3 ms·
Probably my favorite equation, and the proofs for the formula are quite nice too. Perhaps interestingly, I have a friend who accepted this, but after proof upo
by Jach 17y ago
Probably my favorite equation, and the proofs for the formula are quite nice too.
Perhaps interestingly, I have a friend who accepted this, but after proof upon proof could not agree that 0.999... is exactly equal to 1. He eventually conceded, but it was a pretty long period of time to that point and it wasn't through proof.
- wwortiz 17y agoYou should always ask if they agree that 1/3 = 0.33333... then you just need to add them up :)
- sesqu 17y agoI find this easy to accept: lim_{n->inf} 1 - 1/10^n = 1 But I'm not quite sure if I agree that 0.999... = lim 0.999... edit: according to Wikipedia, they're today defined to be equal. While convenient, it's not obvious to me. edit2: ah-ha! I just remembered the proof that had once upon a time satisfied me: there is a number between any two distinct numbers. there isn't one between 0.999... and 1, so they aren't distinct.
- wlievens 17y agoBonus points for realizing it yourself and editing your post accordingly!
- jackowayed 17y agoMakes sense. The fact that e^(ipi) = -1 seems crazy at first, but no one has a preconceived notion of what it should equal, so when you show a simple proof, of course they'll accept it. But people's whole mathematical careers they've worked with decimals and developed firm ideas of how they work. So they idea that 0.999... = 1 seems to defy their years of decimal practice, which makes it hard to accept. Fun anecdote: In my calc BC class, we did an infinite series question that proved that .999... = 1 (it was an infinite series of 9/(10^n), so it was adding 9/10 + 9/100 + 9/1000 + ...), which blew the minds of half of our class. During the argument that ensued, our teacher said "Well, it doesn't actually equal 1. It'll never quite get there. It just gets infinitely close." Needless to say, what little respect for her I did have at that point in the year was gone after that.