8 ms·
From the outside, movie scripts just looks like mono-spaced text with dialogue indented. Can you explain why one would need special software for this? What doe
by wodenokoto 10y ago
From the outside, movie scripts just looks like mono-spaced text with dialogue indented.
Can you explain why one would need special software for this? What does Final Draft give the writer, that word or open office doesn't?
- andrewflnr 10y agoRoughly the same reason programmers tend to like IDEs. There are a lot of conventions around alignment, spacing, capitalization, and probably others that need to be respected in a screenplay. Specialized software makes it easier.
- Keyframe 10y agoKeeps the format consistent, yes. Also, word completion for characters, scenes, and other conventions (INT./EXT., DAY/NIGHT/... for slugs). Also, probably the most important reason, it gives you consistent numbering and revision system. This is important when doing a production breakdown. think of it as a reporting tool. There's reporting as well. How many action there is vs dialogue, how many characters and which in a scene or script, which scenes, which props per scene (not every tool does that), etc. Some of these reports are done externally in apps like MMS6 or Gorilla. You could, and people do, write screenplay in Word or whatever. Trouble arises later when you need to go through revisions and work with other people that work in those production-oriented apps. For that reason alone it's better to do it all in a specialised app.
- kbenson 10y agoSeems almost like you could use an IDE with a couple specialized plugins...
- Keyframe 10y agoSay no more http://www.vim.org/scripts/script.php?script_id=3880 http://www.vim.org/scripts/script.php?script_id=3880
- TeMPOraL 10y agohttps://www.emacswiki.org/emacs?action=browse;oldid=ScreenPlay;id=Screenplay https://www.emacswiki.org/emacs?action=browse;oldid=ScreenPl...
- coldtea 10y agoYes, if for some perverse reason you wanted to adopt something that's designed for something else first and foremost (development in the case of an IDE), and are able to tolerate all the non-task-specific functionality that results from that. Not to mention that lots of popular IDEs are written in unnecessarily wasteful/slow environments (Eclipse and Idea which use Java, etc).
- kbenson 10y agoI'm not sure why you seem to think script development is entirely distinct from software development. Perhaps you have some insight into this that I don't, but while there are some obvious differences, I'm willing to bet that a good IDE that's general purpose enough to work for both a lisp and static language and support refactoring and syntax highlighting and interface with external programs like source control would support quite a bit of what's needed already. As for implementation language, I'm not sure java is significantly slower in the case of the project size we are talking about here.
- andrewflnr 10y agoI know scripts rely heavily on centering and right alignment. I'm guessing that's not the only way they depend on the assumption of being printed. There would be some impedance mismatch in using tools designd for plain text.
- Keyframe 10y agoYou could write in Fountain syntax http://fountain.io/ http://fountain.io/ and have the presentation be printed as intended. I actually tried that once or twice (short commercial form) in Vim and I didn't have any issues.
- moflome 10y agoAny feedback on how well Amazon's SaaS solution for screenwriting [0] works as a replacement for the ever-present Final Draft? [0] https://storywriter.amazon.com https://storywriter.amazon.com
- icelancer 10y agoSame reason that everyone is in love with LaTeX which seems needlessly overly-complicated.
- CydeWeys 10y agoFollow-up question to this, why are scripts monospaced in the first place? It is just a historical convention at this point, because they used to be done on typewriters? Or is this just a simple way to handle alignment? I find dialogue in variable width font easier to read, so I'm wondering if there's really some compelling reason why monospaced is better.
- skepticaldrunk 10y agoYes. Initially, it was a relic from the typewriter days, and the tabbing and indentation was developed to allow each of the affiliated tradespeople involved in the project to do their jobs effectively. But now, it has its own reasons. One page in a standard format screenplay translates into roughly one minute of screentime. There are exceptions to this rule, but the first thing someone in the business does when they get a new script is check the last page number. Further, when a screenplay goes into production, the work for the day is organized into eighths of a page, which is used as a shorthand for how long each piece of work is going to take. So while changing the tabulation and type spacing might make a screenplay more readable, it would make it much much less produceable. At the end of the day, a screenplay isn't meant to be read, and the formatting reflects that.
- Keyframe 10y agoTechnically, it's eight eights that are one minute of screen time - WHEN you keep dialogue to ~three lines per spoken part and you write only what you see. In general though, if format isn't what it is you wouldn't be able to gauge how long a script lasts and you wouldn't be able to break it down for production easily.
- skepticaldrunk 10y agoTrue, but if we're getting really technical, the script supervisor gets to decide what an eighth is, so a decent scripty will keep it shockingly consistent. Another quirk, for sure, but when you see the breakdown and it lists 120 pages worth of scenes on a 114 page script, it actually makes sense.
- skepticaldrunk 10y agoFrom a spec writer perspective, the short answer is that it has hotkeys, formatting based on element type, and autocomplete. Beyond that, there are versioning tools (screenplay versioning can get a bit esoteric), alternate dialogue capabilities, scene numbering and reporting tools, and a lot more. It also has a lot of capabilities related to production, such as omit functionality, watermarking, script locking, etc. Final Draft gets bagged on a lot for being expensive and ugly, but it really does have a ton of specialized tools that are incredibly powerful if used correctly.
- zeroer 10y ago> screenplay versioning can get a bit esoteric I'm curious. What features to writers need that git couldn't provide?
- Keyframe 10y agoIt's not versioning like you would find in software development. Google will provide you with details (first link for me): http://www.scriptchick.net/Info/Revisions.html http://www.scriptchick.net/Info/Revisions.html The gist of it is that each version gets distributed to various channels of pre-production and production. Once locked, each page has its number and if the page changes, it stays in (!), but new one is added according to certain rules. In a way it's like a commit history printed out, but isn't. It's weird, but it works.
- wtallis 10y agoLooks like screenplays are heavily afflicted by a cult of doing it the hard way. Computer programmers have moved beyond punched cards and manual line numbering, but Hollywood is still pointlessly (proudly?) stuck in the typewriter era. Nothing in that article supports the assertion that screenplays have a different concept of versioning than software developers. Screenwriters just have a different preferred format for displaying diffs, a different convention for version numbering (but that's completely irrelevant to a tool like git), and a paper-saving way of handling insertions and removals, when printing out on paper (again, irrelevant to git). Advice like "If it's only one or two words that are different, consider just whiting out the existing script and writing it in, rather than reinventing the wheel and generating a new color." makes it very clear that this industry hasn't even tried to use technology to make these problems go away. I wonder how long until this whole system gets replaced by tablets that always automatically show the latest revision, without requiring the use of esoteric paper colors.
- gallerytungsten 10y agoIn addition to the other replies, Final Draft gives you "industry standard" formatting; and easy file interchange within the industry.
- smonff 10y agoI find it interesting that the author also mentioned pieces of scrap paper and that some pencil-on-paper have been chosen as illustration for this post: I regret to always conceive things on my computer, because I know that there are special things in the creative process that are easier to drop on a piece of paper than on a file. But for the final presentation as these codified movie scripts, you better produce something very clear.