14 ms·
> Just to get to his apartment in the financial district, he has to contend with hordes of commuters and selfie-snapping tourists clogging narrow sidewalks. So
by TulliusCicero 10y ago
> Just to get to his apartment in the financial district, he has to contend with hordes of commuters and selfie-snapping tourists clogging narrow sidewalks.
So make the sidewalks wider. I can think of nowhere in the US more appropriate to allocate more space to sidewalks than Manhattan.
> Ms. Starr, for one, has all but stopped using the Citi Bike system to commute. She used to ride from her apartment in TriBeCa to her office on Maiden Lane in the financial district nearly every day. But as more pedestrians and cyclists filled the streets, she had to concentrate to avoid running into anyone or being run into.
Sounds like they need separated bike lanes then.
Manhattan is the densest major city* in the country. The amount of space allocated to cars on the roads should be the bare minimum: enough for emergency vehicles, business deliveries, surface transit, the handicapped, a limited number of taxis. With only a tiny amount of space per person, you really have to push for denser forms of transportation. Personal vehicle use should be at a minimum in Manhattan.
> In Lower Manhattan, people are not the only obstacle. Construction on streets and buildings is everywhere. A labyrinth of imposing metal scaffolding hems in available walkways and forces pedestrians closer together, or into the street.
The solution here is to cut into space on the road to provide more walking space.
* I know it's only part of a city but you know what I mean
- BorisMelnik 10y agoHave you seen the streets in lower Manhattan? If they get any narrower there wouldnt be any room for cars. There are also already tons of bike lanes. Most New Yorker's don't drive - they walk, bike, take the train, or taxi/uber. Don't you think if the answers were this simple someone would have done this already?
- marxidad 10y agoThe problems may be more political than technical.
- the_gastropod 10y agoAs uncommon as car ownership is in NYC, it's incredible how much friction there is around reducing roadway for cars. Every bike lane added in the city is a hard fought battle. So I think you're absolutely right—the solutions are well understood. Changing car culture is difficult.
- superuser2 10y agoPerhaps because while most people don't own cars, they do depend on them (even if only in special circumstances) in the form of cabs.
- bradleyjg 10y agoIf that were what was mostly going on there'd be a heck of lot less on street parking. Essentially none of Manhattan should have any on street parking at all. Some standing zones for deliveries and pick up / drop offs (but not loitering forever, I'm looking at you black cars) and that's it. You'd be able to cut width of a typical street by 1/3.
- duaneb 10y agoYou don't understand why people might like cabs, trucks, busses, and emergency vehicles? People don't drive their own cars already.
- acdha 10y agoNone of those need street parking – in fact, you'd dramatically improve their experience if the parking lanes were replaced with dedicated transit / bike lanes, etc. and a few dedicated taxi/etc. loading spaces. One of the reasons for this is that street parking is usually subsidized well below the market rates and so drivers will spend a significant amount of time looking for a cheaper parking space rather than simply parking in a garage, and they're using road capacity until they either find a space (and then block the lane while they slowly attempt to parallel park) or give up and pay to park off-street: “In 2006, surveyors interviewed drivers stopped at a traffic signal in the SoHo district of Manhattan, and 28 percent reported they were cruising for curb parking. A similar study in Brooklyn found that 45 percent of drivers were cruising. The same results might be found on many other streets in New York because off-street parking is generally far more expensive than on-street parking. In midtown Manhattan, for example, the price for the first hour of off-street parking is often about $20, while curb parking is only $1. Parking for an hour at the curb saves $19, but drivers first have to cruise to find a space on the street.” http://shoup.bol.ucla.edu/CruisingForParkingAccess.pdf http://shoup.bol.ucla.edu/CruisingForParkingAccess.pdf
- philipov 10y agoGetting rid of cars is a feature, not a bug.
- jinushaun 10y agoI think getting rid of cars isn't going to fix the problems the people in this article are complaining about. It's the age old problem that plague all popular cities around the world: tourists versus residents. And having visited places like Florence, Paris and Barcelona, I'd rather see the residents get their way.
- baron816 10y agoResidents aren't the ones with cars. No one in this area own a car.
- ghaff 10y agoExcept the residents (and workers) use taxis, Ubers, black cars, etc. And, as the article notes, the local businesses need to get deliveries, repair people, etc. I would guess the issue doesn't come so much from owners' private cars traveling through the area. I was adding that I made the mistake of passing through Times Square on my way to some destination a number of months back. As in the article, you literally could not walk on the sidewalk which was effectively blocked by the mass of people. Times Square (like areas of downtown) is an extreme example, but things do get really crowded. (And you can't just do away with road traffic there. You're at intersection of two major N-S avenues.)
- macNchz 10y ago> Have you seen the streets in lower Manhattan? If they get any narrower there wouldnt be any room for cars. It'd be well within the realm of reason to consider closing a bunch of the narrowest/most heavily foot-trafficked streets in lower manhattan to cars and only allowing delivery trucks during certain hours of the day. It's an extremely impractical place to drive anyway.
- pm90 10y agoI would imagine the advent of delivery drones would be a nice solution to getting supplies in and out of dense urban areas, after which there would be no need for allowing vehicles (other than emergency or public transportation).
- notliketherest 10y agoYeah good luck getting a drone to deliver a 400pound pallet of soda.
- nashashmi 10y agoThe biggest delivery truck traffic is for furniture, goods (one or two UPS trucks for an entire building), or garbage. No amount of drone tech can reduce/eliminate truck traffic for an entire building.
- TillE 10y agoThe slightly more sane idea would be to look in the other direction, and build underground. That would be extremely expensive and have to deal with all sorts of issues, but at least it's physically possible. The actually realistic solution is to focus on developing housing and infrastructure in the outer boroughs; Brooklyn and Queens are full of the absolute worst kind of inefficient quasi-suburban accumulated sprawl.
- krschultz 10y agoOr build the street up 1 level and have an underground level on the current street - isn't this basically how Chicago built sewers?
- kartan 10y ago> If they get any narrower there wouldnt be any room for cars. Relevant: http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-36791485 http://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-36791485 "A spokesman said the project would contribute to the mayor's aim of improving air quality and make Oxford Street "a far safer and more pleasant place to visit"."
- TulliusCicero 10y agoOh really, tons of bike lanes? Well, there are at least an order of magnitude more car lanes than bike lanes, so surely reallocating some of them for bikes will be no problem then, since there's a veritable smorgasbord of space for cars as it is. Bike lanes can handle much higher peak loads of people, so they're a more efficient use of space. > Most New Yorker's don't drive - they walk, bike, take the train, or taxi/uber. Yes, and those non-car modes should obviously have more surface space. If way more New Yorkers walk than drive, why is there more street space for cars than peds? > Don't you think if the answers were this simple someone would have done this already? No. Politically it can be very difficult to take space away from cars, even when it's obviously the right thing to do.
- finid 10y agoIt would be actually easy to take space from cars in boroughs other than Manhattan. It just takes some push and a champion.
- notJim 10y agoReally? I had the opposite experience. If you take away even one parking spot, people in Brooklyn go absolutely insane. The city was considering putting in bike lanes in my neighborhood, and tons of people showed up to the meeting in opposition to it. They all had their own reasons, but it was pretty clear that the 2 real motivations were a general dislike of cyclists, and a desire to not lose parking spots. http://gothamist.com/2016/06/22/yell_louder_cyclists.php http://gothamist.com/2016/06/22/yell_louder_cyclists.php
- dispose13432 10y agoWhy doesn't someone just build a huge commercial parking lot, and rent out parking spots? In a dense city like NY, it may actually work
- scott_s 10y agoThere's parking garages all over the city.
- baybal2 10y ago>If they get any narrower there wouldnt be any room for cars. Americans like gigantic cars. They need to make them smaller, like in Japan
- MrFantastic 10y agoNarrow lanes decrease car speeds and reduce accidents and fatalities.
- kruhft 10y agoGet rid of cars in the area? The area is easily walkable for its size. Doesn't Paris do this downtown?
- apaprocki 10y ago> So make the sidewalks wider. To be fair, almost all of that mass of people is found on Wall/Broad Streets right near the NYSE, Federal Hall, Trinity Church. All of the relevant part of Wall/Broad was shut to vehicles after 9/11. The entire width of the street from sidewalk to sidewalk is essentially one big sidewalk. > Sounds like they need separated bike lanes then. The city does have them, in the modern avenues and streets where they could take back a lane and install them. On the avenues, they're even separated from traffic by a parking lane. The issue is that in the oldest parts of the city (FiDi area) dating back to the 17/18th centuries, you can't just will the buildings to move and make wider streets. > Personal vehicle use should be at a minimum in Manhattan. The vast majority of people use subways and buses :) Nearly every subway line has a stop within 2 blocks of the area mentioned in the article. There's also multiple ferry stops and even a helipad!
- jinushaun 10y ago> The vast majority of people use subways and buses :) Nearly every subway line has a stop within 2 blocks of the area mentioned in the article. There's also multiple ferry stops and even a helipad! Exactly. If you pay attention to the cars on the road, personal vehicles aren't the problem. There are simply that many taxis, ubers, buses and delivery trucks.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoTaxis are still more or less personal vehicles in terms of density/efficiency.
- redblacktree 10y agoExcept that they don't park.
- mnutt 10y agoI live down here (a block up from Wall St) and the only place on Wall that I've had any issues with has been the barricades put up after 9/11 in front of 1 Wall that narrow the foot traffic down to a single (often covered in scaffoding) sidewalk. Otherwise, Wall is pretty navigable. Come to think of it, the only other place where it's unpleasant to walk is over on Church by WTC where there's only a single sidewalk. Hopefully all of that opens up soon.
- jinushaun 10y agoLower Manhattan is the historical city center. You can't simply "make it wider" any more than you can make historic Rome or historic Paris "wider". Even if you make lower Manahattan pedestrian only, that won't fix the congestion problem because New Yorkers already regularly walk on the roads when there isn't enough room on the sidewalks. In other words, the sidewalks are already "wider". This is also why adding dedicated bike lanes is tricky. Bikes are avoiding pedestrians on the road/bike lanes, not other cars.
- baron816 10y ago>So make the sidewalks wider. I can think of nowhere in the US more appropriate to allocate more space to sidewalks than Manhattan. I live in the Financial District and I agree this is needed. They should ban street parking in the area and use the extra space to widen the sidewalks.
- bogomipz 10y agoAnd when delivery trucks can't get to restaurants and Mom and Pop stores then what happens? What happens when a fire truck or ambulance needs to get to someone or some place in an emergency?
- mnutt 10y agoDelivery trucks already just drive on the sidewalks, and illegally parked cars/trucks already impede fire trucks and ambulances. None of those parking spaces are ever open to delivery trucks, they're occupied 24/7. Eliminating street parking would just get rid of a row of parked cars.
- illumin8 10y agoIt's actually very crazy. I've witnessed delivery trucks double park and instantly get parking tickets. I think (and the article seems to confirm it) they just look at the ticket as a price of doing business in NY, and pass it along to their customers. The city actually could really enforce this by towing these trucks, which would put a stop to this practice, but they are probably addicted to the ticketing revenue and don't want to put a stop to their "free money." Then there is the problem of how would the restaurants and stores get their inventory if the delivery trucks are effectively banned from parking? It seems like there might be a great technological solution that involves rooftop deliveries by drone, but that is probably some years out, and likely to be stifled by paranoid regulators that don't like the idea of UAVs flying so close to skyscrapers, especially in an area that is constantly under the threat of terrorist attack.
- 10y ago
- bogomipz 10y agoSince you speak as someone who doesn't seem to know Manhattan at all: There are already dedicated bike lines. The article even states: "But as more pedestrians and cyclists filled the streets, she had to concentrate to avoid running into anyone or being run into" A contributor to that crowdedness is the amount of other bikes and pedestrians. And why on earth get rid of Taxis? There are plenty of legitimates needs for Taxis. Trains break regularly and there is always MTA maintenance where your train is not actually running or the route is being altered during maintenance to the point that it can't not get you where you need to go. Taxis are still the best way of getting to and from the cities airports. Lower Manhattan is the oldest part of the city, the streets like John Street and Nassau mentioned in the article are typical of the area. They actually predate cars. They are single lane streets that are the narrowest in the city. They were designed during the era where horse and buggies were the dominant mode of transport. It is not possible to widen the side walks. So no the solution is not to cut into space on the road. Those roads have businesses on them that need to get deliveries. While I am big proponent of alternative transportation, just blindly stating "more bikes, less cars!" is a hugely naive oversimplification.
- devb 10y agoAs someone who does, in fact, know Manhattan quite well, you have to be kidding. Nassau Street has parking on both sides for most of its length. John Street has parking on one side. There's no reason that empty car storage couldn't be sacrificed for expanded sidewalks and dedicated bike lanes.
- bogomipz 10y agoWith the exception of the one block stretch between Pine and Liberty, Nassau street doesn't have parking on both sides of the street. In fact when you get to Pine there's a security barrier and there no parking or cars allowed - all the way past the stock exchange. For those who don't know how ridiculously narrow the streets are down there this a typical stretch of Nassau Street: https://www.nybits.com/images/photo/nassau_street_01.jpg https://www.nybits.com/images/photo/nassau_street_01.jpg So how do deliveries work to businesses on Nassau Street when you eliminate parking? They don't matter? What happens to the price of goods when their delivery becomes much more expensive? The block that does have parking on both sides of the street on Nassau is used extensively for deliveries. In fact if you do a Google Street view of it you will see a Fed Ex truck parked there. Arguably an important thing in an area that is largely financial companies and law offices.
- spyspy 10y agoMTA is already wildly overburdened. As much as I hate cars in NYC, you can't just eliminate an entire form of transportation without thinking of the consequences.
- treve 10y agoI don't think a change like that would happen without people thinking of consequences though.
- bsg75 10y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/local/trafficandcommuting/metro-sank-into-crisis-despite-decades-of-warnings/2016/04/24/1c4db91c-0736-11e6-a12f-ea5aed7958dc_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/trafficandcommuting/met...
- treve 10y agoSounds like they thought of the consequences and didn't heed the warnings ;)
- bogomipz 10y agoYes thank you. But as you can from the comments here. If your views disagree with the "more bikes no more cars!" knee-jerks reactionaries you are branded a subhuman. It does not matter if you disagree for reasons that are based in practicalities and not ideological ones. But more people will down vote you rather than engage in a dialogue. Yet everyone like to complain that Facebook is the echo chamber.
- ju-st 10y agoIt's always the same in HN threads discussing differences between Europe and USA. These kinds of "discussions" are reminding me about Parkinson's Law of Triviality.. people on HN discuss topics they know only little about the most. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_triviality#Examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_triviality#Examples)
- mc32 10y agoThey could also consider elevated walkways for businesses and other public places in places where converting streets isn't a viable option.
- kbenson 10y agoThis is what I was thinking. I believe the movie Her uses an ultra-dense future Los Angeles where the main (human) character lives and works in high-rises, and walks between them on elevated walkways[1] as the location. An elevated walkway that zig-zagged across the road and had stairs to the regular sidewalk once or twice a block seems like an interesting approach. 1: http://static.srcdn.com/wp-content/uploads/her-joaquin-phoenix-31.jpg http://static.srcdn.com/wp-content/uploads/her-joaquin-phoen...
- mhenr18 10y agoIt's fairly common in Hong Kong's denser parts like Central. I was able to get around much of the heavily trafficed areas without needing to be at street level.
- notjustanymike 10y agoIt's the oldest part of New York, and many of the streets in the financial district are as small as they can get. Parts of FiDi are reminiscent of old European cities. You can not narrow the remaining streets without introducing significant congestion; one does not simply shrink Broadway. Downtown is also a major turnaround point for traffic, and significant commuter hub. It's too simplistic to suggest narrowing the streets without considering the impact it has on the rest of the city. That southbound traffic has to go somewhere, and your solution would probably just bump the traffic problem elsewhere. As mentioned, there are separate bike lanes, but also quite a few suicidal pedestrians. I used to commute by bike from Wall Street, and the danger was always a pedestrian on their phone. In other words, this is a complicated problem where all solutions can have negative consequences.
- TulliusCicero 10y ago> You can not narrow the remaining streets without introducing significant congestion; one does not simply shrink Broadway. You're stuck in the traditional American mindset of only thinking about cars. Yes, congestion for cars might go up. But you're not taking the space and throwing it into the ocean; it's going to other, more space efficient modes. Total congestion, then, goes down. In Manhattan of all places, worrying about car commuters seems hilariously misplaced. This area has the best transit in the entire country. People will adapt.
- baybal2 10y ago>Yes, congestion for cars might go up. If you do not use cars, car congestion goes down
- vidarh 10y agoCongestion for cars in most dense cities tends to stay pretty much constant: Add lanes, and car use goes up until congestion is pretty much back to "normal". Close lanes and more people pick alternate modes of traffick until congestion is back to normal. Which is one more reason to not pay attention to car congestion when deciding what to close, and instead make such decision based on how congested the sidewalks and public transport is.
- finid 10y agoSo make the sidewalks wider. That tells me that you haven't been to (Lower) Manhattan. Most of the streets there are narrow, and the sidewalks just as narrow. There's barely any room for expansion.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoSo take a car lane and use that space. Surface transportation land use is necessarily zero sum. As you get more and more people, the only rational course of action is to take space away from low efficiency modes and give it to high efficiency modes.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jccalhoun 10y ago>So make the sidewalks wider. I can think of nowhere in the US more appropriate to allocate more space to sidewalks than Manhattan. I wonder how much that would solve and how much it would make worse? I think that I've heard that adding more lanes to roads can make congestion worse because more people use the roads. I wonder if the same would be true for pedestrian walkways?
- kbenson 10y agoEven if you accept that as entirely true, that likely means more people walking instead of using cars, and since cars use far more static and dynamic space (negotiating obstacles/other cars), eliminating even one lane and filling it with walking traffic would likely be a very large net win.
- htrp 10y agoAt the rate you go, you would have to turn entire areas of Manhattan into car free zones. They proposed congestion pricing but that died quickly.
- up_and_up 10y agoMaybe they need to implement Super Blocks [1]. Focus traffic to specific streets, open up entire streets to pedestrians and bikes. I was recently in lower Manhattan and I was struck by the sheer number of sidestreets. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/02/nyregion/what-new-york-can-learn-from-barcelonas-superblocks.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/10/02/nyregion/what-new-york-can...
- erjjones 10y agoThere is a lot of free space above the street. Go up for pathways.