2 ms·
you say Jordan has > a weird obsession with Marxism but from the article: > My primary interest has always been the psychology of belief. > I got interested
by Chris2048 10y ago
you say Jordan has
> a weird obsession with Marxism
but from the article:
> My primary interest has always been the psychology of belief.
> I got interested in ideology, in a large part, because I got interested in what happened in Nazi Germany, the Soviet Union, the Cultural Revolution in China, and equivalent occurrences in other places in the world. Mostly I concentrated on Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union.
> Part of the reason I got embroiled in this [gender identity] controversy was because of what I know about how things went wrong in the Soviet Union. Many of the doctrines that underlie the legislation that I’ve been objecting to share structural similarities with the Marxist ideas that drove Soviet Communism.
Doesn't this make clear why Jordan mentions Marxism? Why do you say he has a "weird obsession"?
> I can't put a finger on what exactly he believes is common among and unique to Soviet nationalist and contemporary social justice discourse
One of the questions in the article is:
> you wrote that ‘words like zhe/zher are the vanguards of a radical left wing ideology that’s frighteningly similar to Marxism’. Can you elaborate?
doesn't this address that?
- resfirestar 10y agoIt comes off as weird because he claims to see a connection that I don't. As I mentioned, there is no concept of "revolutionary language" in Soviet or general Marxist thought. The connection to pronouns rests on that being a real thing, so there's nothing left to help me see why social justice-themed legislation has anything to do with Marxism in his mind.
- Chris2048 10y agoDo you mean you don't see it in this interview, or in Petersons' work in general? "revolutionary language" possibly means soviet language reform?: https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=stqV47DuteoC&pg=PA103 https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=stqV47DuteoC&pg=PA103