2 ms·
Sharks kill people also every year, but this fact do not makes Chernobil more safe.
by pvaldes 10y ago
Sharks kill people also every year, but this fact do not makes Chernobil more safe.
- mikeash 10y agoWhat's your point? My point is that concern should be at least vaguely proportional to danger. Freaking out about thousands killed by nuclear accidents while ignoring millions killed by properly operating coal plants is not sensible. And if nuclear displaces coal, then it will save many, many lives.
- pvaldes 10y agoThis recurrent thing about how nuclear only killed one or two people or maybe five (all in Nagasaki), is getting really tiresome.
- mikeash 10y agoAre you saying we should stop discussing nuclear power's actual safety record because it's too annoying?
- pvaldes 10y agoI'm saying that discussion must stop cherry-picking and hiding variables at will. Like breast cancer rate increased for decades, value of wipping entire cities, billionary damage to economy, making the country easily vulnerable and a slave of security measures, agriculture and ecological problems. The only answer from this guys are "but coal is worse and sun can make you blisters", you don't care for guys that also die by X! and this is a red herring. Yes, everybody knows that cars kill a lot of people each year. Can we focus again in the elephant foot's problem?
- mikeash 10y agoWhat's being cherry-picked or hidden? I even tossed in casualties from nuclear weapons just to be generous. Comparing with coal is highly relevant, since nuclear substitutes for coal. If coal is significantly more dangerous (as the numbers would indicate) then fear of nuclear power has ultimately killed a lot of people by preventing nuclear from further substituting for coal. If you'd rather just talk about the dangers of nuclear power without that context, that's entirely fair. But that's a rather different complaint from what you've made so far. And if that's what you don't like, might I gently suggest just clicking the little [-] next to the comments that talk about coal? There's plenty of other discussion to be had here.