4 ms·
In fact this is why I take the fear mongering around climate change with a pinch of salt. I agree with Popper's definition of science: https://en.wikipedia.org
by cm2187 10y ago
In fact this is why I take the fear mongering around climate change with a pinch of salt.
I agree with Popper's definition of science: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability
A discipline is scientific if it is possible to challenge it, if it can be proven wrong (it doesn't mean it will, but there is a way to prove it wrong).
If the discipline is using political pressure to prevent anyone from doing so, it cannot be called science anymore. A political movement would be a more appropriate term.
And more generally, my profession (finance) is making extensive use of mathematical models to model something too complex to be understood perfectly (financial markets / the economy). But we know our models suck, because we could do experiment on them, we can test them against reality. We know we can build models or investment strategies that do great in back-testing but fall apart as soon as they go live (I have seen that so many times first hand). I give very little credibility to someone who comes up with a complex mathematical model that pretends it will predict the climate in 30 years, knowing that we will only know if his model was reliable in 30 years, we have no way to test it now. Therefore it cannot be falsified and therefore I don't think it is science.
- Hondor 10y agoAny prediction requires us to wait to see what really happens. I don't think it's fair to say that 30 years is too long to wait and that it's therefore not falsifiable. Science has made claims in the past that took much longer than that to prove false, but we still accept them as falsifiable and that they were valid science at the time.
- cm2187 10y agoWhat sort of claim do you have in mind? I can think of scientific theories that have been proven wrong after a long time, but they haven't been proven wrong because it was impossible to prove them wrong immediately. Only because it took so long to come up with an experiment / better theory which in insight could have been done on day 1. This is not the same as telling everyone "I have a model, my back-testings are telling me it works, I will only be able to prove it right (or wrong) in 30 years, but you need to take actions now based on what this model says".
- gizmo686 10y ago>What sort of claim do you have in mind? Gravitational waves. Higgs boson. Relativity.
- wallace_f 10y ago'Waiting 30 years to measure the earth's temperature and weather patterns' is hardly a controlled experiment. You have exogenous variables (volcanic activity, sun activity, the earth's normal variations in temperature) and for how many years would you propose to measure this activity--you'd need a statistically significant sample. Why? Because the earth's weather patterns can fluctuate--i.e. you could have a year with severe weather with or without climate change. To the best of my knowledge, a better scientific experiment would be having ~30 earths with 1 climate policy, ~30 earths with another climate policy, and yet another control group. There's a big difference between saying "we scientifically know emitting pollutants into the atmosphere has certain unintended/undesirable consequences, and we're uncertain of the harm so we should stop," and "we know global warming will create extreme weather patterns that will destroy the world's economy and kill billions of people"--I have heard people tell me of these doomsday scenarios, even here on HN. Politics always exist to serve self-interests. Ask yourself whose are served by this movement.
- candiodari 10y agoDo we get to apply that standard to past IPCC predictions too ? Reality is that the current temperature anomaly is -far- below IPCC 1990 predictions. So ... falsified ? It is, in fact, so that the temperature anomaly is below every IPCC prediction of more than 5 years back, best case scenarios, with the lone exception of the 2010 report's optimistic prediction for last year (2016 however is out of the 95% interval of that one too, unless something drastic happens). There are reasons for this. Such as that there was a bit of a pause in global warming from late 90s to late 00s. But the fact that the models failed to see this coming, and only incorporated it afterwards of course is further indictment of those models. It kept warming, mind you, except perhaps for 1 year, just way, way slower than predicted. There is a joke that the IPCC now must be correct for the next 22000 years. Why ? That's the only way to make their 95% certainty predictions actually be true in 95% of the cases, given one prediction every 5 years. And this is not the only consideration. Obviously things like the Kyoto accords were based on these predictions. They turned out wrong. So should we now abandon those accords and laws, at least until the evidence can be examined ? That would be very scientific, or at least, it would be very scientific the way I was taught statistics. To say that this would be politically problematic, a lot of work and very, very, very impractical is an understatement. And of course, more recent science cannot be used until there is enough evidence to support the correctness of the model. Normally one would say, half to validate, half to be used. The problem is that you cannot trust researchers who've seen (and evaluated) against all data they've seen. So you need to use future data to validate models, but of course all IPCC models so far have crashed and burned in that comparison. So you cannot just say "let's just use the 2015 predictions", because if you just put down the temperatures from last year for the next 100 years you would have done better than the IPCC, so far (meaning even outirght climate deniers' models would easily have 95% accuracy one year out). And that then violates intuition. The graphs show a clear and consistent rising of temperature for coming up on 160 years now. Obviously the truth is that we don't know why, or at least, not to the level of detail required to predict the effect of policies we implement. Now of course, both cause and effect seem obvious - BUT the models fail to predict effect given cause, so technically a mathematician should use the notions taught in philosophy of science, as applied to statistics, and reject the models. One would be obliged to point out that maybe the models are wrong because their assumptions are wrong, or at least inaccurate. I would say that we should just train everyone in how to analyze the data, but I realize it's not very practical. Plus it would actually mean climate change would be tempered (one would hope that policies would be moderated given that the predictions they're based on turned out to be overly pessimistic). All this is ignoring theoretical problems, the most obvious one is that these models are based on statistics. Statistics that studied cause and effect in a situation ... that no longer exists and very likely will never return. We are using models to predict the future based on values that lie outside of the range they were modeled on (predictions out of range is one of the statistical fallacies: you cannot model based on data between 0 and 10, then have confidence in predicting what happens at 15. Everybody does do that of course, but it's wrong, as obviously the distribution of your source data is different from the prediction data. But we don't have data with the same distribution, because the situation is new). Technically that means they're wrong, period. What do we do with that ?
- inimino 10y agoThere is real science being done, and there is journalism, doing a generally poor job of reporting the science. And then there is politics. If you let the journalism blind you to the science, then you're going to be misinformed. Read the IPCC reports cover to cover, and then follow up with the references if you don't think there is real science being done.
- reitanqild 10y agoAgree. Reading just the primer is way better than starting to argue with even HN about this. Problem us either is HN and Ars Technica are very political or techies and science lovers has started abandoning their love for evidence to participate in "troll hunting" not just blatant trolls but also anyone who asks any critical question. And, as a former sceptic: from the outside climate science seems cult-like :-/ (That said, even as a former sceptic, I have advocated cutting the dependency on fossil, I do have all my shares in solar etc.)
- cm2187 10y agoAnd there are many other good reasons to cutting our dependency on fossil fuel. Limited supply, geopolitical implications, and simply quality of air. I am not convinced that electric cars pollute less overall, as they will become obsolete much faster than a normal car, and I understand the batteries are problematic to recycle, but at the very least it creates pollution in low population density areas, rather than under the nose of tens of millions of people, including people with asthma, etc.
- triplesec 10y agoGenuine request: what kinds of conversation / arguments tend to work for people who think science is cultish, and might help it to seem less so. This is of course for those willing to engage with you rationally? (although counter-emotive arguments are also good, and maybe more effective). I have a Republican friend who will engage with my and she sees a 'groupthink' problem. Your advice may be invaluable in helping to open up discourse.
- 10y ago
- wallace_f 10y ago> I agree with Popper's definition of science: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falsifiability > A discipline is scientific if it is possible to challenge it, if it can be proven wrong (it doesn't mean it will, but there is a way to prove it wrong). Thank you for that. I feel relieved (and on HN, a little bit personally vindicated) for seeing this. In the past I've posted 'about taking the climate change alarmism with a grain of salt.' I've had people attack me personally for that. I've had people write to me on here about 'Mad Max' scenarios, and that climate change could lead people to resort to nuclear war. The fact is that greenhouse gas emissions leading to long-term temperature rise is what is science. The alarmism, Mad Max scenarios, and the idea that technological progress will not be able to help us adapt (or what is especially heretical, reap the rewards of new resources: countries are already beginning to squabble over these, yet even mentioning they exist garners immediate scorn for expressing such a blasphemous idea--it does not garner informed debate!) is what is politics. That said, I agree with the author we should take action against climate change: we have a long history of basically screwing up our environment on earth, we should try to tread more carefully in the future. The whole thing also reminds me of what some criticized the War on Poverty for: the industry has become a movement of individuals whose careers and institutions have, perhaps, become more important than the underlying cause of the movement itself. Trying to express these ideas reminds me of this quote: > All truth passes through three stages. First, it is ridiculed. Second, it is violently opposed. Third, it is accepted as being self-evident.
- cm2187 10y agoAgree, there are many good reasons to reduce pollution. The first of which is not to live in a toxic environment, health issues, inconvenience, etc. But I cannot take seriously the UNFCCC agreement in Paris, where countries were negotiating fractions of a degree celcius like if it was something tangible and deterministic.
- inimino 10y agoIt's a proxy for painful changes that will require hard political work. If they used equivalent tons of carbon dioxide, the same discussions would be taking place, so what's your problem with it?
- crusso 10y agoI try to tell people the same thing. I have been involved with RF modeling scientists as a supporting software developer. I also learned that models tend to stink and it's only through painful reality-based tuning that they start to do okay in very limited domains. Long-range claims based upon climate modeling seem to far outstrip the current state of the art. Given the complexity of the problem, it's not at all surprising - but most lay people (even the technology-savvy) don't seem to see the probable gap between reality and the models.