3 ms·
> valuable information is scarce His point is that valuable information is only scarce because of monopolies on that information. If it were allowed to move fr
by majewsky 10y ago
> valuable information is scarce
His point is that valuable information is only scarce because of monopolies on that information. If it were allowed to move freely, it would not be scarce anymore because of zero-cost lossless reproduction.
> Just like you cannot form an 'air monopoly' since it is so abundant.
Information monopolies only work because they were established before information became abundant. And even then, only with government intervention. See, for example, the history of book printing prior and up to the invention of copyright.
> They are creating platforms that enable the creation of valuable information or finding valuable information out of a sea of worthless information.
That doesn't mean their business model can't (or won't) be disrupted. 30 (or even 20) years ago, no one could've imagined a free encyclopedia written by enthusiasts.
> it is useful to incentivize the creation of valuable ideas which is difficult when they are used freely.
There are a lot of people who create valuable ideas which are then used freely. They're called scientists.
- clavalle 10y agoMost impactful scientists are paid. Either they work for a university, hold patents, sell books, speak, consult, or work for private industry. If we expect them to create to the level we currently enjoy, we would be wise not to cut their legs out from under them. In fact, it may be a good idea to figure out how to reward scientists more efficiently so the good ones aren't globe trotting to their consulting or speaking gigs, spending inordinate amount of time writing popular science books, or getting sucked into the trade secret black hole of private industry.