10 ms·
Zenefits ordered to stop offering free insurance software in Washington state
- koolba 10y agoFrom the article: > “The inducement law in Washington is clear,” Commissioner Kreidler said in a statement accompanying the order. “Everyone has to play by the same rules.” > As a result of the order, Zenefits has worked out a compromise with the State whereby it will offer its software on a paid basis, at a rate of $5 per employee per month. I don't get it. So the rule is that you have to charge your customers something? Why can't businesses get free services off the fat of VC capital? Who's being protected by this besides existing insurance companies that are getting their lunches eaten? Note that I'm not defending any of the other shenanigans that Zenefits has done. I'm just curious what the rationale is for requiring them to charge customers a fee. Anti-dumping laws?
- tombone12 10y agoOffering something for free based solely on big capital sound like the definition of dumping, so anti-dumping laws is probably right.
- stale2002 10y agoTheir business model doesn't rely on charging for HR software. Their HR software is free and will continue to be free forever. This is just a straight up win for consumers. Is Facebook, or Hacker News, or reddit "price dumping" its free software?
- gnaritas 10y agoThose big sites sell users to advertisers, the users of said free software are their product, not their customer. This site is just a hobby project.
- stale2002 10y agoThe same can be said about the Zenefits users. They don't care about the 5 dollars per user that they can make in revenue. They care about the x000 dollars in insurance dollars that they make off of them. The customer is the insurance companies, not the users. The users are the product, so of course they give it away for free.
- pbreit 10y agoBut the marginal cost of the service is near zero. I don't really understand what the rule is. What service must be charged for?
- Thriptic 10y agoThe risk is that a well funded company gives away their product, drives all their competitors out of business and creates a monopoly, then jacks their prices up. It could be viewed as anti-competitive. That being said, I also think this is overkill.
- openmosix 10y agoLike... Google or Facebook?
- reacharavindh 10y agoYes, this looks like a simple effort to safeguard against anticompetitive behavior of a well funded company. I think there should be proper regulation against this sort of freebies. Even more straight forward example would be Uber vs all other ride-sharing companies. They started off offering steep steep discounts to both drivers and riders (from their VC coffers) while running at a loss, making it impossible for any less funded competitor to even think of entering the business. There should be some sort of regulation about starting off free and jacking up prices once the competitors are driven out of business. Or if such already exist, it must be enforced and made more stringent.
- Eridrus 10y agoI don't think Uber's case is more obvious. Uber's business only works at scale, therefore they need to get there and deep discounts to get to scale make sense regardless of competitors. This is particularly clear in the case of Uber Pool which only makes sense with lots of riders using it, which you need to bootstrap somehow, or it will not be feasible for anyone.
- reacharavindh 10y ago"Uber's business only works at scale, therefore they need to get there and deep discounts to get to scale make sense regardless of competitors." Isn't that almost universally true for everything? Is it an acceptable reason to stifle open market competition? I mean think about any other industry. Say a new airline wants to get into business. Is it okay for them to offer $1 tickets (while writing off taxes/airport fees as losses) until they gain enough market share? What would that do to other competitors in that industry?
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoIt would have been interesting to know the history of that law. Maybe if we had that context it would make much more sense.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoMy guess is the incumbents paid off politicians to make regulations benefiting them. Common thing. Microsoft has the lead on that in Washington.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- harryh 10y agoI dunno why you're getting downvoted. Regulatory capture is a common and well understood phenomenon.
- nickpsecurity 10y agoIt's what Uber and IIRC AirBnb ran into constantly. For Uber, it was usually to protect the interests of existing players local politicians supported.
- snuxoll 10y agoTo be fair, Uber is a much better example, Airbnb not so much. Uber is shitty in the way it treats drivers, but the majority don't seem to have an issue with the platform (doesn't excuse their behavior). The housing laws Airbnb is constantly battling with are to protect residents from inflated housing costs, and if Airbnb gets its way it is going to do actual damage compared to the "think of the taxi drivers" silliness that Uber runs into.
- nickpsecurity 10y ago"Uber is a much better example, Airbnb not so much. Uber is shitty in the way it treats drivers, but the majority don't seem to have an issue with the platform (doesn't excuse their behavior). " I'll take that one. Especially "think of the taxi drivers silliness." It's the kind of stuff I'm talking about that's politically motivated.
- ThrustVectoring 10y ago
- wilde 10y agoThis law appears to be widespread. http://compliance.aeproduction.info/wp-content/uploads/2015/07/StateLaws-on-GiftingRebating-and-Inducements2.pdf http://compliance.aeproduction.info/wp-content/uploads/2015/...
- jhspaybar 10y agoAs a licensed insurance agent and tech person working in insurance, this sort of law is common and is a big part of the ethics portion of the licensing exam. I honestly don't think it applies here, but I could see how it could be justified.
- SilasX 10y agoCould you explain the dynamics here? What dangerous behavior is this prohibiting, and why? What's the "nightmare scenario"? Edit: Here's an article on the same thing happening in Utah, which explains the law and Zenefit's defense: http://beehivestartups.com/blog/utahs-attempt-shutdown-zenefits-highlights-very-troubling-trend/ http://beehivestartups.com/blog/utahs-attempt-shutdown-zenef...
- mrkurt 10y agoMostly it's to prevent brokers from giving customers kickbacks (either pure money or gifts). When a broker is helping people make decisions about what plans to buy, it seems like a reasonable restriction, although I don't think the intent was to prevent what Zenefits is doing.
- stale2002 10y agoKickbacks just means "charging customers less money" and "giving customers a better deal than their competitors" and "competing in the free market". The insurance industry is so messed up that they have made it illegal to give customers good deals and have made it illegal to compete. Imagine that a bunch of companies got together and decided that everyone should increase their prices. In the normal world that would be called illegal monopolistic pricing. In the insurance world, charging people less money and giving consumers a good deal is the illegal thing.
- a_c_s 10y agoKickbacks (especially in the form of gifts) often go to the individuals rather than the company. A broker who gives a 10% discount to a company saves the company money which allows them to get their employees a better plan (or higher profits or whatever). A kickback of steak dinners and free golf for the HR manager is more like a bribe: no benefit accrues to the company itself.
- CGamesPlay 10y agoThis is based on the regulation that brokers can't be better than one another on the basis of price. You can't give "kickbacks" to your customer that make you appear to be a better option. The health insurance companies get the same premium regardless of broker (1), so this is about inter competition between the brokers, not insurers. (1) OK, well in the large group segment you could make an argument that a sufficiently large broker could use that pressure to negotiate better rates with the insurance companies, but I don't know if that's the tack being taken here.
- beambot 10y agoWhy do we need the brokers at all?
- CGamesPlay 10y agoZenefits doesn't want to be an insurance company, they would much rather be a broker. But to actually answer your question, a broker is a tool for the consumer / provider to facilitate sales. If there's a better replacement tool, we don't need brokers. For example, travel agents used to be the best tool to find and purchase flights, but they have been replaced by Kayak and competitors.
- beambot 10y agoI know what brokers ostensibly do. I'm asking: Why do we need healthcare insurance brokers in this day and age? If the answer is "we might not", then entrenched middlemen shouldn't be propped up by outside lobbyists, regulations, or "because, jobs." In fact, you could probably make a real case that middlemen are directly responsible for substantial markup on healthcare insurance costs!
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoYou could make that last case: However, I think a broker is probably the best way to compare different insurance plans when buying from the market instead of through your employer. For example, take 3 insurance shoppers. One has asthma, the second diabetes, and the third has MS. The three have vastly different needs for care and coverage, and the key to matching up the needs is the broker. The need for brokers could theoretically be eliminated, but that would take some government software and regulation and whatnot to get done.
- Stryder 10y agoZenefits had their fuck-ups and they've been paying their dues and righting their wrongs. This feels a bit much. Kicking people when they're down is just bad karma.
- Esdraelon 10y agoThree capitalist pigs were sitting in a jail cell in glorious Soviet Russia. They were discussing their plight, and how they might be better re-educated for the benefit of the proletariat, when they got onto the topic of their incarceration. The first says, "I sold my goods for more than my competitors, and was found guilty of price gouging " The second says, "Well, I sold mine for less, and was accused of dumping." To which the last responded, "And I sold mine for the same as everyone else, and I sit here for collusion!"
- BuuQu9hu 10y agoI wonder if this could affect open source in some way.
- wwalser 10y agoThe top comment in this tread says: "Why can't businesses get free services off the fat of VC capital?" Perhaps an explanation of Zenefits' business model is in order. The explanation of it's software being free is and has always been that they don't make money from the software but from the brokerage fees from insurance which is sold through the software. Think of it like Expedia, they doesn't charge you for flight search and booking software. They make money as a "broker" for the sell of flights. Without any data, I can't nor could a government entity, say whether or not Zenefits is "dumping" using VC money. Zenefits have had their missteps and have paid for them. This case though feels like pure protectionism of existing players. Again, I'm saying that absent the data. Maybe, this seems unlikely, running the business actually does take more money than could potentially be made from brokerage fees. A reasonable measure, in my mind, could be a look at their average(mean) customer lifetime value. All new customers are going to be negative (cost of acquisition being fairly high for a sales driven company) but over time it should recover unless the average customer churns quickly. VC dollars _should_ reasonably be spent on increasing up front spend in order to acquire customers more quickly. If Zenefits have increased that spending so dramatically that the average customer isn't profitable then perhaps it should count as dumping.
- chime 10y agoZenefits should show a counter on their site to each logged in user: "Get the state law changed and we will refund you the $24,545 you paid us so far." Let a few hundred thousand businesses see that amount in their dashboard and see if it affects the support of the law.
- Animats 10y ago"As part of its free software offer, Zenefits provided certain features with a paid commission. To access these premium features, the company required the client to designate Zenefits as its broker of record, then collected the commissions associated with the insurance product sold."[1] Free software is fine with Washington state. Attaching an illegal revenue stream to "free" isn't. [1] https://www.insurance.wa.gov/about-oic/newsroom/news/2016/12-01-2016.html https://www.insurance.wa.gov/about-oic/newsroom/news/2016/12...