4 ms·
> Knowing the source is critical to solve a problem. Right, but I think it's important to separate social science from politics, even though the two are relate
by pron 10y ago
> Knowing the source is critical to solve a problem.
Right, but I think it's important to separate social science from politics, even though the two are related, just as we separate science from technology.
> If cultural pressure is the source, shouldn't it be solved?
I don't think social pressure is the source of power, but just the form it takes, but I agree that in order to change society, those who work to change it would eventually need to address such social pressure. It's just that these things tend to change on their own once material conditions have changed -- but it takes time. It's a little like those who claimed that soldiers would never be able to accept integrated units in the military. Instead of sending psychologists to treat the white soldiers' anxiety, they just integrated the units. After a while, everybody got used to it, and the social pressure and norms changed. Social norms almost invariable (history shows) follow practice, rather than the other way around. Social action therefore strives to change practice, and the norms follow. I am not aware of cases where action can first directly change norms. Sometimes norms change "naturally", due to technological or material changes that are not a result of social action.
> How successful has efforts in the past been in trying to get people that are forced into a situation to also fix the problem of being forced?
Isn't that what revolts are? Revolts fix the problem for both sides.
> Could you define in what way 80% of decisions have been positive for say, men in general in the last 30 years?
First let me say that things have gotten better for women. But the lack of social-security-paid maternity leave and subsidy of child care, still work against women in the US.
You could say that social norms demand that this be the case, but, like I wrote above, I think history shows that social norms are usually reflections of material conditions rather than something deeply ingrained, and also nobody said that power doesn't have any downsides. It's like a king who feels lonely at the top; lonely he may be, but he's still the king.
> Should 8% get equal 50% influence?
No, but it should get 8%.
> In an election, the winning 51% get 100% representation
I'm not interested in fixing the system or in whining about it; just in describing it.
> since the 92% don't intentionally try to mistreat the 8%.
I'm not sure. E.g., in America, the Republican party has been working for years to curtail the voting power of blacks below their share in the population.
> You need intent for discrimination
I don't think so. I can invite people to a party on the roof of my building, which has no elevator. I discriminate against handicapped people without intending to.
> Its only in the last 30 years that the movement changed course.
I strongly disagree with that.
> shouldn't a movement about equality stand for more than that?
I don't know; I know absolutely nothing about political strategy.
> The other side want people to be treated different based on gender and race, but demand that the outcome to be equal.
I disagree; that's not what that side wants at all. That side wants everyone to be treated in a way that recognizes that people are different, but doesn't want the outcome to be the same for every person individually. Nobody is asking that a single, uneducated black mother from Philadelphia be granted a Harvard diploma or get a job as a New York lawyer. They just want the statistical power distribution to be fair. I see no contradiction between this and any previous demands.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- belorn 10y ago> it's important to separate social science from politics If you don't recognize the politics in science, you end up with eugenics and bias in the data. If you separate science from politics, you get decision not anchored in reality. The biggest improvement to government process (a field rarely talk about) in the last 200 years was the cost-benefit analyses. Scientific methods are a core part of government. > It's just that these things tend to change on their own once material conditions have changed Lets structure this a bit, since we have two different theories: is it social values that leads to material conditions, or is it material conditions that leads to social values. If its the first case is true, we should see signs of social values being changed while material conditions lagging behind. The opposite should be true for the second case. I would claim that the case of the solider lacks to mention a critical third-party. Its not that the soldiers themselves that decided to integrated the units. Its an outer force, in this case the military leadership who do not share the same cultural values of the soldiers, and that outer force is what forces a material change for which later results in a cultural acceptance by the soldiers. Take Japan after WW2. Its was not that the Japanese suddenly decided to change their cultural views about Imperial rule. The allies, who did not share the cultural views of those in Japan, imposed a material change (ie, the forced surrender and statement from the emperor). After a time, citizens of japan accepted the new reality and cultural values and norms changed. An other case would be to look at the revolution that created the Soviet Union. People didn't just suddenly decide to create a revolution, and then after a few years have cultural values changed. The cultural values changed much earlier, primarily because of lost wars, which cause people to loose faith in the tsarist autocracy. The process was very slow, and took somewhere between 100 and 50 years, ending with the revolution. At that point, Social norms had already changed, a fact that the Tsar Nicholas II where very aware of. To ground this into current situation with men being more pressured into taking higher paying jobs than women, the government as a third-party would need to basically go in and decide who works where and how much people should get paid, and the government would need to have a different cultural view than the rest of the population. I doubt either requirement could happen, the first because communism had already tried it, the later because a government with different cultural views than the population is unlikely to get voted in. > But the lack of social-security-paid maternity leave and subsidy of child care, still work against women in the US. Is that a positive decision for men? I know that where I live, Sweden, both those things exist and our work market is even more gender segregated that the US work market. If we consider the extreme pressure that the dating site data shows, how much will a few months/year of paid leave change things. Will men start to seek women who can support a family, thus sending social pressure for women to seek higher paying jobs? Will women change their cultural values of seeking men with higher paying jobs? Looking at Sweden, what it did is to silence the false myth that women are a bigger risk to employ than men. It did not change the cultural expectancy that society has on from female and male roles in society. > the Republican party has been working for years to curtail the voting power of blacks There is indeed political efforts to win at all costs and to try prevent voters from voting rather than win them over. I would not go and claim it is anything supported by white men as a group, but rather a fringe behavior by people whose income is based on being an politician. A other word for it would be corruption, buts its not commonly used word for describing such behavior. > I can invite people to a party on the roof of my building, which has no elevator. I discriminate against handicapped people without intending to. There will always be people who are unintentionally discriminating against if we remove intent from discrimination. Claustrophobic people can't use elevators, Acrophobes can't be on the roof, and Agoraphobia don't like open spaces. Its a meaningless term if everything everyone do is unintentionally discrimination towards someone. >> Its only in the last 30 years that the movement changed course. > I strongly disagree with that. I can see the effect in sex segregation. Before it, the trend where going towards less segregation. After it, to more. > That side wants everyone to be treated in a way that recognizes that people are different How is that different from saying that they want people to be treated different? Just because you added the word "recognizes", don't change underlying statement. The story of Rosa Parks isn't how society failed at statistical power distribution where half the time men sat in front and women in the back of the buss, and other half of the time they should have switched places. Such system don't recognizes that people are more alike than different. Recognizing peoples similarity is more important than to recognizes the minute way people are different, and it just happen that I prefer a society that focus on similarities than a society that focus on differences.