4 ms·
Keep in mind he openly disclosed in his first post that he bought EMagin and is hoping to pump up their stock price by saying Magic Leap may be using microdispl
by cma 10y ago
Keep in mind he openly disclosed in his first post that he bought EMagin and is hoping to pump up their stock price by saying Magic Leap may be using microdisplays or other tech instead of scanning fiber projectors.
That isn't illegal if he isn't lying or anything, but whether he is right or not, he isn't an unbiased source.
He was also eviscerated here and never replied, though he replies to almost every other reddit comment:
https://www.reddit.com/r/magicleap/comments/5c337v/magic_leaps_videos_appear_to_be_using_oled/d9uokuq/ https://www.reddit.com/r/magicleap/comments/5c337v/magic_lea...
(disclaimer: I own a small amount of EMagin from before his post)
- kguttag 10y agoHi, I'm not sure what you think eviscerated me. My information is factual. I try to answer all responses but I am getting a LOT responses and I may have missed some at reddit. It is best to go to the comment section on my site. It turns out that Magic Leap does use Mico-OLED in one of its prototype, but they are also using DLPs and LCOS. My subsequent posts point this out. I warned people that it was just a hunch. I kept my stake in eMagin at least for the time being, but as I said it was a small stake for me. BTW, my website is down right now. I found out that there was a lot of traffic from Hacker News while trying to see what was going on which is what brought me here. I'm on hold with tech support right now.
- cma 10y ago>I'm not sure what you think eviscerated me. After he showed you the caption on the images all you came back with was a statement (via an edit to your post) that the first image was still an "artists concept" (it isn't, highlighting the projector's field of view and pointing out that it was done in the caption isn't anything like an "artist's concept"). And then for the second image you said it "might be real." That means you are essentially accusing the researchers and saying they "might" be faking the second image and committing research fraud. Their caption says, "the bottom photo is unaltered." (shameless edit: I have VR and mixed-reality experience including relighting the real-world with game-engine lighting. If any Magic Leap guys are browsing the thread and looking for third party content devs or recruiting, send an email to mljobcandidate@gmail.com!)
- jv22222 10y ago+1 for the hustle and, yes, I'm expecting down votes ;)
- kguttag 10y agoYou are shameless alright. OK, I was answering a lot of questions that day and I went to the direct links the person gave to the jpeg images and not the paper. The first one was obviously altered but the picture I saw did not have the caption. Same for the second, I never saw the caption or that paper before I went back to check tonight. As for speckle, it would not have shown up in the low resolution pictures. It might also not be there due to the vibrating fiber (some types of vibration will essentially eliminate speckle but usually it has to be the screen that is vibrate). BTW, my website may be down for a while.
- dang 10y ago> You are shameless alright You're of course welcome to comment here, but HN commenters are required to remain civil and substantive, and especially to refrain from personal attacks. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html
- kguttag 10y agoThe person implied I was a shameless, a liar, and that I was eviscerated. I was just using his words back.
- kbenson 10y agoNo, they stated you may be biased and were eviscerated (which I interpreted to mean your views were throughly disproven). They laid out evidence that they believe points to you being wrong. Their postscript regarding being shameless is a self depreciation that applies to their self promotion, not you. It's a fairly factual and benign set of comments to my eyes.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- snissn 10y ago> he isn't an unbiased source. No one ever is What I've learned - I think - is that the magic leap video demos use a totally different technology than that which they hope to bring to market -- seems pretty analogous to Theranos to me.
- cma 10y agoThere's bias and then there's financial bias. Here's the kind of thing he has been writing on reddit: >I'm driven by facts and evidence and not by some big name person investing money. These people sometimes invest based on ego (which pretty much explains Google Glass). I would suggest you watch the movie "The Big Short" (not totally factual but it gets the point across). [1] My eyes rolled when I read that quote from him: he started his whole debunking-Magic-Leap blog series by making a disclaimer that he was buying eMagin and trying to pump them up by showing that Magic Leap might be using them. Only egotists would invest in hyped-up Google glass! That's why he wishes he did: > The last time I played this game of “what’s inside” I was the first to identify that a Himax LCOS panel was inside Google Glass which resulted in their market cap going up almost $100M in a couple of hours. A little bit of ego there, huh? Why, he was personally responsible for $100M of market cap and wishes he could have bought in so that he could dump the position during the hype, knowing that Google Glass itself wouldn't take off in the long run. And even after missing out on that opportunity, he missed another: >About the time Himax stock hit its high, I found out about the Seeking Alpha article and posted a comment reiterating what my blog post had stated that I didn’t think the Himax panel was used in the newest prototypes (there were also comments from others stating the same). Himax then stock dropped back about 16% or about $135M in market cap. (Gad, I should have shorted before I wrote that comment ). None of this is some huge moral indictment; just be aware the guy is now openly thinking along these lines when he writes technical analysis on his blog. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/magicleap/comments/5fyq6b/some_more_info_on_the_state_of_fiber_scanning/dao4lds/ https://www.reddit.com/r/magicleap/comments/5fyq6b/some_more...