3 ms·
I agree that this is a stupid policy, but there is some attempt at logic behind it. Oil production has the problem that increasing in oil production requires s
by btilly 10y ago
I agree that this is a stupid policy, but there is some attempt at logic behind it.
Oil production has the problem that increasing in oil production requires spending money that will only pay off if the price of oil remains high for several years. Cheap producers like Saudi Arabia know this, and so try to make the price fluctuate with enough lows to wipe out expensive oil producers, and enough highs to get rich themselves. More marginal properties would make money, but it is hard to survive the lows.
Therefore government policy that produces an effective price floor encourages the production of otherwise marginal oil. This is effectively a bet that increased tax revenue from future production is worth the risk of that tax guarantee. And in the short run you get an increase in jobs for no actual outlay of resources. Which is a trick any politician can appreciate.
That said, it remains a bad policy. Once implemented, lobbying efforts are virtually guaranteed to expand government support until the public is guaranteed to lose money. Doubly so because oil producers can now play one government off against another in a race to see who can offer more. (Sports teams have mastered that particular game...)
- EGreg 10y agoAnd if they didn't, we might have built a sustainable society faster and invested in sustainable energy sooner. It could have been done in the 80s. I know it's scary to imagine Americans driving on smaller cars and bicycles and public transport like Europeans... but we would survive it :)
- alivelore 10y agoAverage commute time in the us is lower than almost all of europe (https://goo.gl/r8DJqz https://goo.gl/r8DJqz) and public transport not only needs billions in investment to be built but there are very few places where it doesn't run on subsidies. So yeah you're asking americans to a) take longer to get to work b) constantly subsidise a system that will keep on losing money. Based on the political makeup of the country i'd say you can keep on dreamin' :)
- EGreg 10y agoI live in NYC where it is reality :-P
- jmknoll 10y agoCommute times can be misleading. It takes me about an hour to get from my house in downtown Shanghai to my office on the other side of the city. However, this is about 15 minutes of walking and 45 five minutes on the metro. Even though its longer than the US average of 25 minutes, I much prefer this option. Commuting by car is dead time. When I'm on the subway, I can read, send emails, catch up on work. Its also much better for the environment and costs a grand total of $200/year.
- kartan 10y ago> b) constantly subsidise a system that will keep on losing money If you take into account the total cost of car ownership you will see that also is heavily subsidized. From car production to roads, parking spaces, oil production... if the accounting is done properly it is obvious that when you make 100 people travel all together in the same vehicle it is a lot cheaper that using 100 different machines to move that same 100 people. Cost wise it is a no-brainier. I agree with you that lack of political will, and also suburban landscape, are going to make it very difficult for it to happen in the USA.
- JDiculous 10y agoIsn't that what oil futures are designed to hedge against?
- smallnamespace 10y agoYes, this basically socializes the cost of figuring out how to hedge (assuming the state actually hedges, which it probably doesn't), since the intersection of oil producers and prudent users of derivatives is probably rather small...
- clappski 10y agoThat still isn't risk free, a producer could sell some futures contracts and not be able to produce on delivery; then they either have to sell the future on at a below market price (it will be closer to the spot) or purchase oil to make delivery. It only has less risk on the buy side.
- btilly 10y agoYes. But the government has more economic incentives to extend those futures than other participants because they stand to earn money from taxes.
- codecamper 10y agoOr politicians could catch a glimmer of the future & put some tax dollars towards: * battery factories * electric car incentives * open source car sharing / planning services. (get rid of the 30% uber tax meanwhile steering people towards shared services) * carbon taxes it's been said a million times, but may as well keep saying it. it'll fix the problem for good. no more wars. less environmental destruction. Cars would actually be cheaper this way, if you wanted to bother owning one. way less maintenance. car pretty much lasts forever, just swap out the battery pack now & then.
- mulletbum 10y ago"car pretty much lasts forever, just swap out the battery pack now & then." Not in Michigan. You will have far more problems from a car than just battery maintenance.
- mr_overalls 10y agoElectric cars don't have non-zero maintenance aside from the battery, but -- due to the lack of an internal-combustion engine, simplified drive train, and absence of emission-control equipment -- maintenance costs should be considerably lower.