4 ms·
Kudos for the theme of your analysis, but is Intel really serious enough about the Atom? I haven't looked in quite a while, but when I did one of the big probl
by hga 17y ago
Kudos for the theme of your analysis, but is Intel really serious enough about the Atom? I haven't looked in quite a while, but when I did one of the big problems was that the chipsets they provided were not optimized for low power and consumed more than the processor itself. Have they corrected this, especially for the mobile market?
Then there's the question I have WRT to it being a horse race; as I understand it:
The Atom is in-order superscalar, 64 bit (all recent versions), faster than anything from ARM and consumes more power.
The Cortex A9 is out-of-order, 32 bit, slower than the Atom (don't know how that might play out with ARM 2-4 cores) and of course consumes less power.
On a speed/power basis, ARM still wins.
- ippisl 17y agoI don't know about the chipset issue, and yes this is an important point. But the biggest move that points to the seriousness of their approach , is moving to selling ATOM cores at TSMC. selling cores is a low margin business, but it makes sense to enable fast time to market , and high integration, which are important for consumer products. That of course that doesn't mean that intel would win, but i think they seriously try.
- hga 17y agoWHOA! OK, absolutely yes, Intel is deadly serious about this market given that they did that. On the other hand it looks like they've got a customer demand problem with this attempt: http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/24/a-tie-up-between-intel-and-tsmc-fizzles/ http://bits.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/02/24/a-tie-up-between-in...; the partnership is on "hiatus" as of the end of February but Intel hasn't given up. And on the third hand, much of the commentary I found on the net suggests that Intel has a disruptive technology problem here. Until they have a few notable successes that may be the way to bet, however hard they are trying.
- ippisl 17y agoexcept for tsmc , intel also works hard on developing it's own SOC: "LG Unveils GW990 Smartphone with Intel's Moorestown Platform " jan2010. so intel has one design win for it's platform. Also they have moorsetown-w which supports windows.i wonder what would a windows capable phone would look like.