3 ms·
Are Psychiatric Drugs Causing A Rise of Mental Illness in America?
- MichaelGG 17y agoMore people being diagnosed with mental illness doesn't mean there is more mental illness, does it? Social acceptability and understanding has increased since the 50s and 80s, so we should expect to see a lot more mental illness, even if nothing else changed, right? The other points about psych meds making symptoms worse is true - the rx info for Ritalin and so on clearly list severe issues such as psychosis as a side effect. Perhaps the problem lies in patients not receiving proper care and follow up.
- Alex3917 17y agoIf I'm reading it correctly, the article isn't claiming there are more people being diagnosed with mental illness, but rather that there are more people severely enough incapacitated that they can't work.
- gruseom 17y agoThis sounds like an important book. The key point is this: [The scientific literature on psychiatric drugs] is remarkably consistent in the story it tells. Although psychiatric medications may be effective over the short term, they increase the likelihood that a person will become chronically ill over the long term. Most people nowadays think that psychiatry finally established itself on a scientific footing with the biochemical model of mental illness and associated drug treatments. If this guy's right, then the biochemical model and associated drugs are just the latest chapter in a long history of pseudo-scientific barbarism, this time founded on a massive conflict of interest. This part is positively Orwellian: At some later point, however, as the chemical imbalance story repeatedly fell apart, psychiatrists in the research community understood that they were telling a “fib.” I can still remember -- this was the summer of 1998 -- when I questioned a prominent academic psychiatrist about whether the chemical imbalance story was really “true” and he replied by stating that it was a “useful metaphor” that “helped patients understand why they needed to take their medication.”
- pyre 17y agoWhenever I hear about people making claims against the current psychiatric model, I look closely to see if they are associated with the CCHR (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_Commission_on_Human_Rights http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_Commission_on_Human_Ri...). They basically believe that psychiatrists are purposefully poisoning us as part of a campaign of eugenics... Not to say that this guy might not be right, but it triggers my scepticism alarms.
- Alex3917 17y agoIf you read the article the author actually criticizes CCHR. In any event he's not arguing that psych meds shouldn't be used at all, but rather their long term health effects should be taken into consideration.
- maxharris 17y agoDo any of the people that came up with this have any relationship with Scientology? I'm completely serious - Scientologists hate psychiatry and psychiatric drugs. If there's no connection with those nutters, I'm very sorry for having raised the issue at all. But you gotta know these things before you can trust what you're reading.
- gjm11 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Whitaker_%28author%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Whitaker_%28author%29 -- seems like he's OK, though of course it doesn't prove anything.
- gruseom 17y agoFrom the article: Big Pharma and its partners in establishment psychiatry have smartly used Scientology to defuse criticism of their medications. I honestly believe that if Scientology weren't around, then our society could have a much more rational discussion about our drug-based paradigm of care.