3 ms·
Not a New Yorker, but living in the middle of the East Coast I've been to, done business in, and toured NYC many times. The Financial District is cool, but why
by bane 10y ago
Not a New Yorker, but living in the middle of the East Coast I've been to, done business in, and toured NYC many times.
The Financial District is cool, but why anybody would want to live there who doesn't work there is beyond me. It's a short walk from any of the residential areas to any of the major financial firms, it's a miserable slog anywhere north of Chinatown.
And it's not like it's cheap, 800sq ft 1 bedrooms run well above a million dollars.
There's other problems which, at this point, seem to matters of inertia rather than planning:
- NYC is one of the few, dense, major cities without service alleys for trash pickup and delivery. A casual observer might notice that NYC blocks are solid, not hollow, the middle is still full of building. In other cities, with other designs, an access alley allows for service vehicles to enter a mid-block courtyard to provide service functions. As a result both delivery vehicles and waste vehicles block the street with both their presence and the materiel they move in and out.
- The regulations around inspection scaffolding are absolutely out of control rent-seeking. I would be comfortable in saying that there isn't a highrise block of the city that's doesn't have this scaffolding present on it. While it does provide some minimal protection from the elements, it's more like walking through a construction site than a an arcade. The regulations should either be changed to get rid of this nonsense, or to make formal arcades a requirements, thus presenting new facades to the city. I'd actually be in favor of the later since NYC suffers from pretty much the worst of all seasons: cold and wet in the winter, and hot and miserable in the summer.
I love love love NYC, but it's not without its imperfections.
- krschultz 10y agoThe requirements around scaffolding are kind of an annoying middle ground of rent seeking. You are required to put them up, but then you aren't charged enough for them while they are up to incentivize anyone to take them down. In some cases the scaffolding goes up and the company that owns it goes out of business or the contractor goes bankrupt and it just gets left there.
- bogomipz 10y agowho is doing the rent seeking though? For years they would leave the scaffolding up so they sell advertising on it and the fine was laughably small compared to the revenue generated from selling ads. That was outlawed a few years back though. This is an interesting look at the phenomenon: http://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20160124/REAL_ESTATE/160129960/scaffolds-are-everywhere-in-new-york-city http://www.crainsnewyork.com/article/20160124/REAL_ESTATE/16...
- mnutt 10y agoIf you want to live in Manhattan, the Financial District is actually one of the more reasonably priced neighborhoods, especially if you want new-ish construction and amenities. It also has some of the best subway access. From my apartment, I'm a few blocks from every major subway line.