3 ms·
A news story that the Pope endorsed Trump is fiction and should be labeled as such. That has political implications because everything does. But evaluating con
by snowwrestler 10y ago
A news story that the Pope endorsed Trump is fiction and should be labeled as such.
That has political implications because everything does. But evaluating content based on those implications, rather than on the actual facts, is a categorical error.
We label fiction and nonfiction in libraries, book stores, movies, magazines, etc--basically every other medium for accessing content. Why not Facebook too?
- ikeyany 10y agoHow do you define fiction? "The Pope endorses Trump" would be labeled as fiction. But what about "The Pope endorses [some of] Trump's views"? Or "The Pope is a bigger fan of Trump than you think"?
- jamespo 10y agoHow about start with the most blatant examples... like spam detection
- snowwrestler 10y agoFacebook is not even addressing the most blatant, obvious fake news. In fact, they do the opposite: they promote it to millions of people. Or more accurately, they permit their software to do so. And they claim they have no responsibility, even though they built the entire thing.
- orionblastar 10y agoFacebook does not want to lose revenue from advertisers that submit fake news articles. I saw the BS News extension it checks each link for citing known fake news sites in their article. It is not practical as I keep seeing new fake news sites popping up from nowhere. Just register a domain, install Wordpress, write some articles and then pay for advertising on Facebook. Fake news sites got Trump elected by saying false things like the Pope supports him. It is serious when people only use Facebook as their only news site and read and believe without checking the facts first. If I were to make a fake news site detector I'd have it search Snopes and Politifact and others to see if it has been already reported as false. Basically the way it ends up is a new way to censor the news using AI. Suppose instead of a black list of sites they use a white list of trusted sites? Then block any new sites until they can verify them as trusted?
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoYou didnt answer my question at all: how does Facebook, prior to the political decision of how to determine what facts are, know that the Pope endorsing Trump is fiction?
- contras1970 10y agoSo... When have you stopped beating your wife?
- snowwrestler 10y agoDetermining what facts are is not a political decision. Decisions with political implications are not the same thing as political decisions. Huge categorical difference, in fact.