4 ms·
> One problem, said Brian Swingle of Harvard and Brandeis universities, who also works in holography, is that Verlinde lacks a concrete model universe like the
by mirimir 10y ago
> One problem, said Brian Swingle of Harvard and Brandeis universities, who also works in holography, is that Verlinde lacks a concrete model universe like the ones researchers can construct in AdS space, giving him more wiggle room for making unproven speculations. “To be fair, we’ve gotten further by working in a more limited context, one which is less relevant for our own gravitational universe,” Swingle said, referring to work in AdS space. “We do need to address universes more like our own, so I hold out some hope that his new paper will provide some additional clues or ideas going forward.”
Woah. How can AdS model universes have less "wiggle room for making unproven speculations"? There is no AdS universe to observe or experiment in. How could speculations in such universes be "proven"? Or rather, disproved?
- simonh 10y agoI think they're talking about mathematical proofs. AdS models are mathematically simpler than the physical universe containing matter, so it's easier to construct mathematical proofs.
- mirimir 10y agoOK. But proofs about mathematical objects are entirely distinct from testable hypotheses about the actual universe. So it seems odd to compare them. OTOH, there is much "theoretical physics" that's not much more grounded in reality than AdS models ;)