4 ms·
I've been saying for years that AWS has secret DDOS protection. Never confirmed, but I'm pretty sure the basic level is just them admitting that they've always
by jedberg 10y ago
I've been saying for years that AWS has secret DDOS protection. Never confirmed, but I'm pretty sure the basic level is just them admitting that they've always had that service.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoI wondered about this as well. At the very least, AWS provided admin protection during a DDOS attack. Unlike other providers their administration portion of the website was always online and accessible. This was an important and unsung benefit to using AWS.
- kyledrake 10y agoThis is not true. The reality is that they have never had a "secret strat" for dealing with DDoS attacks except to pass the buck to their customers. And the lack of a clearly defined policy, combined with their exorbitant bandwidth costs, has made it far too dangerous to anyone without a massive budget to build services on their infrastructure. They have decided to "resolve" this problem by using it as an opportunity to further gouge their customers on bandwidth (which is already 12x+ more expensive than market rate for IP transit), instead of absorbing it into their existing cost structure. Which still would have meant their bandwidth was overpriced, and still would be way higher than what you can get pretty much everywhere else. For a contrast, OVH provides this protection as an included feature in all of their offerings. Before everyone writes it off as junk in comparison to the glorious AWS black box (AWS is amazing at marketing), bear in mind that the OVH scrubber just took a terabit DDoS attack against it and survived: http://www.securityweek.com/hosting-provider-ovh-hit-1-tbps-ddos-attack http://www.securityweek.com/hosting-provider-ovh-hit-1-tbps-... OVH correctly realizes that the only way to solve this problem is to make sure everybody gets access to it. Otherwise you're just encouraging the democratization of censorship for those without the means to protect themselves against it. I hope the "cloud" providers follow their example.
- breser 10y agoYour comment was addressed in the session on Shield at AWS re:Invent. You were indeed correct they've been doing it for a while.
- Florin_Andrei 10y agoOne obvious thing they've always had is monstrous amounts of bandwidth. That will help with some attacks. But yeah, it's interesting to learn there's a baseline anti-DDoS thing that's on by default.
- Guest98123 10y agoI think so too. In the past, I'd get frequent DDOS attacks against my site, and the dedicated hosts I was with would null route my account, or tell me to take a hike, even though I was paying them $1k+/mo. I switched to AWS 1.5 years ago, and all my DDOS issues magically disappeared overnight.
- richardwhiuk 10y agoMost DOS/DDOS attacks you need to stop as soon as possible, so the kit to do it has to be on the edge, and they don't want to be doing 'who is this for and what plan are they on' provisioned onto all of their edge kit - they may as well just nuke everything that looks bad.