 houses. I've been house hunting recently. Even houses in the same neighborhood are very different, and there are a lot of factors going into valuing a house. Also may be very subjective - some people would pay a lot for things that other people don't care about. Maybe Zillow is uniquely bad at one or two out of 20 factors - e.g., it can not detect a house in a good neighborhood that has been neglected and needs a lot of repair (I've seen houses in very good places that looked great from outside and required tens of thousands dollars of work on the inside just to be livable - maybe that's what happened to that -75% house - maybe it had a recent fire or flooding). Or maybe it doesn't value having a pool correctly. Who knows. But it's impossible to figure that out from only 9 houses, 3 per huge market! You need hundreds of data points to smooth out the individual differences and cancel out noise from all different criteria. That's exactly what Zillow's advantage is supposed to be - to aggregate thousands of data points. Maybe they do a good job, maybe not, but I don't think you can evaluate it by just using mere 3 houses per market of millions!