4 ms·
The article is wrong in one very important detail regarding the Federal Arbitration Act. The author states, The legal basis for outsourcing legal proceedings
by wahern 10y ago
The article is wrong in one very important detail regarding the Federal Arbitration Act. The author states,
The legal basis for outsourcing legal proceedings is a 1925
law passed by Congress specifying arbitration as an option
for “merchants” who agree to a private alternative.
Actually, nowhere in the statute is the word merchant or merchants used. That word is used in the legislative history (i.e. the debates and arguments). But from the plain text of the statute, a layman reading would have it apply to all commerce that would otherwise be governed by federal law. You have to rely on some presently out of favor legal interpretative devices to believe that the law should only apply between merchants.
The _real_ issues are,
1) What kinds of commerce are reachable? This bill passed in a time when the Federal Courts held a substantially narrower interpretation of Congress' powers over commerce. And even proponents of modern, so-called plain text interpretation usually admit that in some circumstances, especially involving constitutional issues of powers, you want to see a more clear articulation of an intent to extend power so broadly.
2) SCOTUS upended over half a century of settled precedent. First when it held that the FAA was enforceable in state courts applying state law, and again when it decided that state law defenses to enforceability (i.e. state-specific definitions of unconscionability) could not be used.
3) Deciding that state law defenses are not useable is ironic give the plain text limitation that arbitration agreements are enforceable "save upon any grounds that exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract". There's a sound argument that this exclusion doesn't capture state-based grounds. But that argument necessarily depends on the historical legal context--at the time the law couldn't have reached nearly as much commerce as SCOTUS allows today. And it wasn't until 1938 until Erie Railroad v. Tompkins exalted state law in choice of law matters.
These details matter because if you try to debate the Federal Arbitration Act with knowledgeable defenders you lose all credibility by repeating falsehoods like the author did. We really need change in this regard: 1) stop so-called tort reform, and 2) fix SCOTUS' error in applying the FAA so broadly. It helps if people stick to facts.
Many conservatives love the FAA; and many conservatives love so-called tort reform. But the inevitable outcome of both these things will be centralization of consumer protection in federal government agencies. A modern democracy simply won't stand-by while corporations cheat and injure people. The question is, which system do you want:
1) One that is decentralized, relatively equitable (1000 years of careful balancing of interests between plaintiff and defendant), and with more freedom for states to experiment, or
2) One that is centralized in a few government regulatory bodies, where the little guy will almost always get screwed, and businesses are subject to the whims of each passing administration on major issues, turning every major business dispute into a political issue.
The latter is what you get when you take away the ability for people to seek out individualized justice in the courts. And the outcome will not (and is not) good for anybody.
- pessimizer 10y ago> A modern democracy simply won't stand-by while corporations cheat and injure people. This is essentially a religious belief.
- pmarreck 10y agoJust world fallacy, perhaps. ;) "The karma will get them eventually!!"
- wahern 10y agoNo, it just follows from the definition of democracy. If McDonalds starts shooting every fifth customer in the head, no matter how deeply in the pockets the police and legislators are, in a functional democracy representatives will be responsive to the electorate to some substantial degree. But note that what change the electorate gets might not be very effective. It might be just barely adequate, or it might just obscure the problem. And that's my point: conservatives are taking away the tools to seek out justice. Liberals are replacing some of those tools, but the newer tools suck. They'll not only be less effective in protecting consumers, but they're likely to be even more stifling to business. Everybody will be worse off. Regulatory agencies are worse for business because unlike courts, regulatory agencies can _prevent_ businesses from innovating on the pretense of consumer protection. While as a general matter courts can only respond to manifest harm. Because regulatory agencies don't and cannot provide individualized justice, when they work well to protect consumers they do so by being overly protective. Usually it's beneficial to society to let businesses take more risk as long as they can compensate those people who are harmed. I'm not saying regulatory agencies are always a bad idea, just that vesting the power in consumers to sue on their own behalf, and relying on them to do so, is a much more powerful mechanism for correcting bad behavior than people think. It's administratively inefficient in many respects, but at least it's uncoupled from politics and more directly tied to manifest harms. I think in real economic terms it's less costly for society.
- emodendroket 10y agoThe problem with this line of thinking is that McDonald's has a team of people to lobby tirelessly on their behalf and individual voters don't really know or care about these issues until they're affected personally. So by one small change after another the court system can become less and less favorable to individuals by very small steps. The idea that regulation is becoming more stringent is simply not borne out by reality.