3 ms·
> How can we be sure what caused the increase in fires? We can't be sure from this data, but there is a very plausible causal model that leads from drought to
by lisper 10y ago
> How can we be sure what caused the increase in fires?
We can't be sure from this data, but there is a very plausible causal model that leads from drought to fires. It just seems highly plausible that drought over woodland would result in more fires. But I don't have access to that data at the moment. Anecdotally I can tell you with high confidence that the Gatlinburg fire, and most of the recent mega-fires in California, as well as the one up in Canada that made the papers a while back, were all associated with not just drought, but historic drought. That might just be a coincidence, but until someone actually runs the numbers you can't assume that.
In any case, it is pretty clear that something has changed. Do you have a better theory to offer?
- CamperBob2 10y agoIn any case, it is pretty clear that something has changed. Do you have a better theory to offer? That's not how this sort of debate works. Not when you're demanding trillions of dollars' worth of global economic rewiring.
- lisper 10y agoThat is exactly how a scientific debate works (or at least how it's supposed to work): hypotheses are advanced, the ones that can be rejected out of hand as non-explanatory or at odds with known evidence are rejected, and then experiments are designed to select among the remaining candidates. If there is only one hypothesis that survives the first stage of the process then it wins by default until someone comes up with a better hypothesis. The basis on which I say this (aside from having done a lot of reading on the philosophy of science): I used to be a scientist working for NASA. I was not a planetary scientist, I was a computer scientist, but I was doing research (in AI), writing grant proposals, etc. My productivity was measured in peer-reviewed publications. So I have some first-hand insight into how the process works, how it is supposed to work, and how these two things often differ.
- inimino 10y ago> it is pretty clear that something has changed You don't just jump into a debate about someone's scientific integrity with unrelated web links and speculation that you just pulled out of your ass, and then back out with "well we can't be sure, what do you think?"
- lisper 10y agoI'm not backing out of anything. I still believe that the author's claim that the evidence is "scant" is demonstrably wrong, I just can't demonstrate it right now because I cannot find a low-bandwidth source of drought data, so I'm having to rely on proxies. But proxies are still data. Instead of leveling ad hominem attacks at me, why don't you go look up the drought data?
- CamperBob2 10y agoInstead of leveling ad hominem attacks at me, why don't you go look up the drought data? Ah, another rhetorical ping-flood attack, forcing the recipient to do the research necessary to dispute a vague positive claim.
- lisper 10y ago> forcing the recipient to do the research necessary Normally I would agree with this, but there are extenuating circumstances here. I'm not fobbing the research off on you out of laziness, I'm doing it because drought data is voluminous, summaries turn out to be very hard to find, and I'm on an extremely slow internet connection. But I did finally find this: http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/cas/adai/papers/Dai-drought_WIRES2010.pdf http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/cas/adai/papers/Dai-drought_WIRES201... > to dispute a vague positive claim My claim is not vague. It is very specific: the evidence that climate change is increasing extreme weather events is not "scant".
- inimino 10y agoI don't think getting into the minutiae of drought data, or the causes of wildfires, is going to get us anywhere. The claim that evidence is scant or not would need to take into account all the evidence on the effects of climate change on current weather events. You could cherry-pick tons of evidence to support either position, if that's your thing. If you wanted to shed some light on the topic of the article, it would be more interesting to see what the author's background is and follow up some of the claims about why he was fired by 538, whether he is being unfairly attacked in the media, etc. Remember that this article isn't primarily about the science, it's about the journalism. The only reason we are talking about wildfires is because you brought it up, which was really quite a stretch.