6 ms·
TL;DR: The author conflates "capitalism" with state controlled economic systems. The author commits the cardinal philosophical sin of not defining his terms. W
by AndrewKemendo 10y ago
TL;DR: The author conflates "capitalism" with state controlled economic systems.
The author commits the cardinal philosophical sin of not defining his terms. What exactly is "postcapitalism?"
"Capitalism" is simply the description of who owns the means of production (regardless of the good). Namely that individuals without legal means of physical coercion control production rather than a state with the legal means for physical coercion. So anything that is post-capitalism by definition means that production isn't held by individuals - which is the opposite of what the author seems to be advocating for.
Markets exist irrespective of whatever the formal mechanism of trade is sanctioned by the state. So even in the most socialist/communist of systems, there exist markets. It just happens that in those systems the state has the plurality of pricing controls (ie. controlling supply and demand). In fact the more top-down controls there are in a market the more there are non-sanctioned, non-connected markets (black & grey markets as an example).
The author seems to be saying primarily that there is an increasing number of grey and black markets that are forming and being utilized because the official sanctioned markets are "failing." Ok, nothing new here really other than speed and scale.
This is how capitalism works. Markets will clear eventually, and it will probably be really bad for a lot of people. There isn't a "solution" to this. People will need to adapt to the demands of the people around them, as has always been the case.
- rpeden 10y agoI think you assessment of the article is fair. It's not the best piece I've read on this topic, but I found it interesting enough to share on HN. Do you think it's possible we'll get to the point where technology makes labour so cheap that capitalism and markets as we know them now will no longer make sense? With software that already replaces a lot of human labour, and things like 3D printing continually improving, it seems like it's at least possible for us to reach a point where the means of production are so easily available and so dispersed throughout the population that the current system as we know it won't really make sense anymore. So I'm not even sure "postcapitalism" would be the right word to describe it. Things will still be produced, and the idea of markets won't go away. But this new system might not be recognizable to us at all. I often wonder if we can even envision how the transition could happen, because we're so used to reality as it exists for us now. I don't mean to sound like a naive technological utopian. I suspect that something better than what we have now is possible, but the transition, if it happens, will be messy and painful.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoDo you think it's possible we'll get to the point where technology makes labour so cheap that capitalism and markets as we know them now will no longer make sense? The short answer is yes I do - in fact I'm betting on it. The functional problem however is distribution of resource production/demand. A functional market requires that some Agent A has some resource X that they can trade with Agent B for resource Y for some exchange rate. The medium of exchange (currency) is an important aspect to the efficiency of this but is too complicated to factor in to this discussion. If the plurality of Agents do not have a resource that is in demand then they have nothing to trade and thus their optionality is severely limited. For all periods of time individual labor was the default resource that people traded. Either they traded it to themselves in the form of time for output of land (farming for ones self), they traded it for goods from someone with those goods, or they traded it for a medium of exchange (currency). If the "market" effectively drives the price of labor to 0 then the productive input for any Actor basically evaporates. That doesn't mean the market evaporates, it simply means that individuals have no pricing power inside of it. So the idea of your average individual controlling the means of production is put into jeopardy - which I think is what the Author meant to say. Ok, so then what? Well that's when you see projects to redistribute resources to Actors with no pricing power introduced - such as UBI. Such schemes however rely on an increasingly small number of Actors to provide the resources which are then redistributed into the system. The libertarian proponents of such systems assume that the small groups will voluntarily redistribute these resources, which could be the case. Pro-state proponents suggest making the state redistribute the resources - essentially ending the "capitalism" - though the author doesn't suggest this. I think functionally this redistribution at scale is impossible with the human animal. IMO the human desire for unfettered agency is too strong to accept such a construct. I'm not sure what the answer is but I think it's gonna get nastier before it gets better.
- marvin 10y agoHow do you bet on a future like this occurring? It's hard for me to see how to ensure that you get a positive payout if this happens. Owning machines (stocks?) would seem like a sensible bet, but how do you ensure that your part of the capital won't be obsoleted?
- mdpopescu 10y ago> Markets exist irrespective of whatever the formal mechanism of trade is sanctioned by the state. Yep. One of the most amazing things about "1984" is that there is a very visible market, dismissed by Orwell as "the proles". ("Orwell's Revenge" by Peter Huber is a great analysis of 1984.)
- ewzimm 10y agoI think the author's definition of capitalism is close to the Wikipedia version. "Capitalism is an economic system based on private ownership of the means of production and their operation for profit." What postcapitalists generally talk about is a shift in the means of production away from the industrial paradigm, leading to a shift away from private ownership and operation for profit. Private ownership of industrial manufacturing as the basis of economic power shifts to public ownership of information which is shared freely and used to generate value for society as a whole. Since this quotes Marx, we can talk about a shift in a world conceptually defined by a struggle between an owner and a worker class to a world defined by a struggle between intellectual property advocates and advocates of freely shared information. As we've seen, it's very difficult for a working class to overthrow their oppressors without becoming even more oppressive than the oppressors. However, it's much easier for virally-spread free and open source software to overtake proprietary software. The prediction of postcapitalism is that this trend of unobscured information and therefore decentralized information will upend the traditional paradigm of owners and workers. Taken to its extreme, the new working class will become entirely automated and humanity will collectively become owners of it. Just as today, some people in the upper class are better off than others. Those who keep secrets and private keys to valuable information spaces will have advantages over others for the forseeable future, and it's likely that this inequality will pass to machines as well. Eventually, as we move toward the development of artificial general intelligences, it's likely that processing power and access to information will be the most valuable distinguishers of power and influence.
- AndrewKemendo 10y agoHowever, it's much easier for virally-spread free and open source software to overtake proprietary software. I don't think this is true at all. If that were the case GNU Linux would dominate the computing world. Taken to its extreme, the new working class will become entirely automated and humanity will collectively become owners of it. Through what mechanism? I just don't see that happening because individuals don't have that much attention to devote to maintaining such a collective. Someone will always rise to the top to dominate and people will "elect" that person through their behaviors if not explicitly - in effect the same thing that we have today. it's likely that processing power and access to information will be the most valuable distinguishers of power and influence Correct. That just means only a tiny group of people (or trans-human people) will dominate.