5 ms·
If your goal is to build General AI, getting access to the game state information is cheating and ultimately self defeating because it does not generalize acros
by chongli 10y ago
If your goal is to build General AI, getting access to the game state information is cheating and ultimately self defeating because it does not generalize across games. Expert humans are able to pick up and play a brand new game with a high degree of initial success despite zero knowledge of the memory states within the game. We do this by reliance on our vast knowledge of video game and literary tropes as well as experience playing past games. I have yet to see any video game bot make use of this stuff to figure out how to play Zelda, for example.
- BaronSamedi 10y agoAn AI which can learn any game from "looking" at a screen is a very ambitious goal. I doubt it is achievable in the near term. Humans can do it because of years of learning about the world. Personally, I prefer the more modest and achievable goal of teaching an AI to play complex real-time games such as Starcraft, LoL, and Dota--especially the latter 2 since they are team games.
- lawless123 10y agoThat's not their goal though.They want AGI.
- chongli 10y agoPersonally, I prefer the more modest and achievable goal of teaching an AI to play complex real-time games Those sorts of goals are better suited to individual hobbyists. OpenAI is a blue sky research project set up by billionaires with the goal of improving all of mankind. I hope I'm not being too uncharitable when I say that your comment reminds me of those who scorned the Apollo program for its ambition.
- BaronSamedi 10y agoI support research in AI of all kinds, however, its history is one of vastly over-promising and under-delivering. Modest but demonstrable progress is better, in my view, than yet more hype.