7 ms·
This assumes most people don't want car ownership.
by oblio 10y ago
This assumes most people don't want car ownership.
- XorNot 10y agoI suspect most people don't? Unlike many things you can own, owning a car is a visible blackhole of money. The problem with changing that dynamic is a continuance of convenience: can a clean vehicle be made available to me with nearly the same amount of notice?
- mudetroit 10y ago> owning a car is a visible blackhole of money All shared vehicles do is distribute that same cost though. The owners of the shared fleets aren't going to no recoup those costs. If anything it simply makes the lost money less visible, but still equally present. (Feel free to argue that the actual costs are less with more sharing)
- gumby 10y agoIf you mean "shared vehicles" by the Uber/Lyft model, I agree. If you mean "shared" as in a fleet, well, Daimler Benz probably has a better balance sheet than you do, and can borrow at prime. I feel the same way about housing stock, BTW; the US model of home ownership only works because it is heavily subsidized by the federal government as a longstanding matter of policy (not counting the tax deduction for interest which simply preys upon people's financial ignorance). Almost everyone in the US would be better off it a set of large companies/REITs owned the majority of the housing stock and most people rented.
- rplst8 10y agoThe comment you replied to is the typical "city-dweller" POV. What few people realize is that there are millions of people that live in rural areas where the taxi/uber/shared asset model just does not work.
- mark_edward 10y agoWhy do people pretend that rural people are a majority or even close to it. In the US it's 20% of the population. Edit: No these services aren't suitable for everyone but they're suitable for a huge and growing amount of people, urbanization and civilization are the same thing. ICEs filling cities like Beijing carrying 1-2 people is literally killing people.
- sickbeard 10y agoYou can be a city-dweller and not live in the city core.
- wavefunction 10y agoRural people are incredibly important to the other 80%.
- usrusr 10y agoThe combine harvester is incredibly important for everybody, yet nobody considers them a mainstream mode of transport.
- mark_edward 10y agoWhat does that have to do with the proliferation of self-driving and/or electrified cars? This is a non-sequitur. Do you think tractors and trucks will disappear?
- toomuchtodo 10y agoI would assume people would not be okay tying up five figures of capital in a quickly depreciating asset that sits idle 95% of the time if other options are available (electric rideshare on demand). "17 million new vehicles are sold per year in the US. Assume self driving vehicles replace 25% of those sales, eliminating the need for the rest (just for giggles). That's 12,750,000 vehicles that don't need to be built and sold per year. At the average sales price of a new car ($35K), that's $446,250,000,000 ($446 billion) in loans that don't need to be taken out, or capital that must be committed to purchasing those vehicles, and the same amount of labor that must be expended to repay the loans on those vehicles." I get that these numbers are very hand wavy, but I think they illustrate the scale of the effects of self driving electric vehicle rideshare networks.
- ethbro 10y agoIf people knew what "depreciating asset" meant, they wouldn't be buying new cars en mass.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoDisagree. The US is enourmous, and a car is the only option outside of major metros with public transit. I encourage you to attempt to get everywhere in Tampa, FL, Dallas, TX, or Atlanta, GA without a car.
- CarVac 10y agoNew cars, specifically.
- camiller 10y agoSometimes, depending on the season (fall when dealers are liquidating inventories to make room for the next model year), dealer inventories, etc., the 0.0%-0.9% 5yr financing on a new car makes for a lower monthly payment than the 5.9%-7.9% 4yr rate on a decent, low mileage, used car.
- gumby 10y agoCar ownership is a pain. There's maintenance and a huge financial outlay for an asset that has a very low (typically less than 5%) utilization rate. The interest rate on the car loan which most people have is higher than that! But right now there's not much alternative except in some big cities. Sure there are social reasons for car ownership but then again I see kids less and less interested in the car ecosystem. Hell, the mini I bought in 2009 devoted 40% of its manual to the entertainment system, which I consider a good thing. The shift from cloth production->clothing purchase (many years ago) and from cooking to eating out (more recent) et al demonstrate that people are happy to outsource work when it's convenient and financially beneficial.
- slackstation 10y agoPeople want car ownership; it's built into the culture. The question is at what cost. I have gotten rid of my car because Uber/Lyft and public transport/biking are SO much cheaper than owning a car. On the order of a few hundred dollars a month (if I had gotten a new car and insurance). Additionally, I don't spend time parking or with car maintenance nor do I worry about speeding. In addition, I have more time to make or take phone calls on the road, do some light work on a laptop (with a mobile hotspot) or if I'm feeling tired, just nap. Despite initial concerns, Ubering and Lyfting is simpler, faster, easier and far, far less stressful than driving. This only compounds for longer trips. There is nothing like an hour-long Uber ride where you basically take a nap and wake up when you've reached your destination or just calmly listening to a podcast or watching an online lecture and being able to take notes. Now, that said, I'm becoming an avid outdoors person and I want a vehicle I can take on trips that can stow my gear. I use a car rental service for this (currently Turo) and that works well but, I wish there was a service that let me borrow my friends' cars but, got a daily insurance rider so that their asset would never be at risk and that I would be in compliance with the law in California that requires all drivers to have insurance. Something like what Google's ridesharing is doing but, for car borrowing. Put a per-mile fee on there based on IRS mileage, slap a $5 per rental fee for putting all of this together and boom, you have something that would really revolutionize things.
- Theodores 10y agoMaybe you need to write the app and build the product behind it that lets people insure any vehicle for any journey and any amount of time with the proviso that it is not your vehicle and that the vehicle is otherwise insured and road legal. If the process was no more thought involving than paying for parking. The business logic behind the insurance could be very different, a lot would be known about the journey to be undertaken, the app could be recording what really is happening, with a source of crash sensors and satnav it should be possible to identify what happened in ways current insurance can't do. You could make it so an app has to run during a one-off insurance permit, you could not do that for normal insurance. You could get different rates for different cars that you can borrow, therefore if making a big one-off journey it might pay to borrow the eco-mini-car instead of something flash. Going into town then the sportscar might be worth the higher rate as the journey could be short. So you could end up borrowing different cars. Now if you allow some charge back to the owner 'profit' then people just might have a fair incentive to lend you their vehicle. The app could even tell them how many pennies they are to earn.