3 ms·
Early development of a numerical solution for roots using Newton-Raphson in Fortran IV on a DEC 10. My code was correct, I walked through it manually many times
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
Early development of a numerical solution for roots using Newton-Raphson in Fortran IV on a DEC 10. My code was correct, I walked through it manually many times and I had printed out many variables and yet it never found the roots.
In one of my subroutines I changed the value of a passed in variable. In my code there was a point where I called that subroutine with the value '0' for the variable.
The Fortran compiler was pass-by-reference, so the compiler accommodated me by creating a reference to the constant 0 and passing it to my code. In my subroutine I changed the value of that passed in 'variable'. Since the compiler was using that "constant" elsewhere any conditional that looked for 0 would fail after that point since the value of 0 had changed.
My professor and I only found it after we printed out the machine code generated by the compiler.
- nitrogen 10y agoI guess that might explain the "Have you ever changed the value of 4 accidentally" question from the hacker quiz I found so fascinating as a kid.
- fapjacks 10y agoHey I remember that! Jeez I tried to find ways to increase my score.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoJesus jumped-up Christ on a snowmobile. How does that get through testing? "Passing a number to a subroutine can result in the value of the number being changed"?
- joemi 10y agoOld-timers please correct me if I'm wrong, but modern-style full-coverage tests of code weren't trivial to write or add to fortran projects on dec10's...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoIt was possible to write tests but pass by reference is a "feature" of Fortran IV. A subroutine receives values from the caller through the parameter list; likewise, the subroutine returns values by modifying the variables in the parameter list. Subroutines are invoked in a FORTRAN program as a statement, not an expression. The syntax used is, CALL name(actualParamList) See you modify the parameter to send a return value. Really ancient stuff. And if you're working on hardware that is challenged in not having a "load immediate" instruction for floating point, well you get "optimizations" where the compiler creates what is essentially a pre-initialized variable and uses the address of that when a constant is used.
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoI mean, I don't understand how the compiler got out the door if passing an integer to a subroutine caused inexplicable disasters. It seems like ChuckMcM is saying the equivalent of int increment(int x) { x = x + 1; return x; } int y = increment(2); Would blow up your program's concept of 2, and I can't imagine that being missed before sending it out to users. But I've never used Fortran, so I may be seeing false equivalences to structures and practices in modern languages.
- nikanj 10y agoIn Java, if you have something like void foo(Integer i) { // Putz with reflection, change value stored in i to something else } main() { foo(150); // Nothing special, you just created an autoboxed integer and then alter its value foo(4); // Java pulls you an Integer from the autoboxing cache, and you do indeed accidentally alter the value of 4. }
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoCan you tell me a bit more about reflection and autoboxing, or link to where I can learn myself?