Totally agree that it is indeed "our loss". No argument there. I don't want to appear a kook, so I won't relitigate what I said in another reply. But essential

Totally agree that it is indeed "our loss". No argument there. I don't want to appear a kook, so I won't relitigate what I said in another reply. But essentially we do want to give back. We just aren't always able to give back everything (at least not right now). AGPL, like GPL, is all or nothing in that way. I don't get the option of giving back something, then giving back more later (OSS is threatening to some people - I have frequent discussion at work re why we give anything at all back). Your software, your rules. You have every right to take this all or nothing position! More power to you. But assuming that anyone that doesn't like AGPL does so because they "want to use someone else's work while hoarding [their] own" is, respectfully, a simplistic and stereotyped point of view.