5 ms·
A long time ago I got a real estate appraiser's license. Here is the procedure for appraising real estate, as taught by my state: 1) Pick three homes that you
by DennisP 10y ago
A long time ago I got a real estate appraiser's license. Here is the procedure for appraising real estate, as taught by my state:
1) Pick three homes that you feel are comparable.
2) Pick out the material differences between those homes and your client's
3) Make up a value for each of those differences, and adjust accordingly
(Unofficially speaking) If you don't like the number you come up with, just make different decisions in steps 1-3 until you get the number you want.
- robbyking 10y agoIn the late 90's I worked for an online mortgage broker, and 9 times out of 10 when we ordered an appraisal, the appraiser would ask us what the selling price was and return an identical figure for their estimate.
- jaxytee 10y agoI purchased a home couple years ago. The appraiser I used did exactly this.
- leereeves 10y agoAmazing that people still pay for that.
- URSpider94 10y ago"People" don't. It's a required part of the due diligence to get a mortgage. No appraisal, no loan. For the most part, the banks and brokers re-sell those loans immediately, so they don't stay on their books. All they need to protect them from lawsuits later is proof that they followed the process to the letter -- which involves getting a written appraisal. No mortgage broker or Realtor ever got rich by picking a fight with the appraiser to lower the appraised value ... there is literally nobody present at the table who has an incentive to push the value down.
- DennisP 10y agoAside from the buyer, who can pay for his own appraisal.
- JamesBarney 10y agoUsually a buyer has already agreed to buy a house at a certain price. So if the appraisal comes back low, the seller doesn't lower the price. Instead the buyer just doesn't get a loan so they don't get to purchase the house they had their heart set on.
- DennisP 10y agoA friend of mine saved $15K on a house because the appraisal came in low. If the bank won't write a loan for the agreed price, the original contract is void, since it's contingent on loan approval. If the seller's heart is set on moving, he might well lower the price.
- URSpider94 10y agoReally depends. In the Bay Area these days, sellers will usually only take offers with zero contingencies (because they can). Even if you do get a financing contingency in your offer and the deal falls through because of a low appraisal, there's almost always a back-up offer waiting in the wings that can cover the low appraisal with an additional downpayment (the bank doesn't really care about if the house appraises for the selling price, they just want to make sure that their Loan-to-value (LTV) ratio is OK.
- smsm42 10y agoThat's really playing with fire. Good RE agent would tell their client so. Even if you're rich and buying in cash, at least inspection contingency is a must, but otherwise unless you have tons of money and don't really care for nasty surprises inspection could uncover - zero contingency is the riskiest bet one can make in one's life. My opinion, if you're on the market where sellers won't accept a contingent offer, it's better to get out of that market. I've bought house in BA recently, and there were plenty of sellers willing to take contingent offers (backed by some solid bank paperwork, maybe, but not just requiring to commit blindly). Of course, BA has many different places and in some market could be so hot sellers can get away with anything. But it's usually not good to get in such place as a buyer.
- EpicEng 10y agoApparently you've never actually taken out a mortgage.
- jandrese 10y agoWhen we were selling our home we didn't have a good idea of what it was worth so we called an appraiser and the first think he asked was "what are you selling it for?" Then we found out that even if we paid him a couple hundred bucks he wouldn't even come out and inspect the house before "appraising" it. We ended up just guessing high and lowering our price a couple of times until someone bit.
- bronson 10y agoThat actually makes some sense. That number is supposed to indicate the maximum someone would pay for the property. If you're in contract, especially after competitive bidding, then we know that number: it's in your contract! The appraiser just needs to make sure that the number isn't fraudulent or crazy.
- bshep 10y agoAs an example of above, A couple of years ago my wife and I were selling our home and the appraisal came back lower than agreed sale price, we asked appraiser to pick different comparables and the appraised price went up 10-20k
- arthurgibson 10y agoThats interesting, why would the seller have any control over the appraisal? The mortgage broker who requests the appraisal is typically working with the buyer.
- cema 10y agoI don't think this is "control", the appraiser [sp?] did not have to agree to do that.
- bshep 10y agoYou are correct they didnt have to agree to change anything. But there were other houses that were closer ( one of the comparables that he pcked was in a different neighborhood and was waaay cheaper ) and houses that were more similar so we pointed that out. He agreed and redid the estimate with houses that were closer both on distance and in size/amenities. All of this was throught the realtors ours and theirs.
- smsm42 10y agoTrue, but the appraiser has zero incentive to disagree (unless it's overtly fraudulent there's no such thing as wrong appraisal) and probably some incentive (repeat business) to keep the agent they are working with happy.
- wheelerwj 10y agoThis is how it USED to be done, and was a significant contributor the housing bubble that lead to the recession. It's different now, not necessarily less subjective but the incentive for creative appraisals has been drastically reduced. Prices have to be justified and mortgage brokers can't interact with the appraisers now. Apprasing has to be entirely separate from the underwriting process and is now entirely blind. In some states, appraisers are now accountable for significant deviations. The turnaround time is also significantly longer. I've heard reports from some people of appraisals in bigger markets taking as long 9 weeks. It's actually a pretty interesting process, ripe for disruption if anyone wants to take a crack at it.
- tomohawk 10y agoThe separation part only sounds good. However, if you get an incompetent appraiser, there's literally nothing you can do about it. It's also hard to weed out the incompetent ones, as they are now independent from their customers. We got an incompetent on our last deal. Couldn't find the house. Misidentified the street. Couldn't find the electric panel. I could go on. Took several weeks to get the appraisal done, and there was nothing we could do about it because independent.
- wheelerwj 10y agoya, i understand. but that sounds like a very different issue.
- smsm42 10y agoIt's kind of scary that million dollars' decisions (and in aggregate, probably billions) are made on the basis of solely "let's look what others are doing and then fudge it based on gut feeling until it looks kinda plausible" and that's supposed to be expert verdict. Not that I can offer any better idea :)