3 ms·
Another proposed solution for buffering wind and solar energy is https://www.ecn.nl/news/item/energy-train-de-revolutie-voor-energieopslag/ https://www.ecn.nl/n
by Someone 10y ago
Another proposed solution for buffering wind and solar energy is https://www.ecn.nl/news/item/energy-train-de-revolutie-voor-energieopslag/ https://www.ecn.nl/news/item/energy-train-de-revolutie-voor-...: a train going round in a 5km diameter circular vacuum tunnel doing up to 2000km/h.
That hasn't been built yet (it seems more or less at the 'back of an envelope' stage to me) and would be more expensive to build, but it promises to store quite a bit more energy (20 GWh vs 12.5 MWh), so it might be cheaper per kWh.
I also think it can be built using existing technology and will be safe enough if the tunnel is built underground (derailments would be catastrophic)
One problem is that this only works at scale. Halve the diameter of the ring, and you likely have to halve the top speed of the train, decreasing capacity by 75%.
- dmurray 10y agoIs this like a very heavy flywheel?
- Someone 10y agoIn a sense: yes. Heavy, large, and all its mass is near its rim. For a flywheel, it's not _that_ fast, though; only about 125 revolutions/hour. They got rid of the forces acting on the center of a flywheel that tear apart large fast flywheels by getting rid of the axle and using a rail on the outside of the wheel to counteract the centrifugal forces. I would guess they want to use maglev as a rail system, as a conventional track may break down too soon at 2000 km/h. On the other hand, it is 'only' 15 km of rails in a controlled environment, and they can use enormous wheels, so it may be possible to lay conventional track a lot smoother than outside.
- nickparker 10y agoThat reminds me of a more 'out there' energy storage mechanism I've looked at a couple times: Hyperloop If you've got a large Hyperloop network with hundreds or thousands of ~40,000 kg vehicles shooting through it at 700 mph, each of those is 400 kWh of stored energy. Of course, it'd be crazy hard to actually use because demand for travel on the network isn't gonna be constant, but it's an entertaining thought.