7 ms·
I'm curious where the profits accrue in the real-estate industry. It's a manufacturing industry where we have relatively advanced machinery to build the houses
by nostrademons 10y ago
I'm curious where the profits accrue in the real-estate industry. It's a manufacturing industry where we have relatively advanced machinery to build the houses themselves; you'd think that the cost of housing would have dropped the way, say, cars or silicon has. But it hasn't: the price of housing has largely been flat or increased. Usually when this happens, it's because there is some monopoly scarcity in the value-chain that allows the producer at that level to reap large profits, eg. Microsoft and Intel in the desktop software value chain, or Apple in the mobile ecosystem.
I'd thought that real-estate developers were that scarcity in the housing value chain, but this article suggests that they struggle to break even. Who is it? Construction and real-estate brokers can make a lot in boom times, but they tend to lose it to the cyclical nature of the real-estate industry, so I don't normally think of them as the ones getting rich. Is it Caterpillar, making the heavy equipment used by construction? Land owners, who can keep land supply off the market? (But then, the price of raw unimproved land basically tracks inflation, indicating a competitive market.) Property managers? Is there artificial scarcity enforced by transportation infrastructure - the article indicated that one of the developer's primary constraints was the need to build near light rail?
- maxerickson 10y agoI think the light rail thing is so that they get a higher development cost. The simulator mentioned in the article says it costs $9 million to construct 50 units. That's $180,000 per unit, which seems like it must have some regional peculiarity to it (you can buy a new 3 bedroom house for less than that in many areas). Hopefully they are at least pretty nice apartments.
- ido 10y agoI suspect Denver isn't one of those places tho. In which city as major/prosperous as Denver can you buy a 3BR house for less than $180k?
- maxerickson 10y agoThat's what I mean by regional peculiarity. Housing is especially expensive in Denver, and likely even more so near public transport. I'm sure the building boom going on there has some impact on all construction costs. Before I posted I did a sanity check. You can buy a decent new house in the Orlando area for $120,000. That's with a lot and so on. A better study would examine the cost of housing across a variety of job markets, not pick 1 and make units with high proximity to mass transit the only units they talk about.
- ido 10y agoWow, I had no idea Orlando was that cheap (I'm not American and most of my American friends/colleagues are from much more expensive cities). In Berlin you generally can't buy a 3BR anything (house, condo, whatever) for less than $400k (aside from terrible/out-of-reach neighborhoods), and even that would be on the cheap-side.
- maxerickson 10y ago$120,000 might be too low a number. $150,000 is certainly defensible. (You can jump the reply restriction by clicking on the comment timestamp; The delay in showing the reply link is there to provide some friction when threads are going too fast.)
- roel_v 10y agoHouses get bigger and use more expensive materials and fitout that increase the comfort of the inhabitants. Building a house now to the standard of say 50 years ago is either impossible because of building code, or doesn't pose a sufficiently attractive value proposition to convince buyers. In other words, a house and a house are two different things.
- fma 10y agoNot necessary more expensive. Roof cost in terms of labor and material is lower. https://www.thehousedesigners.com/articles/prefabricated-roof-trusses.asp https://www.thehousedesigners.com/articles/prefabricated-roo... Builders also cut corners. Example, my 1974 home has the AC condenser on a concrete slab. My new 2015 home it's on a piece of plastic supported by dirt. Guess which one is noisier. Garage doors are now styrofoam, unlike solid wood in the doors of the past. Hence its cheaper, and your garage opener doesn't need to be as strong so that is cheaper too. Hardwood floors can be engineered hardwood, while the past was only solid wood. Significant savings in material and installation. Land lots are getting smaller too...here in Atlants, developers are buying up older homes and putting up several home, dividing the lot up.
- gozur88 10y agoLand lots are getting smaller, but houses are getting larger. The average new home in the US has increased in size by 1000 sq ft since 1973. http://www.aei.org/publication/todays-new-homes-are-1000-square-feet-larger-than-in-1973-and-the-living-space-per-person-has-doubled-over-last-40-years/ http://www.aei.org/publication/todays-new-homes-are-1000-squ...
- betaby 10y ago1) This study was proven flawed, because of definition 'home'. It does not include condos, and nowadays that's significant. I remember long threads about it on other 'forums' 2) More correct metric would be m^2/person and m^2/adult and that metric is in constant fall. Can't recall exact numbers, it is now somewhat 25-30% less m^2/person than it was in 70-s. Also, see UK and most of Europe, shrinking is a common trend for a very long time http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2398714/The-incredible-shrinking-houses-British-homes-built-just-HALF-size-1920s.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2398714/The-incredib... "The average new British home is now just 925 square feet – barely HALF the size they were in the 1920s"
- bufordsharkley 10y ago> But then, the price of raw unimproved land basically tracks inflation, indicating a competitive market. This is true looking at all land, as recent articles by Robert Shiller indicate[0], but especially valuable land has outstripped inflation by many, many times-- in the Bay Area, for instance, land value has increased by a factor of 10X in recent decades (or significantly more, depending upon neighborhood). The only thing that keeps land in check is the ability for land to sprawl out into previously marginal land, and our ability to commute from where we are sprawling to is reaching a breaking point. (I know people commuting from Tracy to SF, which is hell.) [0] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/17/upshot/why-land-may-not-be-the-smartest-place-to-put-your-nest-egg.html?smid=tw-share http://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/17/upshot/why-land-may-not-be...
- sarcher 10y agoSome of the better returns, in my limited experience, are reaped by land and under-improved property speculators/developers (development, I this case, referring to lot subdivision or other methods of locking in construction approvals above and beyond existing by-right approvals). Another large proportion of potential profits are destroyed by the regulatory process because by-right approvals are often extremely limited and easily challenged by third parties. I'm a huge fan of communities being able to shape their built environment, but making most development approvals into a lengthy, expensive series of challenge/response hurdles rarely leads to progressive outcomes. Lastly, project delivery timelines can de-sync with economic cycles due to long developent periods and the timeline of construction itself. Since construction starts typically lag economic booms, people take losses due to this off-cycle behavior more often than they realize unusual gains. I work in a small construction market though, so my experiences may not carry well to the more populous parts of the USA.
- maxsilver 10y ago> I'd thought that real-estate developers were that scarcity in the housing value chain, but this article suggests that they struggle to break even. Who is it? The real-estate developers are still the scarcity in the chain. They make the money -- and lots of it. They just don't make that money on affordable housing for the poorest of people without government subsidy. Which is why that stuff almost never gets built. But they make a good chunk of cash on government subsidized housing (anything with Brownfield credits, for instance) and they make a lot of cash on luxury units. I'm in a small city in the Midwest, and condos here are selling for $300k - $600k despite way-below-average land and labor costs. There's 20-40% profit margins in those units, no one is loosing any money there.
- yourapostasy 10y agoThe asset inflation that a good chunk of that profit derives from (because so much of real estate vitally depends upon transaction churn) is in the dirt, not the structures on top. Verify this for yourself by looking at fire insurance: it hasn't nearly increased coverage amounts by the same growth as real estate in general. Any taxpayer-based bond issuance for infrastructure of water, wastewater, roads, electrical, data, and emergency services is a giant externality that developers pay only a tiny fraction of by comparison, and the developers capture a big bite of the profit up-front on the initial sale. Taxpayers end up footing the risk cost of anticipating the network effects of the build out will pay off the projects. This is compounded by the car-centric American culture imposing infrastructure costs that go up as the square of the expansion, but by and large cost recovery and operational costs are comparatively linearly composed because American suburban and exurban developers tend to sell low-density in the first pass greenfield development (large lots, fewer people per acre) to sell their book and cash out fast. NIMBY politics then gridlock densification later, so you get all this infrastructure that is now spread among fewer taxpayers than you need to effectively not only pay it back, but properly maintain it as well. The real estate industry enjoys enormous subsidies that really distort the market, and if you aren't in the industry this basically translates as monotonically increasing land prices (which most people interpret as constantly-increasing housing prices). Much of the dysfunction is likely to entrench and get much worse in the future, and won't stop until a really ugly, sharp dislocation happens.
- skewart 10y agoI used to work in the real estate development industry. The best returns are almost always made on increases in land value. Who exactly captures that profit can vary a lot. Sometimes it's land speculators who buy land cheaply on the outskirts of growing cities. Other times it's developers who buy a large parcel cheaply and then develop it slowly until by the end it's a much more desirable place for a lot of people and they can sell sell product at premium prices but with a very low land basis cost. More often than not it's property owners - typically REITs for multifamily and office buildings - who benefit from price increases. And they can profit enormously from speculating and trading properties. In a lot of ways the US real estate market is similar to luxury consumer goods markets. People are willing to pay a big percent of their income to live in SF or NYC because those cities have a strong brand. There's a perception of value that goes above and beyond quantifiable quality of life measures. It's not radically different from how people will pay a premium for an iPhone over an arguably equal or better Android phone. Landowners and homeowners can benefit from owning property in a location that commands a brand premium not unlike shareholders in a company.
- morgante 10y ago> It's a manufacturing industry where we have relatively advanced machinery to build the houses themselves; you'd think that the cost of housing would have dropped the way, say, cars or silicon has. I'm not sure why you think that. Unlike manufacturing cars or silicon, housing has very poor economies of scale. Building 10 houses isn't a whole lot cheaper than building 5. It's also a lot harder to make more efficient. Housing isn't manufactured in large factories where you can optimize every step of the process—instead, it's done by lots and lots of local firms. This leads to vast differences in the level of efficiency. There's also the problem that there is still a social stigma against "generic" housing. Having the same phone as everyone else isn't looked down upon, but mass-produced homes carry a definite negative connotation. People look down on cookie-cutter condos or manufactured homes. > But then, the price of raw unimproved land basically tracks inflation, indicating a competitive market. Where on earth are you getting that from? Raw land in the middle of nowhere might track inflation, but land near any jobs center certainly doesn't. That's also the explanation of where most of the profits go: to owners of appreciating land in desirable areas, which is a mix of professional speculators/investors and existing homeowners. Source: Spent Thanksgiving hearing about the frustrations my architect relatives have dealing with different contractors around the country.
- mc32 10y ago>Housing isn't manufactured in large factories where you can optimize every step of the process True it isn't, in large scales but it could be. Both for single family homes (manufactured homes) as well as for high-rises (PoC in China: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/apr/30/chinese-construction-firm-erects-57-storey-skyscraper-in-19-days https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/apr/30/chinese-constr...) or apt bldg. in Brooklyn http://www.forbes.com/sites/erincarlyle/2014/04/16/building-the-worlds-tallest-modular-apartment-tower/#4b63ed235913 http://www.forbes.com/sites/erincarlyle/2014/04/16/building-...) but most people aren't just into "utility" and want something which projects themselves and their values and sensibilities.
- niftich 10y agoPrefabricated housing [1] was also employed in Europe after WWII to accommodate the demand for housing in and around cities as many headed from rural areas to cities for work [2]. The social connotation usually varies by neighborhood, as with other types of housing, and merely living in a prefab flat is not commonly considered undesirable. Although most often found in the former Warsaw Pact countries, they are also fairly common in Sweden [2] and France [3]. The same can be said about Hong Kong [4] and Singapore [5]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panel%C3%A1k https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panel%C3%A1k [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Million_Programme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Million_Programme [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banlieue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Banlieue [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Hong_Kong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Hong_Kong [5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Singapore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Singapore
- leakybit 10y agoPeople don't expect to get a return on investment with cars and silicon. Really if you think of it, there's wide spread market manipulation being performed by the public, local, and federal government.