4 ms·
I went to grad school in English Lit and this resonated with me: "By the time I started to draft journal articles and map out my dissertation, I became frustra
by jseliger 10y ago
I went to grad school in English Lit and this resonated with me:
"By the time I started to draft journal articles and map out my dissertation, I became frustrated by having to write articles no one else would read that had to cite other articles no one else would read in order to satisfy peer reviewers and engage in a process that seemed internally self-justified to fill CVs and have an academic career but didn’t have much effect." He found more satisfaction writing his blog, which reached readers around the world.
I wrote more about the issue here: https://jakeseliger.com/2012/09/22/the-stupidity-of-what-im-doing-and-the-meaning-of-real-work-reading-for-phd-comprehensive-exams/ https://jakeseliger.com/2012/09/22/the-stupidity-of-what-im-... and here: https://jakeseliger.com/2013/02/12/a-lot-of-academic-research-may-barely-count-as-research-by-many-definitions/ https://jakeseliger.com/2013/02/12/a-lot-of-academic-researc..., but academics in the humanities act like their peer-reviewed work doesn't matter at all. There are no pre-print services and no sense of urgency. Whether an article is published today or five years from today seems to be of no importance. The whole system is wildly dispiriting from an intellectual perspective.
Teaching, meanwhile, gets subordinated to the world of fake research, to the detriment of professors themselves and the students they're supposed to be teaching.
- sndean 10y ago> Teaching, meanwhile, gets subordinated to the world of fake research, to the detriment of professors themselves and the students they're supposed to be teaching. This was pretty eye opening for me in grad school when I saw that, after certain professors received a windfall of grant money, they would buy their way out of teaching. (This was in a biochemistry dept.) It seemed very backwards to me that the professors that were doing some of the best work of their careers would pay to avoid interacting with students. The ones that had to teach classes to grad students were the ones who haven't published anything in 10 years.
- aaron-lebo 10y agoThe flip side of that is the almost predatory nature of professors looking for the best student that they can co-opt to work on their own research. Sometimes it seems like the only reason undergraduate and graduate classes exist are as a place to gather herds of students and pick the best.The others fall through the cracks.
- throwaway3h09ha 10y agoI know this isn't a popular view, but why would you want to distract yourself when you're doing real impactful work? If you were working at a startup would people accuse you of neglecting students, as if doing the best work in the field, like a startup, doesn't use up most of your time? I talked to a former academic who did amazing research, got multiple best paper awards, and then because of some personality conflicts in her department she got forced out over her teaching philosophy (in part because she was making people look bad by comparison). It seems like the teaching thing is mainly orthogonal to doing good work, other than for recruiting, and it's something that people can use against you when your research speaks for itself so strongly they don't have anything on you.
- Jun8 10y agoI got a PhD in EE and wanted to say that this feeling is by no means unique to humanities (modulo, of course, some differences between disciplines, e.g. https://xkcd.com/451/ https://xkcd.com/451/): I remember the first time (many more such moments followed), while hunting down relevant references for a paper I was writing through stacks, and stacks of volumes of IEEE Transactions on PAMI, Information Theory and what have you at Purdue's Potter Engineering Library (pre-XPlore days) and suddenly being struck with the understanding that 99.9% of these articles would not be read by anyone and my painstakingly polished paper will be among these, if it's accepted, that is. Years later, toward graduation, I heard of a practice that empirically tested this assertion: Colleagues putting $20 bills into the bound version of their theses that were placed in the library to see if they were consulted by students.