2 ms·
I'm gonna pull my hair out. I saw this: >> The researchers analyzed a diverse set of 153 galaxies, and for each one they compared the rotation speed of visible
by phkahler 10y ago
I'm gonna pull my hair out. I saw this:
>> The researchers analyzed a diverse set of 153 galaxies, and for each one they compared the rotation speed of visible matter at any given distance from the galaxy’s center with the amount of visible matter contained within that galactic radius.
That just smelled like they think Keplers law applies (which I've been arguing against for ages) so I googled "radial acceleration relation" and found this paper:
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1609.05917v1.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1609.05917v1.pdf
The opening paragraph is this:
>> The missing mass problem in extragalactic systems is
well established. The observed gravitational potential
cannot be explained by the stars and gas. A classic ex-
ample is that the rotation curves of disk galaxies become
approximately at (V=constant) when they should be
falling in a Keplerian fashion.
To say the gravitational pull at a given radius depends solely on the amount of matter inside that radius is utterly bogus. It is entirely dependent on the distribution of that matter. It is valid if the distribution is a uniform sphere (or a sphere of concentric layers each of uniform density) but that is not the distribution in a galaxy. Likewise, you can ignore all the matter at a larger radius IF it's distributed as a shell (or series of shells) of uniform density - but that is not the case when dealing with rings instead of shells. In my mind, this whole debate has wreaked of a misapplication of the Divergence Theorem from day one. If you thing galactic dynamics have anything to do with Kepler I have a nice bridge to sell you.
- Tloewald 10y agoThe use of Keplerian simply refers to the inverse square law, and if you think the inverse square law isn't involved then maybe I should take that bridge off your hands. You seriously think these guys don't know high school physics?
- phkahler 10y agoThe inverse square law applies to 2-body systems ONLY. I do in fact think they know high school physics and are trying to misapply it. The use of that simple physics can sometimes be used in other systems as a special case of the divergence theorem (third year calculus) IF certain conditions are satisfied. I'm just saying they keep applying by missing a key point in the justification for doing so. Perhaps they're not actually using Kepler, but they sure do keep bringing up his name - and I am correct that it's not OK to use that. As I sometime say - the only dark matter is between the astrophysicists ears. This assumes they're actually using Kepler as a reference for "expected" behavior - some of those guys are smart beyond my comprehension.