4 ms·
I thought that was just me. It has seemed like posts critical of government policy can disappear quickly, but I don't have a comprehensive feel for how posts mo
by TaylorAlexander 10y ago
I thought that was just me. It has seemed like posts critical of government policy can disappear quickly, but I don't have a comprehensive feel for how posts move on HN so it was only ever a feeling.
How can we collect data on the mobility of posts?
I've wondered this on Facebook too. Post something about a robot I made and people love it. Post something about US weapons killing children in Yemen and no one reacts or comments.
How much of that is the fact that people just don't respond well to those things and how much of that is the algorithm hiding the post for some reason?
How can we monitor moderated sites like this? What are the metrics we could collect?
- Jerry2 10y agoI've noticed the exact same thing. Posts critical of gov are either flagged or they drop to page 4 or 5 with 50+ upvotes in an hour. Then there are posts that get into top 10 position with only 4 upvotes in an hour. Weird. Someone is definitely pushing an agenda.
- grzm 10y agoIt depends on user action. User flags affect submission rankings even before the [flagged] tag appears. There's also a "overheated discussion detector" algorithm that can also depress the rankings of a submission. I think ranking may also be improved depending on the rate of upvotes (besides just quantity), e.g., if a submission gets 4 up-votes in an hour it'll have a higher rank that receiving 4 up-votes over 4 hours. Mods can add weight to a submission as well, but from what I've seen of their public behavior on the site, I suspect they're not using such weight very often.
- Jerry2 10y ago>I think ranking may also be improved depending on the rate of upvotes (besides just quantity), e.g., if a submission gets 4 up-votes in an hour it'll have a higher rank that receiving 4 up-votes over 4 hours. Sure, that's true but go to new submissions page and look at the posts that got 4 votes in 15 minutes. None of them are on the front page let alone in the top 10.
- grzm 10y agoI believe it also has to do with the context of activity of other submissions. Compare the activity of those submissions with the others on the top page. If you believe someone is pushing an agenda, please be explicit about what you mean. Who is it? What agenda are they pushing? Hand-waving vague accusations sound like vague conspiracies: it's "them"! The nefarious "they"! Edit to add: From what I've send there is one agenda that is being pushed: keep the community healthy. Try to keep flame wars, off-topic, and other non-constructive discussion to a minimum. If that happens to conflict with what you'd like to see on HN, then likely yes, there is something nefarious going on.
- Jerry2 10y agoI'm not saying it's nefarious but mods quite often push a story up on the front page with only few votes. I've witnessed it about a dozen times. And given that it happens, they definitely want some stories to be seen. By the definition, that is an agenda -- nefarious or not.
- grzm 10y agoWho is they? What is their agenda? Give me examples! Stacktrace or GTFO! :)
- grzm 10y agoThere's a couple different HN APIs you can use to analyze some of the data: - https://github.com/HackerNews/API https://github.com/HackerNews/API - https://hn.algolia.com/api https://hn.algolia.com/api