4 ms·
I read your consciousness post and will reply here because that thread is already locked. I think the problem of consciousness comes from its definition. The wo
by visarga 10y ago
I read your consciousness post and will reply here because that thread is already locked. I think the problem of consciousness comes from its definition. The word consciousness is too large, encloses too many aspects of cognition, religion and philosophy to be useful. It's a suitcase word, reifying various meanings into one name.
What we need instead of "consciousness" is a set of concepts:
- "perception" - means representing inputs in such a way as to be able to adapt to the environment to achieve goals (I place qualia here)
- "judgement" - the ability to select the best action for the current state
- "reward" - comes from time to time, and is used as a signal in behavior learning
These three concepts : perception, judgement and reward are simpler, clearer and less ambiguous. They have implementations in AI, not human level yet, but getting there. These concepts make the problem concrete instead of bringing up 2000 years of attempts to "get consciousness" based off armchair philosophising.
A more interesting question than "what is consciousness?" would be: what are the reward signals that train the human brain. We do Reinforcement Learning in the brain, but the reward signal is complex, made of multiple channels, which are evolutionarily optimized for our survival. It's the engine of drive that puts us in motion. We need to reverse engineer that in order to replicate human consciousness in silico.
Consciousness is a replicator, a system that is concerned with survival and maintaining balance in the face of perturbations and entropy. What it does is to make us go find food, make babies and protect from danger - essential actions without which the human species would disappear, and consciousness with it. Or, in other words, it maximizes its rewards over time, reward being having food, shelter, company, access to learning and a few more. But it's just limited number of reward types, and they are much simpler to understand than consciousness itself.
So consciousness is just that thing that maintains itself instead of becoming disorganized and dissipating out like most physical processes that lack a self stabilizing, self replicating dynamics.
Consciousness is a balancing system for the colony of cells that just want to pass their genes into the next generation.
- logicallee 10y ago>Consciousness is a balancing system for the colony of cells that just want to pass their genes into the next generation. is there anything in that which requires that it be a physical biological substrate rather than a model? Can't computer models follow the same behavior as long as that's how their environment / system is set up? (More specifically, can't they also have brains made up of cells connected to each other, in a way closely analogous or even an exact simulation of chemical pathways?)
- visarga 10y agoI think there is absolutely no need for the system to be biological. A computer model can work just as well. As long as it solves the same behavior problem, there is no difference between brain reinforcement learning and artificial reinforcement learning.