10 ms·
Open Letter to Steve Jobs (and a reply)
- kgrad 17y agoCould someone please explain to me how Flash isn't open? To my knowledge, everything about flash is open other than Adobe's IDE. The spec has been released, the sdk is OSS and anyone is free to compile to SWF... Am I mistaken here?
- pmjordan 17y agoThe player certainly very much isn't open, aside from the Tamarin runtime.
- kgrad 17y agoCan you qualify that statement? edit: You are correct, the player provided by Adobe is not open. However, anyone is free to make their own player, one alternative player is Gnash: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gnash http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gnash
- pmjordan 17y agoI can. "License: Proprietary freeware EULA" on http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flash_Player http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flash_Player And the argument that anyone is free to re-implement is just as valid for anything. The fact of the matter is that thousands of man-years have gone into building Flash Player, and replicating them is far from a straightforward task. The spec is huge, and there are millions of .swf files to which an alternative implementation needs to be compatible. It's a bit like suggesting someone re-implement Windows if they don't like Microsoft's version of it. It's open, right? Anyone can look up the ABI for user space executables, kernel drivers, etc., so how hard could it be? ReactOS (or Wine) hard, as it turns out. Note also that for the supposedly open components, Adobe controls them so tightly, they are only "look but don't touch" open. Openness is only useful insofar as you can actually do something with the information or code. They maintain this control precisely because they have an iron grip on the player. There is no point for a third party to extend the Flash spec or compiler, because they can't realistically build an implementation that actually runs code obeying the forked spec. It's as ridiculous as creating a driver to run on a hypothetical version of Windows. Yes, you can do it, but it's also completely pointless.
- kgrad 17y agoThanks for the link, you are certainly correct that adobes player is proprietary, but I provided you with a link to an alternate player... Just because something is hard to reproduce doesn't make it closed. Do you consider java closed because Sun/Oracle makes the best applet viewer? I am not trying to say Adobe is guilt free or anything, but it looks to me like they are making it as open as they can, unless I am missing something.
- jorgecastillo 17y agoJava is licensed under the GPL.
- pmjordan 17y agoNo, I consider Java to be open because it is licensed under the GPL, an Open Source/Free Software license. but it looks to me like they are making it as open as they can With all due respect, you're either trolling or extremely ignorant for someone reading HN. In case of the latter, please educate yourself and read up on the difference between proprietary and open source software. Also take note that "freeware" does not fall under the definition of "open" software. FWIW I will flag any further trollish comments.
- kgrad 17y agoI am sorry if you are offended by my ignorance. I am not currently arguing that the flash player provided by adobe is open. I conceded a while ago that the flash player provided by adobe is proprietary. However, an alternate flash player exists and you can program SWF without ever touching an Adobe product. There is a spec and open tools for doing so. I was simply under the impression that Flash was open minus Adobes implementation and am trying to see why everyone is saying it is not. edit: I don't understand why me disagreeing with you automatically makes me a troll. People are quick to jump on people who don't agree with their viewpoints.
- jorgecastillo 17y agoAdobe Uses DMCA On Protocol It Promised To Open http://yro.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=09/05/22/1254246 http://yro.slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=09/05/22/1254246 How do Gnash developers work with the Adobe/Macromedia EULA? http://www.gnashdev.org/?q=node/25#eula http://www.gnashdev.org/?q=node/25#eula Read this two links and come back to discuss about flash openness.
- kgrad 17y agoedit: apparently adobe did open the RTMP spec? http://www.adobe.com/devnet/rtmp/ http://www.adobe.com/devnet/rtmp/ How does Gnash being built without Adobe tools do anything but further proving that you don't have to use adobe products to use/work with flash? I am not claiming with authority that Flash is open, I am just trying to see how it is closed. So far it looks open to me. I'm not even a Flash developer, so please forgive me if I am not understanding properly.
- jorgecastillo 17y agoDid you really read the links? I can't do your homework for you. "I'm not even a Flash developer, so please forgive me if I am not understanding properly." Me neither I am just an average guy that likes computers. I am not even a developer of anything. But it is very clear to me that flash is not open and Adobe does not intent for it to be other than for PR. So far I haven't seen evidence to the contrary. If Adobe would open source (GPLv2/BSD/Apache, etc) flash and would give the future development and implementation to an independent party (W3C?) made of various corporations, organizations and individuals that have stakes at flash I'd be all for flash. P.S. I think a BSD/MIT/Apache license would be better.
- Terretta 17y agoConsider the "definition" shared in the letter. Compare that definition to WebKit, then to Flash.
- kgrad 17y agoWhich part of the definition does flash violate? Also, Apple doesn't give much credit to KDE with WebKit, they certainly like to imply that they are very open with it without mentioning its origins...
- jorgecastillo 17y agoDo you work for Adobe? This is your first day commenting and you seem to defend flash as if your life depended on it.
- kgrad 17y agoI don't work for adobe, nor do I even code in flash. I am just ignorant on the subject and wish to be enlightened. edit: it's also not my first day commenting, I just forgot my old account and had to make a new one a little while ago.
- wrs 17y agoI really wish people would stop redefining the word "open" to mean whatever makes them feel good. (Vain hope.) Patents are totally orthogonal to copyrights and standards. You can put the source under whatever terms you want, and get whatever international standards body you want to bless the protocol, and that has nothing whatever to do with the patent troll who will show up the next day and start charging license fees.
- pyre 17y agohttp://www.osnews.com/story/23058/Theora_More_of_a_Patent_Threat_than_H264_Wait_What_ http://www.osnews.com/story/23058/Theora_More_of_a_Patent_Th... For 15 years, Xiph.Org has carefully "played by the rules," fully within the bounds, intent, and letter of intellectual property and patent law. For the past ten years we've informed the entire world, including MPEG LA, of our specifications and algorithms in detail. We've requested in open letters that any group believing we are infringing to inform us so that we make take immediate corrective action. I predict that MPEG LA may counter that they know groups have been pressured into licensing patents in order to use Theora. This has been a recent back-room assertion. You might want to ask point blank if MPEG LA itself or any of its constituent members has engaged in this practice, thus manufacturing the evidence that "vindicates" their patent allegations. I beg you - tell me immediately if you get a straight answer (or good video of any squirming)! I'm sure you can tell I'm a bit peeved; this has been going on for over a decade. It's amazing they've never been called out on it.
- _ivan 17y agoYou shouln't take the word "open" in your mouth, JObs.
- papachito 17y agoI asked on the Theora mailing list their thoughts on SJ's answer and this is what I got from one of the dev: > (...) A patent pool is being assembled to go after Theora and other “open source” codecs now. > I think that's great news... If the "industry" finally compiles a list of patents that they think theora voilates we can: 1. find prior art. 2. work around the possible valid patents. Afterwards all the submarine patents are gone, and we can prove it...
- CamperBob 17y agoAfterwards all the submarine patents are gone, and we can prove it... Well, no, only the submarine patents from MPEG-LA signatories are gone.
- randomposter 17y agohttp://lists.xiph.org/pipermail/theora/2010-April/003766.html http://lists.xiph.org/pipermail/theora/2010-April/003766.htm... also http://lists.xiph.org/pipermail/theora/2010-April/003769.html http://lists.xiph.org/pipermail/theora/2010-April/003769.htm...
- quizbiz 17y agoWhy doesn't he at least say something about Apple's closed ecosystem?
- jsz0 17y agoyou like Openness so much that when you use “Open Source” Software to build your Mac operating system Only some parts of it. The bulk of OSX is closed source. May I remind you that H.264 is not an open standard? Jobs said H.264 is an industry standard not an open standard
- boredguy8 17y agoBut the whole point in this debate is that Flash is also, for better or worse, an industry standard.
- pohl 17y agoIs there a specification? I think "de facto standard" is a more appropriate phrase for Flash.
- vetinari 17y agoYes, there is (http://www.adobe.com/devnet/swf/ http://www.adobe.com/devnet/swf/). It is even available gratis (H.264 specification is not).
- blasdel 17y agoFlash isn't an open standard by any useful definition. Sure they specified the container format and data structures (just like with the MS Office formats), but everybody had figured that part out a long time ago because it's obvious and easy to capitalize on by developing an extractor. The runtime APIs are incredibly hard to reverse-engineer, comprise the vast bulk of the Flash implementation, and are the entire reason for the plugin's instability.
- kierank 17y agoH.264 specification is available gratis: http://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-H.264-200903-S/en http://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-H.264-200903-S/en
- alec 17y ago"A patent pool is being assembled to go after Theora and other “open source” codecs now." That's kind of scary.
- papachito 17y agoActually, theora devs have been asking for the patent pool for a long time so they can work around patents once and for all http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1309412 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1309412 So this is excellent news for Theora, as it could be an end to the "submarine patent" FUD.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- nirmal 17y agoThat's one interpretation. Another is that some other entity is gathering patents to use against Theora.
- alec 17y agoSeems reasonable to assume it's the big player in video patents, MPEG LA. Apple has contributed patents to their pool.
- DrSprout 17y agoIf this is legit, Apple almost certainly owns some of the patents involved, even if they're not the instigator.
- lallysingh 17y agoWhen I read Steve's response, I didn't see anything implying that Apple would be involved. Even if they have some patents, they don't have to enforce them.
- snth 17y agoHe didn't say Apple was assembling this patent pool.
- jamesbressi 17y agoSteve has been quite busy with his email lately. I don't remember him ever doing this much correspondence via email. Very interesting.
- futuremint 17y agoI had the same thought. I think its because he wants to get "Sent from my iPad" on the internet on as many web pages and into as many minds as possible. Its a marketing ploy.
- commieneko 17y agoHe's been doing this for years. I know several people that have gotten terse, 3 or 4 word responses to him. It's only recently that the press and the bloggers have noticed this.
- ErrantX 17y agoI think that, ultimately, Apple have as much ability to define what an Open Standard means as the FSF within the context of what they are saying. As it happens I think I agree with where Jobs is coming from... or rather I think this letter nit picks at a specific phrase (Open Standard) that SJ's was just using in a different way to how the FSF would. Ultimately what Jobs meant by Open Standard was reasonably apparent (for the reasons laid out in this letter!) so nit picking over it seems a meta point.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- madmaze 17y agoProps to Steve to actually answer to this open letter, but i think he could have put a little more effort into it, sounds like he has no confidence in open source. I wish apple would be a little more involved in open source.
- pgbovine 17y agoI wish apple would be a little more involved in open source. hopefully they keep the LLVM team well-funded and give them good freedoms.
- ghurlman 17y agoHe did put effort into it - there's a full paragraph there, Steve's emails rarely go beyond a sentence fragment; rightly so, as I doubt he has the time to research and write out a fully-formed response.
- illumin8 17y agoI think Steve has plenty of confidence in open source. He's just a realist and understands that current software patent law doesn't really allow for completely open video codecs. Even if you create an open implementation of them, you're going to be subject to patent lawsuits, and as we know, most open source projects don't have the funding to withstand the legal battles.
- bingobongo 17y ago"A lot of commercial software comes with H.264 encoders and decoders, and some computers arrive with this software preinstalled. This leads a lot of people to believe that they can legally view and create H.264 videos for whatever purpose they like. Unfortunately for them, it ain’t so. Maybe the best example comes from the Final Cut Pro license:" http://bemasc.net/wordpress/2010/02/02/no-you-cant-do-that-with-h264/ http://bemasc.net/wordpress/2010/02/02/no-you-cant-do-that-w...
- andr 17y agoWhile I agree with the spirit of the message to Steve, the attack on Apple not sharing back open source software modifications is out of place. Darwin is open source. WebKit is open source and actively developed by Apple, giving competitors the ability to quickly catch up with one of the iPhone's biggest advantages. Apple is also the chief contributor to LLVM.
- tsuraan 17y agoWebkit is open-source because the people who wrote it (KDE devs) put it under the LGPL. Apple was playing catch-up, and used the best code base they could to get started. They aren't philanthropists, they are just (grudgingly) abiding by the license of the software they are building on.
- demallien 17y agoMacruby is open source. Apple was under no obligation to open source it, yet they have...
- panic 17y agoIt certainly used to be grudging -- originally Apple just threw a huge clump of code back to the KHTML guys, technically satisfying the LGPL, but not doing anyone much good. That's a far cry from the community they've built around the project now. I wouldn't call Apple philanthropists, but they're not simply following the license either.
- albertzeyer 17y agoThey also could have rewritten that. The original KHTML code is a pretty small part (about 140k loc initially) compared to the WebKit project (about 3M loc). Also, they only really needed to have WebCore and JavaScriptCore open but they decided to make all of WebKit open later on (all the rest under a BSD licence).
- scott_s 17y agoThat's true of all companies that contribute to open source.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- btilly 17y agoHopefully Bilski renders these patent issues moot. I really, really hope that. And if it does, I expect multi-media to improve quite a bit in the next 2 years.
- CamperBob 17y agoI doubt it. Bilski will be decided by SCOTUS in exactly the same way they "decided" Eldred... by punting it back to a very well-bribed Congress. And that won't even be the wrong decision, really. There is no constitutional basis for a ruling on software and/or business-method patentability, one way or the other. It's clear that Congress is supposed to make those calls.
- Quarrelsome 17y agoIf you don't know what "Bilski" is (like me). I founds us a link: http://en.swpat.org/wiki/Bilski_overview http://en.swpat.org/wiki/Bilski_overview
- jcl 17y agoAll video codecs are covered by patents. All the popular ones, maybe. But MPEG-1 is over twenty years old, so unless there is a submarine patent out there, all the patents on it have already expired. Likewise, most aspects of MPEG-2 should be freed up within a decade. Even H.264 will eventually be unencumbered, given enough time.
- blasdel 17y agoOn2 had a pile of active patents covering VP3, which they granted irrevocable royalty-free licenses to when they abandoned it to become Theora. Nobody's ever done codec development without either filing a ton of patents or at least publishing rigorous documentation to establish prior art (Dirac). Some of those patents may no longer be in force, but they still exist.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoThe On2 patents on VP3 only covered some optimization techniques and are not required to implement VP3 or Theora.
- PontusVull 17y agoThe writer seems to think that an open standard must be free of cost but is that actually true? Or is it just what many would like to be true?
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoMost standards, up until the turn of the century, were required by governments to have RAND licensing terms in order to prevent abuse of market power. That's Reasonable And Non-Discriminatory, so you could charge fees but couldn't mess with competitors. Governments are now pushing for Open Standards which must be RAND-Z or RAND-RF. Z stands for Zero cost, RF for Royalty Free. These Open Standards make much more sense for software or services delivered at low or no cost via the web, or as Free or Open Source software.
- tlb 17y agoh.264 is far, far more open than Flash. What matters is that the spec is public and that you can choose from many implementations. There are no usable competing implementations of Flash, but dozens for h.264 including excellent open-source ones. The h.264 terms aren't onerous. If you ship less than 100,000 devices you pay nothing. At large scale, it's $0.10 / unit. When selling hardware, that's a pretty light tax. As Jobs points out, Theora is not immune to patents. On2's many patents are irrevocably licensed for free, but there are thousands more patents that may apply held by trolls. It sucks to ship devices with unknown patent liabilities. It almost destroyed RIM, for example.
- dhimes 17y agoHere's a summary of the license terms: http://www.mpegla.com/main/programs/AVC/Documents/AVC_TermsSummary.pdf http://www.mpegla.com/main/programs/AVC/Documents/AVC_TermsS... Let's say you make videos and sell access to them on your web site on a title-by-title basis :) Videos <= 12 min, no charge. Videos > 12 min, USD $0.02 per title or 2% of access price, whichever is less.
- cpr 17y agoOh, maybe that's the basis of the general YouTube 10-minute limit...
- dhimes 17y agoPerhaps, but that policy would be forward-looking. Current there's no charge for web delivered content if you don't charge for access.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoIt pays to be forward looking when your supplier reserves the rights to re-negotiate your terms.
- tlb 17y agoRight, 2% is unlikely to change anyone's business model.
- gizmomagico 17y agoOh, who cares about H264 compared to 3.3.1..
- CamperBob 17y agoExactly. This whole video-codec business is a nice bit of deflection on Jobs's part.
- KevinBongart 17y agoI don't get it. In his open letter, Jobs explains why he chose HTML5 and H.264 instead of Flash, and the author here doesn't not answer about Flash but H.264. Even though Theora looks more open than H.264 for video, I think HTML5/H.264 still stands more open than Flash for the entire web. So, yes, Theora sounds cool, but that's not Jobs point. The point is, get rid of Flash.
- morphir 17y agomay I add that software patents are non-existent here in Europe. So a codec made here in Europe should not have to worry about infringing anything..