3 ms·
Agreed on all your points. Traditionally the US military, especially the Army, has started out the greenest and learned the fastest. The tragedy of Vietnam is
by hga 17y ago
Agreed on all your points.
Traditionally the US military, especially the Army, has started out the greenest and learned the fastest. The tragedy of Vietnam is that the learning part was short-circuited.
In the case of a "cyberwar", or more likely it being part of a greater action, say "The Battle of the Taiwan Straits" or whatever, things would be messy but it's silly to say that we're either 100% unprepared or sitting ducks.
As for "skin in the game", one analysis I like is that the intensity of the nation's commitment to a war goes like this, based on the three cultural groups that matter in this area:
The Jacksonians are always ready and willing to fight.
Next are the New England Moralists.
And if the Midwestern Pragmatists decide that fighting the enemy is better than continuing to do business with him, well, it's all over (for the enemy).
You can find at least one good essay out there discussing this.
- tptacek 17y agoRegarding whether or not we're sitting ducks: support that argument with evidence. In opposition to your argument, I supply this assertion: our commercial and industrial IT infrastructure is riddled with horrible vulnerabilities. Virtually no penetration test against any entity running critical infrastructure fails.
- hga 17y agoWell ... how about "not all of the country's targets are sitting ducks"? There has been a variety of hardening, in part due to the many attacks that have already been made by a variety of actors. Part of it is that the defense will be active and I have some faith in our ability to respond to and recover from attacks. But what you're saying and most especially implying could well be true, but we won't really know unless and until we're seriously attacked. I do say that we won't start to get serious about this sort of thing only after a particular software bug or vulnerability kills thousands of Americans.
- tptacek 17y agoI just don't know what you're trying to get at here. Are there "targets" that are adequately defended? I'm sure. I have no insight, for instance, into theater military communications. Actually, I have very little insight into DoD or the agencies at all. What I have a fair bit of insight into is the industrial and commercial infrastructure which this article about Clarke is talking about. When Clarke suggests that a foreign actor could cause targeted blackouts, he's simply not wrong. If you want to allude to defenses, I'm going to have to ask you to be specific, because I don't know what you're talking about. Shutting the whole Internet off might not totally remediate the threat.
- hga 17y agoBy defenses I mean people like you and me fixing things, in a less violent way than shutting off the whole Internet. Ad hoc, on the fly ... hard if your part of the grid isn't up ... I'm just saying that in a timetable measured in hours to days the defenses against such an attack won't be entirely static.
- tptacek 17y agoIt often takes months to deploy fixes inside of enterprises for known problems. The idea that we're going to be crazy ninjas dealing with nationally distributed attacks using vectors most people haven't even thought of yet strikes me as deeply unrealistic.
- hga 17y agoBut we as humans work at at least two clock speeds, normal as above and "wartime" literally and figuratively. The Yorktown was repaired in record time after Coral Sea and was available for Midway. I've heard a story about a Bell System machine room fire that zapped a bunch of PDP-11s that did ... 411 service? Something important. Anyway, DECs initial estimate was vastly exceeded in a Maximum Effort that got the system replaced in a short period of time. Now, we'd need some software examples to really support this, it scales very differently than the hardware repairs that I cited above. I can't think of any off hand ... was the Patriot clock drift problem "solved" by frequent enough rebooting? Anyway, my point is that the months problem you refer to is happening in situations that are not existential, right? I don't think you can be confident we'll be as slow when the stakes get really high.