3 ms·
I think if you read the essay you might get the idea that he wasn't being entirely serious and re-read it again in that light.
by empath75 10y ago
I think if you read the essay you might get the idea that he wasn't being entirely serious and re-read it again in that light.
- kurthr 10y agoI fear we have run into Poe's law here... that sufficiently advanced humor/sarcasm is indistinguishable from arrogance. If his contemporaries truly reviewed him as a humorist, “done in an admirable manner, in a strain of exquisite humor, with a strong undercurrent of delicate satire against the follies of the times. Then there were the interspersed observations, speculations, and suggestions upon dress, fashions, food, dwellings, furniture, &c., &c., sufficiently queer to keep the audience in almost constant mirth…The performance has created ‘quite a sensation’ amongst lyceum goers.” then it does truly seem that I've learned (and been taught) the very antithesis of his meaning. The joke was on us!
- hkt 10y agoIt is so easy to read him as a prototype of modern I suppose it comes down to whether or not works should stand on their own. I know nothing of Thoreau or his life, so inferring whether or not he's a witty social commentator (which I wouldn't, based on experience) or a stuck up brat is very difficult. I'd say work ought to stand on its own on that basis, although maybe I'm being a lazy reader.