I disagree extremely strongly. I thought a lot of the tone, which made the short story so good, was lost, probably due to the medium and the audience. It becam

I disagree extremely strongly. I thought a lot of the tone, which made the short story so good, was lost, probably due to the medium and the audience. It became much more of a sci-fi alien thriller than a commentary on mortality. I found that, having read the short story, I enjoyed the movie less than those who had not read it.