4 ms·
It really has been an education watching all the Apple shills stumbling over each other in their rush to defend this transparently absurd claim. Nobody has show
by cageface 17y ago
It really has been an education watching all the Apple shills stumbling over each other in their rush to defend this transparently absurd claim. Nobody has shown more reckless disregard for backward compatibility than Apple in the modern Jobs era. The idea that they'd let the discomfort of any number of Mono or Flash developers hold back their plans is ludicrous in light of their breakneck pace of incompatible change.
The loads of shovelware in the app store put the lie to the quality claim so let's just focus on what's right in front of our faces. This is all about raising the barrier to writing cross-platform apps and locking down Apple's control in the emerging mobile computing market. The dishonesty with which this naked power grab is sweetened has a positively Soviet flavor.
- gabrielroth 17y agoNobody has shown more reckless disregard for backward compatibility than Apple in the modern Jobs era. Well, their record on backward compatibility is mixed -- Carbon, Classic, and Rosetta spring to mind -- but let's stipulate that the above is true. Apple has been able to make major changes to its platform because they're not beholden to any incumbent developers. Microsoft and Adobe have a certain amount of sway, but not enough to keep Apple from improving the platform. Now they're trying to extend that independence into the iPhone/iPad era. What's dishonest about any of this?
- cageface 17y agoSo I'm supposed to believe that Apple was prepared to force all its developers to do two complete rewrites (os 9 -> os x, carbon -> cocoa) and port to a new ISA and break compatibilities across every one of its 10.x releases but they're just too polite to tell a bunch of Flash developers to get stuffed if their Flash app breaks in the next iPhone release. Remember, these will, by definition, be apps of inferior quality since they're not Obj-C so it's even less plausible that Apple will worry about breaking them, if you take them at their word. Ask any developer of audio units, for example, how worried Apple is about forcing them to rewrite code every time there's a new Logic release.
- MaysonL 17y agobut they're just too polite to tell a bunch of Flash developers to get stuffed if their Flash app breaks in the next iPhone release. They don't give a damn about most developers: what they don't want is a whole bunch of pissed-off customers whose games (and other apps) broke when they upgraded to iPhone OS 5.0, because Adobe didn't get around to it.
- gabrielroth 17y agojust too polite to tell a bunch of Flash developers to get stuffed Nobody said anything about politeness. Where is Apple pretending that this policy is about anything other than maintaining control of the platform? The fear isn't that they'd have to be rude. The fear is that, if Flash apps for iPhone/iPad became a huge successful popular segment of the market and Flash didn't keep up with iPhone OS, users would have to choose between not upgrading and breaking their apps. Apple doesn't want that. Therefore, no Flash. It's a policy that's better for some people (e.g. Cocoa Touch developers) and worse for other people (e.g. Flash developers). Some users will prefer it this way; other users would be happier the other way. But the decision is made by Apple, and Apple's making the decision based on its perception of its own interests, and no one is claiming any different. It's fine for you to object to the policy, but I really don't understand the accusations of hypocrisy.
- thought_alarm 17y agoWrite-once, run-anywhere is a lie. If Apple wanted to really hurt their developers, they would allow the App Store to be ruined. Flash developers are not entitled to placement in the App Store, and there isn't a single App Store developer who would look forward to an influx crappy Flash apps. You can talk about hypothetical scenarios all you want, but as long as the iPhone and the App Store remain immensely popular with developers and users it's very hard to argue that Apple is doing it wrong.
- theBobMcCormick 17y agoBut the influx of crappy iFart apps is O.K.?
- thought_alarm 17y agoNot it's not. You obviously don't understand how the App Store works or the lengths some developers and marketers go to abuse and game the App Store. That's why Apple has taken a number of steps to curb the abuse and help promote serious higher-priced apps over the volume of 99-cent apps. It's what developers want and it's what users want. Yet the peanut gallery always howls at these App Store "restrictions". Like I said, as long as Apple continues to manage the App Store properly it will continue to be immensely popular with developers and users. And the people who don't understand it will continue to criticize it.