3 ms·

http://ciphermysteries.com/2014/02/21/stephen-bax-voynich-manuscript http://ciphermysteries.com/2014/02/21/stephen-bax-voynich-ma... is critical of the approach

• raverbashing 10y ago
  This critique seems harsh, maybe dismissive, but it has some merit (then again I don't know much about the VM) All the gallows pointing at the same letter is indeed something problematic and that the other video pointed in this thread come to the same conclusion (that is, they mean different things) His point 6 is addressed by the other video pointed in this page (basically the repeated letters should have an 'r' between them) Point 1/3 might be fair, 2 is just nitpicking, 7 might be an issue but then this is not looking at a picture of a plant, but rather a bad illustration
  • deleted 10y ago
    [deleted]
• beevai142 10y ago
  Link to the rebuttal by Bax, for completeness: https://stephenbax.net/?p=275 https://stephenbax.net/?p=275