3 ms·
A very important essay: Vague patent threats are made because "specific statements would allow the victims of this FUD to petition a court for a declaratory ju
by hga 17y ago
A very important essay:
Vague patent threats are made because "specific statements would allow the victims of this FUD to petition a court for a declaratory judgment of non-infringement."
The MPEG formats are deliberate patent minefields" because the process officially does not take patents into consideration (all parties agree to RAND licensing ahead of time) and every party is determined to make sure the standard includes one or more of theirs even if it's unneeded or detrimental to the standard, so that they'll have cross license status and won't have to pay anything to use it.
(And that's what happens when all parties are playing by the rules. That doesn't always happen (e.g. see Rambus, the RDRAM company) and in general patents are making a hash of the standards process: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1134000 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1134000)
Most of these patents are "exceptionally narrow, as it's much cheaper and easier to obtain a very narrow patent."
Read the whole thing for the conclusion, which asserts that avoiding this MPEG type mess is the best approach and implies that patent free formats are possible, although of course there's no escaping the possibility of ending up in court going either way (in fact it might be more likely in the patent centric approach).